Monthly Rentals in Spanish Wells

This was our first trip to Spanish Wells. The beauty of the ocean is breathtaking. We own homes on the ocean in Maine and Florida and the view in Spanish Wells easily tops both of those locations. The cottage was nicely decorated and very clean. The view from the cottage was beautiful. Audrey, the neighbor and cottage caretaker was extremely kind and helpful. She quickly responded to our every need. We truly enjoyed our conversations with her. We would 100% return to this rental. Having said that I will tell you that we have travelled the world and stayed at over 100 Airbnb type rentals. The only downsides that we experienced here, which had nothing to do with the accommodations, were with regard to dining options on Spanish Wells. Compared to other vacations we have taken, the dining options are slim. Especially on Sundays. We didn't want to have to cook on vacation and it was tough at times to find open restaurants. 10/10 for the cottage and 5/10 for island dining.

I had such a lovely stay—exactly what I needed for a relaxing and simple solo trip. The space was clean, peaceful, and felt like a little home away from home. Everything was just as described, and I really appreciated the thoughtful touches. Thank you for creating such a welcoming and restful environment.

There’s a reason Cay Casita has such great ratings! If you’re traveling to Spanish Wells, don’t hesitate to book here. It was perfect for our needs and centrally located.

Our stay at the Tuna Can was nothing short of absolutely amazing! We took a girls weekend trip here, looking for some peace and relaxation and it was exactly that! Suzanne was so helpful with every question I had and so extremely thoughtful! She helped us secure our golf cart rental, taxi/ferry service from the airport and even met us at the dock to bring us to the house! Suzanne has the cutest animal friends ☺️ and her home is truly a retreat in the middle of the most beautiful island I’ve ever experienced! We will be back soon!