House vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Goodyear Lake

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A red house with a modern design is shown from the side, featuring multiple large windows that offer views of the surroundings. A gravel driveway leads to the entrance, with a backdrop of rolling hills visible in the distance.

Home in Canajoharie

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews

2 homes on large private mountain views getaway

Rent these 5 bedroom 4 bath houses for your next vacation. House sits on top of a hill and has breath taking views, amazing sunrises from the master suite and sunsets from the great room. Home has octagon shape great room with open timber ceiling, large indoor fireplace. Very large and great kitchen for your cooking. Studio has a projector style TV 100 plus inches. Red House/game room with additional 3 queen log beds, full kitchen and bathroom, laundry etc. This home has beautiful open timber.

Top guest favorite

A spacious house designed in an A-frame style is set within a lush forest. The exterior features large windows and a wraparound deck, surrounded by tall trees and vibrant greenery, creating a serene atmosphere. A pathway leads through the grass towards the entrance.

Home in North Blenheim

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Think Summer! Hike, Hot Tub, or Relax by the Fire!

Large house perfect for groups & entertaining surrounded by 11 acres near 3 skiing resorts, hiking, state park & more. HUGE WRAP DECK & HOT TUB. 3 Bedrooms & large open loft. Plenty of entertainment space inside & out on 2 floors. New Wood stove, Hi speed WIFI, 2 large TVs, free Prime, Netflix, WII console and plenty of games. Lots to do, day and night inside and out! Beautiful retreat to relax & have fun! Primary and most guests must be over 25 years old,unless family traveling with children.

Top guest favorite

The vintage farmhouse features a classic white exterior with a well-kept front lawn. A welcoming porch is adorned with seating and hanging flower baskets. A flag is displayed on the right side of the building, enhancing the inviting appearance.

Home in Cooperstown

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Two Great Breweries are your neighbors!

A short stroll to Ommegang Brewery or Northway Brewing Hop House feet away (coming soon)! Just a short drive to all other Cooperstown destinations! Clean and inviting 1850's renovated farmhouse with well appointed kitchen, large living and dining rooms, 6 bedrooms and 6 bathrooms. Cable TV in every bedroom and a large screen with cable in the living room, high speed internet and wifi throughout the house, gas fireplace in the living room, built in fireplace in the backyard and a big front porch.

Guest favorite

A bright living area features large windows offering scenic mountain views. Natural light fills the space, highlighting the comfortable leather sofas and wooden coffee table adorned with a decorative runner. Artsy lamps add warmth, creating an inviting environment for relaxation.

Home in Stamford

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Mountain House Family Getaway!

The Mountain House is a 4 bed + loft, 3 bath home located minutes to town, hiking, fishing, and many wedding venues and ski mountains. Tucked away in the peaceful woods, we offer a place to relax and unwind. Start your day while enjoying your morning brew or an evening BBQ on the spacious deck. Kids and adults can enjoy games indoors and out while reconnecting. Visit local farmers markets then prepare in a generous kitchen. Want to hit the slopes Hunter, Plattekill,Windham all 30 mins away.

Superhost

The contemporary cabin is showcased from an exterior angle, featuring a distinct red facade with a green roof. A spacious wrap-around deck with yellow railings is visible, complemented by a landscaped lawn and stone pathway leading to the entrance.

Home in Franklin

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews

Modern cabin in Catskills farm country

Contemporary cabin just outside the quaint village of Franklin in the heart of the West Catskill mountains. We’ve meticulously restored this country cabin with new amenities, a modern aesthetic and blazing fast Fiber optic WiFi. Franklin is an amazing location for exploring the West Catskills and includes many breweries, restaurants, hiking trails and antique shops. We’re 3 miles outside Franklin, 15 minutes from Walton NY and 30 minutes from the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, NY.

Guest favorite

The spacious living room features wood-paneled walls and hardwood flooring. Comfortable couches are arranged around a coffee table, with bright lighting from overhead fans. Large windows allow natural light, and unique artwork adorns the walls, adding character to the inviting space.

Home in Hamden

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

Catskill Retreat

This semi-rural mountainside retreat is the ideal prescription for the city-weary seeking an outdoor adventure or peace and space to relax. In the summer, enjoy local fishing, hiking, bird watching, canoeing, and kayaking during the day and unwind under the stars at night. In the winter you can enjoy skiing, snowmobiling, hunting, and sledding or settle down and sink into the microfiber couches relaxing in front of the wood-burning stove. Located only 2 hours from NYC, Albany, and Syracuse.

Guest favorite

Home in Cooperstown

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

The Ultimate Lake Home. HUGE Floating Trampoline!!

A premiere lake front home on Otsego lake; Cooperstown's perfect multi-family vacation home! 10 minutes to downtown Cooperstown, Hall of Fame and restaurants. 15 minutes to Dreams Park and 30 minutes to All Star Village. Unwind: enjoy the hot tub, sauna and steam bath, relax in the hammock. Take to the lake: swim, fish, boat, kayak. Otsego is the region's BEST lake! Safe and easy car parking for you and your guests. Docks are in June 1st to Sept 1 and sometimes longer.

Superhost

A secluded riverfront cabin surrounded by lush greenery is showcased. The sturdy wooden deck features outdoor seating, overlooking the river. A stone pathway leads visitors towards the entrance, framed by tall trees and vibrant grass, creating a tranquil setting in nature.

Home in Middletown

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Riverfront! Swim, Fish, Hot Tub & Game Barn.

Fish, Tube, Hot tub and Game room! All in one property! This exquisite riverfront home has 3 bedrooms and a sleeping loft. This magical property is 7 acres on the River. Bellayre beach 15 mins and Windham mountain biking 30 mins. Hike, s’mores by the fire, hang out in the 3 season game barn equipped with a pool table and darts, have a drink in the riverside hot tub. 5 mins to retro bowling and restaurants. NO FIRST TIME RENTERS ID VERIFIED/REVIEWED RENTERS ONLY.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the cottage is set against a backdrop of trees, featuring a welcoming porch with white railings. A basketball hoop is visible on a nearby post, and a gentle slope of lush green grass leads up to the home, illuminated by soft sunset tones.

Home in Milford

5 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

At Home Base North

Enjoy the Cooperstown experience while having all the comforts of home. The Baseball Hall of Fame (6 miles), Brewery Ommegang (5.4 miles), and The Cooperstown Dreams Park (0.5 miles) are all conveniently located. Scenic views from the large-covered deck of the rolling hills set on 20 acres. Check out all of the amenities including high speed internet, central air, and a BBQ grill. View our other “Home Base” listings here on Airbnb, all in the vicinity of one another.

Superhost

A charming barn-like structure with blue doors is set against a backdrop of lush greenery and mountains. Bright yellow flowers line the driveway, adding a vibrant touch to the scene. The sky is overcast, creating a serene atmosphere.

Home in Roxbury

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Stunning mountain retreat with fireplace and deck!

Perfect for large groups, this huge light-filled house is a mixture of modernity and classic Catskills charm. Cook meals in the fully stocked kitchen or grill out on the deck. Dine al fresco under the trees or in the bright modern dining/living space, watching the sun set over the mountains. Then relax together in the lodge-like map room with giant stone fireplace. Surrounded by Catskills beauty and minutes from the best ski slopes, farmers markets and hikes.

Top guest favorite

A quaint cottage is partially visible among snow-laden trees. The structure features a green exterior and a red deck, with a warm wooden door contrasting against the winter landscape. Fluffy white snow blankets the ground and branches, creating a serene atmosphere.

Home in Roxbury

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 240 reviews

Charming Cottage on 12 Secluded Acres + Hot Tub

This Catskill cottage is situated on 12 secluded acres with stunning mountain and valley views. The main house features three well-appointed floors with two bedrooms downstairs, a primary bedroom with ensuite on the top floor and a wood burning stove on the main floor. The property also features a separate studio with a large stone patio, fire pit, cedar hot tub, pond, and scenic forest trail beyond. Close to skiing, hiking and golfing!

Guest favorite

Home in Cooperstown

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 395 reviews

Cooperstown Hall of Fame, Dreams Park Baseball

***** From September 1, 2024 to May 31, 2025- Please be sure to add the number of guests staying at the property to get the appropriate pricing. There is an additional fee after 2 guests. *****There is an additional fee for pets. It is a $150 fee per pet per stay. ***** From May 25 to August 29, 2025 Please put in only ONE guest to get the summer pricing. it is a SIX day minimum/maximum stay. Check out time is 9 am in the summer.