Goodyear Lake vacation rentals

Randi is very easy to communicate with - she is super responsive and friendly. The house is close to Colgate- made running back and forth very easy. The house is peaceful, really well stocked with all your kitchen needs plus plenty of towels etc., all very clean, comfortable, neat and uncluttered, and in such a lovely setting, right on the lake. Highly recommend!

Beautiful house and location! We had not planned to stay in upstate NY but glad we did. The lake is beautiful- the house has everything you could need. Close to Cooperstown!

We enjoyed the cottage very much and will definitely consider staying there again when we return to Hamilton! Thank you, Christian!

Very nice home tucked away, was perfect for a private weekend for our group. We will absolutely come back if we are in the area again!

Absolutely loved this house, this lake and surrounding area. The house was ideal for us. We had a full house with 10 guests for our son’s wedding. Could not have been more perfect. Adults loved the house, spa and views. Grandkids fell in love with the lake and dock. (And pet carp!) Rich was very helpful with questions and left clear instructions (and wonderful stories) at the house. We talked about coming back even before we left. Cheers!

Simply beautiful, charming and cozy stay. The waterfall was amazing, it was frozen but I think that made it even more beautiful, its a short hike to the fall and in my 2-day stay I went about 5 times. Even cold plunged in the fall! The wood stove is so toasty and they have an abundance of wood to last all winter. The kitches has literally everything you can think of and you can tell a food lover lives here. There's even binders with tons of recipes that seems to be made throughout decades, super cool. Overall great stay and just what we needed. Highly recommend!

We had a wonderful stay at Heidi's place. The house was immaculate and it was a beautiful setting. Heidi was very responsive and thoughtful to all her guests needs. We will be back.

Paula's house is epic. It is beautiful, large and perfectly equipped for a large group. Plenty of bedrooms to accommodate everyone with very comfortable beds, amazing large kitchen with two ovens, beautiful dining table and very large living room. Spent a weekend celebrating a birthday with friends and we never left! Not to mention the hot tub....

Alex was an excellent host, communicative from start to finish. The house was lovely and perfect for three sets of parents visiting their kids at Colgate. It was comfortable and clean with lots of style and flare and everything you could need in the kitchen. Alex was also very understanding of a spill (tomato sauce on the dining room rug) and our attempts to clean it. A great all around and comfortable experience!

We’ve stayed at Skip’s listings a few times, and it’s been wonderful each stay. Skip is helpful and quick to answer any questions. Andes is the most beautiful town. Highly recommend!

The accommodation was clean and everything we needed was prepared. Eileen was kind and even baked bread for us. We had a wonderful time here, and my parents were especially pleased.

Mary was a very nice, responsive and welcoming host . I would definitely stay at Halcott House again

This is a great place to stay! Felt at home as soon as walked in. All the modern conveniences while maintaining the beautiful history of the house. Travelling with adult kids and friends, plenty of room for everyone. Well appointed kitchen and baths, lots of blankets for an April visit, and the location was perfect for us. Easy walk to Ommegang and easy drive to downtown Cooperstown and several other more local breweries and eateries. We had a blast! Emily was more than accommodating with quick responses and flexibility, really appreciate her as a host. We look forward to our next visit, which will be a little later in the season so we can take advantage of the outdoor area and front porch. Can't wait!

A quiet and private area. A neighbor on one side but never heard or seen anybody. Plenty of room for the dogs to run and hiking trails across the street. It is well stocked but does need some updating.

We had an incredible weekend at Vanda’s home. It was even more spacious and beautiful than the photos and very comfortably accommodated our group of 13. We all fit at the long dining table and there were plenty of beds. The upstairs living room was our main hangout spot, it was cozy (multiple stoves in the house and a beautiful fireplace) and the view through the windows was stunning. And it was very warm despite the cold weather outside! The kitchen had everything you’d need as well. We didn’t have to go anywhere! I would definitely emphasize cars with 4wd for winter visits, the driveway was steep and the snow/freezing rain we got made it difficult even with 4wd. Our hosts kindly sent someone to plow for us, recommended someone to help us tow a car out that got stuck at the bottom of the driveway, and were very flexible and responsive. Be prepared for winter conditions but it’s worth the trip! Overall our stay was really awesome, I’d highly recommend this house for large groups.

The home was very attractive and comfortable. There is a great flow between the entry, living areas, kitchen, bedrooms, etc. We loved the decor and plants and special touches. And the access to outdoors was amazing. Such beautiful and fabulous views.

Mario and Holly were truly exceptional hosts! probably the best we've ever had. They ensured we had everything we needed , they were accommodating and flexible. They made fires for us both nights we stayed there ,and even tended to fire when we asked for help. They went above and beyond!! the place was gorgeous, comfortable, spacious and perfect for us ....it had everything and I mean everything you could think and if we needed anything Mario and Holly were on it , in seconds ....from the lovely grounds, to the chickens and beautiful dogs on the property this place is truly a gem, do yourself the favor and book this place , you don't regret it.... we will most definitely be back to enjoy this luxury RV...thank you , thank you Mario and Holly , you truly made our trip so momentous! Glenda and Jess

Beautiful lakefront home that was very clean and accessible to the town of Hamilton. Perfect for a group.

Great for Colgate parents! Cozy and cute.

Loved the lake house. Very clean. 2 outside decks with beautiful views. rowboat and kayak for the lake. Fire pit with fire wood available. The house was great and would definitely rent again!

Our favorite place to go in New York. We love that the cabin has everything we need and is right on the lake. Our entire family enjoys this experience and look forward to coming back every year!!!

We had a good time on the Beaver Kill. It's a beautiful location and a short drive to both the West and East Branch of the Delaware rivers. Unfortunately, the water levels were way down due to a lack of rain which made the fishing on the Beaver Kill challenging but we did catch a couple on it and the flows were normal on both the Delawares. Good time!

We had an absolutely amazing stay at this Airbnb! The place was fantastic, and the instructions and tips provided were incredibly useful. The kindness of the owner truly stood out, making our holiday feel special and memorable. One of the highlights was the cozy evenings we spent playing the board games provided. The kitchen was well-stocked with all the basics, which made cooking meals together a breeze. We also appreciated the pellets for the stove, which kept the house warm and inviting. We were especially touched to find the table set for dinner when we arrived late. It was such a thoughtful gesture that made us feel immediately welcome and at home. Ivan went above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed, even recommending some great local restaurants and hiking trails. Their thoughtfulness made us feel right at home. We definitely recommend this place and are already planning our next visit. It was the perfect spot for a family getaway, and we can't wait to return!

house is beautiful and worked great for our group of 11 (kids from small to big and 4 adults. The air mattresses and bunk beds worked well and the loft with ladder was big hit with the kids. We drove up in two electric cars so the outdoor outlets near the parking were a big help in getting some charge for driving around the area and getting back home. Fabio was super responsive to our questions and replied within minutes every time we asked anything which is extremely helpful in planning. We will definitely consider the house again for future trips.