Vacation rentals with lake access in Goodyear Lake

Great place on the lake with fun and simple touches that made the week unforgettable!

We were there only for a short period. We all wanted to stay longer. The house and the location is stunning and welcoming. We will definitely be back for a longer stay. Thank you Veronica. You have an amazing place. We came a long way from Brisbane Australia to experience the unique hospitality.

Very beautiful and peaceful location. Was perfect for what we were looking for.

This is a wonderful place for gathering with friends, especially in spring and summer when you can enjoy the beautiful lake views. Winter offers a completely different charm, perfect if you appreciate a peaceful atmosphere. Marlaina is a thoughtful host who provided us with many helpful tips before our stay. During our visit, she always responded promptly to messages, ensuring smooth communication. If given the chance, we would love to come back and experience it in a different season.

Thank you for your excellent hospitality, we had a great experience.....

Simply beautiful, charming and cozy stay. The waterfall was amazing, it was frozen but I think that made it even more beautiful, its a short hike to the fall and in my 2-day stay I went about 5 times. Even cold plunged in the fall! The wood stove is so toasty and they have an abundance of wood to last all winter. The kitches has literally everything you can think of and you can tell a food lover lives here. There's even binders with tons of recipes that seems to be made throughout decades, super cool. Overall great stay and just what we needed. Highly recommend!

Paula was an excellent host. The house was huge and had plenty of space for all guests. The basement was great for the kids to have their own space and the location to Belleayre was perfect. Thanks for a great weekend!

my second time staying here. very nice place right on the water. very clean and comfortable.

My wife and I stayed here last year for the first time and we came back again this year because we really liked this place. The hosts were friendly and accommodating and made us feel welcome. The place was clean and well kept and the 3 bedrooms gave us more than enough space for our needs. They even let our cat stay here which most places won't allow. We really liked the location, the park like property, and being within walking distance to the town pool and the local deli. Thank you again Mustafa and Olena for a wonderful stay!

Great place near Cooperstown for Baseball Hall of Fame visit and overnight stop. Many thoughtful touches. Very cute decor!

The carriage house was beautiful and well appointed. Every inch was spotless and clean! It was so fun to visit all the farm animals, cats, dogs and the silly emu. Jemma is the most gracious and accommodating host. We had farm fresh free range eggs whenever we wanted. The farm was maybe 20 minutes from Cooperstown on a quiet road tucked up in the foothills. If you are looking for a relaxing quiet place to stay in upper state New York I highly recommend this.

Francine and Vince were wonderful hosts. They went out of their way to make us feel comfortable and provided many suggestions for local places to visit. The location was perfect for us since we were in town to watch our son play baseball. We were close to both All-Star Village and Dreams, which was perfect. The lake was also beautiful. My husband and I had a great time during our stay.

The apartment was located in a great area and was walkable to downtown and the restaurants. Once we arrived, we didn't have to move the car.

Kathi was an awesome host and the place was so adorable ! 10/10 would stay there again 🤗

I was looking for a very autumnal place to rest with my family for my husband’s birthday I invited my friends to accompany us all they loved the location the landscape the super clean cosy spacious house

Wesley was a phenomenal host, beautiful home, extremely clean and comfortable! He checked in with us, making sure all was well during a snowfall, and offering a generator if the power were to go out! The kitchen was well equipped, the beds were comfortable and there were many other little extras like games, snacks, some drinks and all the cleaning supplies you might need. If we ever visit Cooperstown again, I would definitely stay at Wesley’s house a second time! Thank you for making our stay great!

This place was such a gem. The furnishings inside were so arty and tasteful, and felt like an incredibly cozy cabin. The kitchen and fridge were well stocked with supplies and utensils, and the renovated interiors especially the bathroom were highly appreciated.

Incredible location right on the lake and within a short drive to Cooperstown. Comfortable and cozy and the views are priceless. We enjoyed drinking coffee on the porch watching the sunrise while relaxing by the fire pit as the moon rose over the lake. The home had comfortable furniture and beds. The kitchen was beautiful with all the amenities. Nothing was lacking. There was even firewood provided for the firepit. The town of Cooperstown is like being transported back in time immersed with baseball nostalgia with cool shops and scrumptious dining. The hiking at Glimmerglass State Park was nice too. We had an absolute wonderful time and plan to return. Thanks Michele for allowing us to stay at your amazing lakeside home.

The Pondhouse was like a fairytale cottage. Denise and Andrea were kind and attentive, and we enjoyed a wonderful idyllic stay. Hope to visit again sometime!

We had a nice time at Alexandra's house. It was comfortable and matched the description correctly. She was always available to answer any question.

We had a lovely stay at Sandy’s cabin! It was spacious, bright, peaceful, relaxing, and well equipped. We were able to enjoy sunrise over the water while drinking coffee each morning before venturing out to wineries and Cooperstown. It was a perfect balance! Sandy was a good communicator and was always available for questions and recommendations. She asked our permission to have someone stop over to repair the fireplace during our stay- she was receptive when we declined for him to come in the morning and helped coordinate the repairs for while we were out for the day. We were surprised to find the cabin located quite close to neighboring cabins, but all the neighbors were friendly and quiet so it made no difference to us. We enjoyed our weekend thoroughly!

I rented this house for my grooms folks at my wedding. It was such a relaxing place to come back to after all the stresses of planning and participating in a wedding, and my entire group enjoyed it immensely. Myles was incredibly helpful and a great host. Highly recommended!