Beachfront vacation rentals in Rye Beach

Peter's property was the IDEAL HOME BASE for my exploration of western Connecticut. The home was extremely clean and tidy, mattresses were very comfortable, linens and towels were of nice quality, the kitchen was well equipped, and the yard was safe and easily accessible for my dogs. I truly felt like Peter's guest when I saw ground coffee in the cupboard, ample silverware, extra paper towels, hand soap, new kitchen sponges, and high end fragrance diffusers. After a long day of travel, it was nice to relax without having to clean the home. I was impressed by how quiet this neighborhood was considering how closely set the homes are to one another and how many year-round families live in the area. It's truly a pedestrian neighborhood with miles of sidewalks for relaxed walking. The gem is proximity to the lovely marina and beach. Peter was an excellent host! He offered many recommendations during my stay and was always quick to respond despite being on vacation himself.

Rob was very responsive to all emails and texts and all the instructions for checking in/checking out were very clear. House was exactly as advertised. Easy to get to beach and town. We had a really nice stay.

Ritestay was a great place. We didn’t spend much time there because we were there to see our daughter. Would be perfect in the summer!!

Great place to stay close to all the things you’d love to do if you’re a person that loves sights and places to eat. Easy to get too!

Jennifer’s place is one of the nicest Airbnbs that I have stayed at - quiet, clean, comfortable and I love the location near restaurants and the beach. I also appreciated the quick and friendly communications with Jennifer. Looking forward to staying here on future visits!

My family and I had a great time, our host were very welcoming.

We really enjoyed staying here. The place was super clean and orderly. Its a small home but it has a great open kitchen / sitting area that all 6 of us were comfortably able to hang out in, eat and chat. Cute neighborhood with a nice beach walking area just down the street. And it was close to the family we were there to visit - perfect for us. Quick responses from Paul and Sean to all of our questions also.

Perfect place to unwind and relax, we really enjoyed accessing the sauna and the spectacular views! We also took their canoe out on the lake for a beautiful paddle around, and encountered some baby foxes playing around just as we pulled out of the driveway on the way out of town! All in all a magical time, and will definitely be back. 😊

The place matched the description perfectly and much more spacious than what one usually finds for a single bed/bath apartment. I enjoyed the stay and would return again. For me it was a perfect place to accommodate overflow thanksgiving guests over the holiday.

Good price and clean area

Hidden gem!!! Shhhh don’t tell anyone this place was fabulous and I want to stay the whole summer! Nothing bets fire island and this house was the perfect retreat!!! Beautiful, spotless and well put together! Loved it! Perfect for a family or friends get away!!! Hosts were responsive and friendly as well. Close to beach and great to a have a pool for part of the day! Great location walkable/bikable to Seaview, Ocean Beach and Ocean Bay Park for dinner was a breeze! A must!

We had such an incredible stay here! The home was beautiful, communication was excellent, check in was easy, and an early drop off of our bags was accommodated. Highly recommend and would love to return next year!

The location was great, so close to the beach. Everything was comfortable and clean. David gave us great information and instructions. Would definitely stay here again.

Best Airbnb in Fire Island! The house was perfectly situated less than a block from the beach and a 5 minute walk from the main street of restaurants and shops. The house was clean and had everything we needed for our family of five. The back patio was great. The house was clean and spacious. Dave was awesome and really went above and beyond to accommodate us and ensure we had a great stay. Overall great experience. We would stay here again anytime!

We had a wonderfully, relaxing and inspiring stay. We left feeling inspired, renewed and hopeful to return. The home was perfect for our family of 6, thank you for sharing this wonderful space with us!

This place is ok if your on a budget. The area is worth a million dollars but the motel was a motel. Although the staff and other people were very friendly. It felt very very safe there. Lots of kids for my kids to play with and a pool. Id coke back for the beach.

Absolutely beautiful! Clean, quiet and comfortable with a million dollar view of the Atlantic!

The house is great. Plenty of room. Close to beach and bay. The market is a short 1 minute walk. The beach is a 2 minute walk. Chairs, umbrellas and beach cart are waiting for use. Great place. Greg and Sandra were very responsive. Looking forward to next year.

Wow!!! Absolutely Amazing! This was our 1st Fall Girls Trip 17-20Nov2024 & We LOVED your home! Whoever decorated this house deserves 10 ⭐️⭐️s!! …You out did yourself!!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! Very Peaceful/Relaxing Stay💕 We hated to leave💕

Eglantine was a very responsive host! She answered immediately with whatever question I had and also very helpful. The binder provided also helped out a ton. There was a slight hiccup with the refrigerator turning off while we were away and we had to throw away some of our perishables because the internal temp of the fridge reach 84 degrees, but Eglantine responded right away when we contacted her about the issue.

We needed a family friendly place for Easter weekend close to where my nephew is located and Jennifer's place was perfect! The kitchen, dining and living rooms were not only spacious enough for the 8 guests we were also able to include my nephew and his family for a holiday meal. The home's layout provided ample privacy for 3 generations to enjoy without feeling on top of each other, the furnishings were comfortable both indoor and out, with great selection of games for a variety of ages and was spotless to boot!

Great location on wide, beautiful, private beach! Lots of outdoor space on beach and patio with grill for BBQ. Kayaks and SUPs were at provided, too. House is surprisingly spacious with seating for many in living room and dining table. Kitchen is large and supplied with basics needed for stay. Primary bedroom is huge and all the beds are very comfortable! Jillian was great with communication. Had a great time with our family spending days on beach, grilling dinner and bonfires at night!

Christina’s place is a lovely cottage by the marina and walkable into town. The main loft bedroom and sitting area is spacious and comfortable. We stayed for the holiday with our adult daughter and we were all comfortable and cozy. She had her own bedroom on the main floor. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay while we visited our family over the holiday.

As soon as we walked inside, my wife said, “We're coming back; next time, it'll be for longer than two nights.” The house was beautiful both inside and out and very tastefully furnished. Every amenity you needed to make your stay comfy was provided. The short trip to Midtown Manhattan was the icing on the cake for us—we got to spend a long, tiring day in the city and only had a short drive home. Our host responded to our texts almost immediately, and all instructions were clear and concise. Snacks and bottled water were also placed on the kitchen counter for us. We're coming back, and it'll surely be for longer.