House vacation rentals in Lake Montauk

Joe's place was perfect for a girl's trip with two 1 year olds. The house was beautiful and had so much personality and warmth. The area was super private and quiet surrounded by nature. Joe was very informative about check in process and recommendations were plentiful.

I stayed at Ashton's place by myself on a visit to see my parents, who also live in Springs. It was everything I could have hoped for. So peaceful, and such a beautiful space. Amazing high ceilings and natural light. The yard is gorgeous, so I can only imagine how lovely it is when the weather is warm. Ashton himself is very responsive and accommodating. I was sad to leave!

Our family enjoyed a wonderful post- Christmas getaway at Jennifer’s beautiful home. The house is fabulous - well- located, pristine , beautifully decorated and well-stocked. It was relaxing and perfect. We did not have much need to reach out (everything was effortless) but when we did, Jennifer was very responsive and helpful. Highly recommend!

Dorina’s home was the calm, peaceful reprieve from the city we were looking for. Her home was so comfortable and she went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed. The backyard was a little oasis with a large pool (with floats!), several (6 I think) lounger chairs, two 6 top tables in different areas and a functioning grill. We spent most of our time here! Dorina was fast to respond, helpful with recommendations and overall what you hope to have in a host. We would definitely come back to Dorina’s home!

I had an amazing experience staying at this Airbnb! Luz, the main host, was absolutely wonderful—so kind, welcoming, and incredibly helpful throughout my stay. She went above and beyond to make sure I had everything I needed and even took the time to recommend some great local spots to visit. Her hospitality truly made this stay special. David was also fantastic so professional and accommodating. He made everything so easy, from check-in to answering any questions I had during my stay. It’s clear he takes pride in ensuring guests have a great experience. The space was spotless, beautifully decorated, and just as described in the listing. It felt so cozy and inviting, and the little details, like the complimentary snacks and toiletries, made all the difference. The location was also perfect. I couldn’t have asked for a better stay. Luz and David are a fantastic team. I highly recommend this Airbnb to anyone looking for a comfortable, welcoming, and enjoyable experience.

House is well represented. Spacious, very clean, and great location. Good for families or groups of friends.

Marks home was beautiful, peaceful and near to so many great areas. The pool and backyard were wonderful and relaxing. We loved it! Highly recommend!

Perfect location for Westerly beaches, the beach pass was very useful, quick drive to the waves. Pool was great, and the house is very well equipped with outdoor/indoor games and beach items. Wonderful spot for family in the summer, outdoor patio was perfect for enjoying the summer weather.

I don’t say this often but the house was even more perfect in person. So cute with great amenities. The hosts were amazing. The area has so much to do and all so close ! Can’t say enough good things!

My main search was for a pet friendly rental so I could invite friends with a senior golden retriever. And secondly I wanted to be near the ocean. Having lived on Cape Cod for 25 years, I moved back to Connecticut a year ago after the passing of my wife. But the call of the ocean never fades and this rental was steps from East Beach. My stay was in February and the weather wasn't the best, but beach walks are always best when the only footsteps in the sand are your own. The rental was very accommodating with 3 bedrooms, a spacious living area and large, fully equipped kitchen. Plenty of outdoor seating is also included. Melissa was very attentive and always responded quickly when needed. I definitely recommend this rental for a peaceful adult retreat or for a full family vacation. Kids will love it with the big yard and kayaks available. Enjoy, John

The place was perfect! We had a wonderful girls weekend. Beds were super comfortable, place was spotless and beautifully decorated and quaint! Super easy walk to town and Jillian was a great host with prompt response. We will definitely book again! Thank you Jillian

Lovely, well kept and comfortably furnished. This home has everything you need for a comfortable stay. Owner is helpful and very responsive. Highly recommened!

We had such a wonderful stay here over New Years. Like many other reviews have stated, pictures do not do this home justice. It’s so much larger and more spread out than we expected. Perfect layout for two couples where we each felt like we had our own place, with plenty of cozy spaces to hang out too. The kitchen is SO well equipped for anything and everything. Beds and sofas were super comfortable and the we loved all of the charming touches of this historical home. The location is fantastic too. Walking distance to everything you could need and a quick drive to so many beautiful areas. I can imagine spending hours in the backyard when the weather is warmer too!

Our group has stayed at Patti's place twice a year for a number of years now. She has always been gracious & helpful, with a nice note and home baked cookies greeting our arrival! The location is quiet and peaceful, right on the beach, which is conducive to our desire for rest and reflection.

A lovely cottage on a quiet street (at least in the fall!). The interior is just beautiful with all the wood floors, walls, ceilings. The kitchen was - unusual! Clearly they had to retrofit an old home to accommodate modern appliances, but all worked well.

Kait was super helpful! She texted me a few days prior mentioning we could check in early! I have never had that happen before! The house was stunning, comfortable beds, well maintained and great location. We forgot a jewelry bag at the house and she sent a photo and arranged for our family members near by to pick it up. Highly recommend!!!

We had a wonderful stay. Cute and comfortable house in an amazing location. Very comfortable for a family of 4.

Erika's East Hampton home was absolutely perfect. She kindly accommodated our same-day reservation for our last-minute anniversary weekend getaway. It was much more space than we needed but honestly, it was reasonably priced for the off-season and had everything we were looking for: a peaceful location, close to amenities, beautiful decor, and a hot tub. The weather was lovely this weekend so we were even able to use the beach pass to sit on the beach and play board games. The space itself was beautiful and cozy, we really felt at home. We're already planning to come back next summer!

Mike is a great host with helpful recommendations and plenty of advice. The house is amazing. Well located, calm, clean and so convenient. The pool is huge and very deep. Everything is perfect. Felt like at home. We will be back

Great stay! House was exactly as described / in photos. Hosts were extremely responsive and easy to communicate with.

Carrie’s house is better than in the pics. The yard makes the place private and quiet (a small refuge near the beach). The rooms were nice, spacious and clean. The kitchen was well equipped! The outdoor shower actually had both cold and hot water. It is a great place. Carrie responds almost immediately to any inquiries or questions! The home is a seven minute walk from the beach and is a great place to spend the week or weekend!! Remember: Bring your own towels and sheets (not provided: Carrie sends reminders about this as well).

The house and area were ideal. I had moved from the area the year before I rented Melissa’s home . My partner and I lived just a mile and 1/2 from the rental. He passed away and this was my first time back on the North Fork. Having lived in the area over 30 years it was great to be back. Melissa’s home was perfect close to all my friends and my partner’s family. The house was ideal with 3 levels it was perfectly suited for me and my two dogs to have our space and my two housemates had their own space. I look forward to possibly renting her home next year as well.

Host is very friendly and polite. she responds to your calls and texts whenever we do, my kid 1 year she has so many things to play in the house and well spent

We must have passed the residence hundreds of times going out Montauk over the past 40 years. What a hidden gem. We were so fortunate to have the opportunity to stay at this location. The home was very well appointed, tidy and clean. What a gem of a home, even in the off season. We would love to return.