House vacation rentals in Tioga County

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Tioga County

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

The home is nestled among tall trees in a serene forest setting. It features a spacious deck that extends outward, providing a connection to nature. Large windows allow for ample natural light, and a screened-in porch offers a comfortable outdoor space.

Home in Ithaca

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 68 reviews

Forest House

Enjoy a quiet forest retreat while still being in a beautiful family neighborhood. Perfect to rest or work from home and/or explore everything the region has to offer. Roast s’mores at the custom stone fire pit overlooking Buttermilk Creek. Explore the beautiful 10 acre woods and enjoy the secluded picnic table. Soak in the hot tub while taking in the sounds of the forest. 5 min to Ithaca College, 7 min to downtown Ithaca, 10 minutes to Cornell. Bathrooms update April 2025: new pictures pending.

Guest favorite

Home in Brooktondale

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

The Homestead-One of Ithaca's Best!

Large spacious private vacation or business rental. Nine miles from Ithaca College and 15 minutes from downtown Ithaca, this property is located close to everything yet just far enough out of town for complete privacy. The spacious living space sleeps up to six while the yard and campfire area are large enough for football or to play Frisbee. Surrounded by forests and rolling hills, the view is spectacular. A trailhead for the Fingerlakes trail is within walking distance from the rental.

Guest favorite

Home in Owego

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 167 reviews

Horse Farm House: 200 Acres & Farm Fun & Hiking

This 2 bedroom Farm House unit is on a beautiful 200acres. Enjoy your safe, quiet home away from home! Farm manager lives in upstairs unit. Separate entrances. No shared spaces (duplex house) •Great for! Hiking,Photography,Stargazing, Meditation & Weddings. •Enjoy seeing Cows,Horses,Ducks & Goats! •Nearby; Golf course, Horseback riding, Casino, Antique stores, farmers market, RiverFront restaurants & more! Notice: NO HUNTING allowed on this property Barn access is for farm tours only!

Top guest favorite

Home in Ithaca

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Picturesque, Rural Ithaca; just 7min from downtown

Idyllic pastoral setting w/ valley and distant lake views. This 2nd story carriage house w/wrap-around deck & fire pit is the perfect place to relax & unwind! Away from the hustle & bustle of the city, yet close to everything Ithaca has to offer. Beautifully updated, Sleeps 6, full kitchen, dining for 6, fireplace, 3 bedrooms, 2 baths. Washer/Dryer, Dishwasher, A/C. 5 min to Ithaca College. 8 min to Buttermilk Falls. 10 min to Cornell. 15 min to Cayuga Lake. 20 min to Ithaca Airport.

Top guest favorite

A lush display of vibrant purple petunias is surrounded by greenery, creating a colorful focal point in the garden. A birdhouse and a decorative stone feature are visible nearby, contributing to the natural beauty of the outdoor space.

Home in Nichols

5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

1850’s renovated farmhouse close to Tioga Downs

This remodeled farmhouse has great amenities. The bedrooms feature a king bed, queen bed, and twin beds ensuring a good night's sleep for all guests. The 2.5 bathrooms come equipped with toiletries and a soaking tub for added relaxation. Outside, immerse yourself in the hot tub, play a game of ping pong or corn hole or just relax by the outdoor fire pit. There are 5 restaurants within walking distance and the excitement of Tioga Downs Racetrack and Casino just a 5 minute drive away.

Top guest favorite

Home in Ithaca

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 210 reviews

Ithaca Music-lovers Barn

The barn is a cozy and unique space, situated on 27 acres of meadow and forest with a pond for swimming, fishing, and ice skating, depending on the season. There is no highway noise on the dirt road, and the stars shine brightly on clear nights, giving the place a true country feel, yet it’s still only a five minute drive from downtown Ithaca, Ithaca College, and Cornell University. Feel free to enjoy and play our piano, any stringed instruments, and extensive record collection!

Top guest favorite

A serene pond is surrounded by lush greenery, reflecting the charming custom home in the background. The building features multiple windows and a porch, harmonizing with the peaceful park-like setting.

Home in Owego

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Private & Peaceful custom home yet close to town.

Beautiful custom home--only 2.5 miles from our charming village. ~3 miles from the highway. In pizza delivery range! Peaceful, park-like setting. Pond, streams, woods, fire pit. Indoor/Outdoor activities. Ping pong, hiking, swimming, yard games, fishing (bring a pole), sledding, and more. Wonderful friends & family spot to make great memories. Peep stunning sunrise, sunset, star, leaf views. Many cool nearby attractions for adults and kids. Ithaca/Finger Lakes gorges~30 miles.

Top guest favorite

A serene landscape features a calm pond reflecting a colorful sunset sky. A small guest house is visible on the opposite shore, surrounded by lush greenery and trees. The tranquil scene captures the natural beauty of the area.

Home in Newark Valley

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 289 reviews

Private Scenic Retreat

The entire place is yours to enjoy! Our guest house is located on a dead-end road five minutes from the town of Newark Valley and only 30 minutes from Binghamton, Cortland, and Ithaca Included is a kitchen with open common area, two bedrooms, full bath and washer/dryer within living area. A farm setting is viewable from the common area and attached deck. There is a 2 acre pond and miles of scenic trails spread over 250+ acres, with sights as far as Pennsylvania!

Top guest favorite

The charming exterior of the home features a bright yellow front door, surrounded by white siding and lush greenery. Pink flowers bloom prominently in the foreground, adding a touch of color to the inviting entrance.

Home in Brooktondale

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

The Trestle House

Explore all Ithaca has to offer, while staying in the beautiful Hamlet of Brooktondale, NY. Located just 6 miles from Cornell, Ithaca College, and downtown Ithaca, this single family home is the perfect place to unwind and relax. Cayuga Lake, Fingerlakes State Parks, and many hiking/biking trails are just a short drive away. This historical home was built in the 1850s and has been tastefully remodeled to include modern updates while keeping it's farmhouse charm.

Guest favorite

A charming Cape Cod home is set amid lush greenery, featuring a light-colored exterior and a sloped metal roof. The surrounding yard is expansive and well-maintained, showcasing a variety of trees, with a picnic table positioned on the grass.

Home in Spencer

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

Quiet country escape In the Hamlet of Danby !

Newly available and entirely renovated 3 bedroom Cape Cod home with fully functional kitchen, bath and bedroom furnishings . Back deck and gas grill, 17 acres of woods and wildlife, WFI available. Within a short distance are: Parks, Theatre, Wineries, Dining and much more. Tompkins county airport conveniently serves our area. Nearby, Cornell University and Ithaca College sit prominently on the hills overlooking Cayuga Lake and Ithaca.

Top guest favorite

A custom timber frame home is positioned alongside a spacious garage, both surrounded by a blanket of freshly fallen snow. The landscape features gentle hills in the background, and a clear blue sky punctuates the scene, creating a serene winter atmosphere.

Home in Newfield

5 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Custom Finger Lakes home near Ithaca with hot tub

Escape to tranquility on our 12-acre property and 3,000 sq. ft. custom timber frame home. Enjoy stocked kitchen, wood stove, hot tub, wood-fired pizza oven, and campfire pit with hill views. Open living area, basement entertainment, and high-speed fiber optic internet. Ideal for small or large groups, any length of stay. Dogs welcome for an extra cost. Your perfect getaway awaits!

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

Peaceful well-appointed home at Treman Park

5 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews7 months ago

We really enjoyed our stay here. The house is beautiful, clean, and super comfortable, and the location is great - very pretty and convenient to both Robert Treman Park and Ithaca. The kitchen is well extremely well stocked and there was a delicious pastry there to greet us. There are three pleasant bedrooms upstairs and a really fun game room in the basement with pool, ping-pong and darts. The hosts were also very gracious. We hope to stay here again!

Home in Ithaca

What guests are saying

Creekside Comfort

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews5 months ago

It was a beautiful stay. We enjoyed walking the nearby market for breakfast and it was easy to get to Ithaca where we were visiting one of the students. Too cold to do much outside, but the interior was warm and cozy. Would highly recommend a stay at this house if you are in the area.

Home in Brooktondale

What guests are saying

Top of Owego …. Relaxing Home

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews1 month ago

We really enjoyed our stay- the house and location were just beautiful, so peaceful and relaxing; lots of space to spread out- having 3 full baths was so great and the main bath is gorgeous; all of the rooms are very spacious with great closet space; having a bedroom plus a full bath on the first floor is great in the event you have guests that may have a hard time with stairs; the expansive back deck and view is so pretty, tons of windows with great light, a really great home! Some things that would have been great to have and a plus for our stay would have been more hangers for the closets- only had a few hangers to hang clothes; more pillows on beds would be nice, a gas grill to cookout to take advantage of the beautiful deck and views, and a fire pit table would be amazing out there ; a toaster/ toaster oven for the kitchen to have bagels etc. One more TV would be nice, only 1 tv for a large house, and a dresser in main bdrm needed just for space to put things away/set down

Home in Owego

What guests are saying

Relaxing, Quiet, Newer Home.

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews3 months ago

Penney is great. We have stayed a coupe times and plan to be back. We have family nearby and have a family we bring. The space is cozy and home like. We like that we can cook and do laundry. Kids have separate space. A dinner table to eat together at and play cards. Perfect getaway.

Home in Apalachin

What guests are saying

Ithaca Area Creekside Retreat Home in the Woods

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews9 months ago

A flash storm had caused a power outage just before our arrival. Owner was quick to respond and proactively send updates and recommendations. We enjoyed our privacy while feeling well cared for. Home is lovely and well decorated. A great set up for our family - my wife and I two young children.

Home in Richford

What guests are saying

Tree House Retreat: Hot Tub/Shindagin State Forest

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews22 months ago

all the reviews seem to say the same thing.. this magical place blew our minds and went beyond our expectations.. this made my daughter's batchlorette girls weekend a weekend none of us will ever forget. beautiful memories made in a beautiful home!

Home in Brooktondale

What guests are saying

Close to river, Close to Tioga Downs

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews1 month ago

This was our second stay at Jennifer’s house and it feels like our home away from home when we return to the area to visit family! The house is just as described. It’s very cozy and comfortable. The layout downstairs is great for family time and plenty of private space in the three bedrooms. The baked treats are a favorite of my daughters! Host is very responsive and helpful. We will definitely be back!

Home in Barton

1 of 12 pages