Vacation rentals in Shipshewana

Had a wonderful stay! Scott was very quick to answer any questions I had, prior to arriving. He also reached out during our stay, just to check in/ask if we needed anything, which was very kind and thoughtful. The house is adorable and cozy! The entertainment/movie room was everything and made us want to duplicate the setup at our own house! We are local to the surrounding area and usually visit the area in the summer, but this was a perfect spot for our son's 10th winter birthday celebration! ❤️ PS - the trains didn't bother us! They are quick stints and we thought it was cool/fun to listen for their arrival!

LOVED it! Was there on a business trip in late winter, and wished it was for pleasure, and in a warmer month, so I could enjoy the lake it sits on, and get to relax while there. However, I was overwhelmed with prep for television and radio appearances and a live cooking show, so I only had the pleasure of using the AWESOME soaking tub to de-stress from super long hectic days, sleeping very well in oh-so-comfy bedding, and tossing together breakfast in a charming kitchen stocked with basics, as well as a well-stocked coffee bar. I thought the fresh creamer in the fridge was a nice touch, and I loved sitting at the kitchen table enjoying my coffee and the beautiful lake view. I hope to return some day -under less stressful circumstances- so I can get to enjoy all its outdoor amenities in warmer weather, too. I also want to mention that I felt very safe staying there alone (owners live next door) and the place is so cozy I felt like I was at home throughout my entire 3-day stay.

We had a beautiful, peaceful stay at Karissa’s cabin. Lots of natural lighting, spacious unit, and lovely amenities like WiFi, jacuzzi, kitchen appliances, and washer/dryer. There are a lot of nearby stores for any last minute groceries or shopping. The views were absolutely stunning. I would recommend staying here and would absolutely come back again but in the warmer season to explore that trails here! Thank you for having us at your cabin! We had such a nice, relaxing stay.

Perfect for us, clean comfortable house, well done!

This cottage is perfect for a getaway. Clean. Real clean not the tidy clean some claim as clean. Pictures are correct. We loved that the cottage had a pier to tie up our boat. It’s in a channel about three lanes wide & you ‘parallel park’. The pier has poles not cleats to tie to. It’s our first boating season & we have been visiting different lakes & setups - thought this might be helpful to share. Our children loved the book selection, the foldable stool, & the “bar” island table. We had a great time fishing on the lake during our stay - the water was so clear! Speaking of water, yes, the cottage’s water has a sulphur smell which is typical of Indiana but taste is fine (cooking, brushing teeth, etc.) Neighborhood was quiet in the fall when we stayed. The neighbors were kind & friendly. We felt welcomed by Nicholas, his information, & the amenities (basic spices, towels, utensils, tp, handsoaps, etc.) We would rent again.

My Happy Place was beautifully and seasonally decorated and Tonya had thought of everything we might need or want. Kitchen had every gadget, pan, small appliance and all adorably matched. She had local menus and even had a Kroger (grocery) savers card there for us to use (which I did!). The beds were very comfortable, as was the futon. We all slept great! Absolutely no complaints and I’d stay again anytime I’m in the area

We booked last minute due to other plans falling through due to floods in Kentucky. Jo was amazing and got us booked quickly. The cottage was comfortable. The lake was beautiful and peaceful. We will be returning when it's warm. We had an enjoyable trip exploring Shipshewana. We read in the sunroom and loved relaxing with a beautiful view. Thank you Jo for hosting us!

This was our third year staying at Chris’s cottage. The cottage was spotless as always, equipped with snacks, water, plenty of towels and amenities. The cottage is on Fish Lake, beautiful and peaceful but also fun to watch all of the water activities and wildlife. The weather was perfect. The mark of a fantastic place and location is never having to turn on the TV to pass the time. We will be back next year if it’s available! Thank you, Chris!

This house was perfect for our girl's trip to see a concert at the Blue Gate Inn. We walked right across the street from the house and ate dinner at the yummy Blue Gate Inn restaurant then walked the 1 mile walk all on sidewalks/safe to the concert. Would absolutely stay here again and recommend this house for a weekend getaway!