House vacation rentals in Shinnecock Hills

AJ is an AWESOME host!!!!! We loved staying at this property. It's so safe and way bigger than the photos. The bathrooms are fantastic. (No bathtubs, though, if you need one.) I cannot emphasize what a great stay we had. Thank you so much!!!!!

We had a wonderful time in this beautiful home that is in an idyllic Hampton's setting. Ashton was a great host and for sure we will be back.

The house is beautiful, looks like photos. Stephen is a great host! Overall great stay, could not recommend more!

Our family enjoyed a wonderful post- Christmas getaway at Jennifer’s beautiful home. The house is fabulous - well- located, pristine , beautifully decorated and well-stocked. It was relaxing and perfect. We did not have much need to reach out (everything was effortless) but when we did, Jennifer was very responsive and helpful. Highly recommend!

My stay here was phenomenal! From the host’s response time, down to the amenities that were placed throughout the house. As soon as you walk in, it felt like home. The house is spacious and highly functional. The design of the house offers a perfect blend of modern mixed with nostalgic elements. The best stay by far. Would love to book again!

House is well represented. Spacious, very clean, and great location. Good for families or groups of friends.

Five stars doesn't feel like enough, if anything I'd say everything was better than we'd expected based on the pictures and the reviews! First, as others have mentioned John was an incredible host, the place was well stocked and had all sorts of snacks and drinks (and a nice bottle of wine); he also bought us dinner and was very good about keeping in touch the whole time we were there. The house was amazing top to bottom, but I have to specifically call out the pool, which was jaw-droppingly beautiful and the perfect temperature despite cold weather outside. We loved the neighborhood and yard to walk our dogs, and the kitchen was great to cook in (made me miss having a gas stovetop). We'll definitely be visiting again, it was the kind of stay that sets a new bar for what to look for in a vacation!

Marks home was beautiful, peaceful and near to so many great areas. The pool and backyard were wonderful and relaxing. We loved it! Highly recommend!

Kathy’s home was exactly as described spacious, clean, and incredibly inviting. I traveled with a large group of my friends, and we never felt on top of each other. Kathy was extremely accommodating & communicative when it came to checking in and checking out of the Airbnb,along with recommendations to eat on the island or close by. The home was an effortless walk to the beach and to center of town. If you were coming to enjoy fire Island with a large group of people, I would absolutely recommend this space!

We cannot get enough of this amazing North Fork bungalow! We have enjoyed staying here several times over the last 5 years and hope to be back again next year! The space is perfect for our family of 6! We enjoy making a fire pit out back, cooking dinner together in the kitchen, playing games at the dining room table and snuggling up together on the couch! Our 4 kids cannot get enough of the bedroom upstairs! They love reading, playing games and being altogether for a big sleepover! We love taking a break from our busy life to relax and enjoy walks to town for coffee and dinner, hiking on the beach, the wineries and taking a trip over to Shelter island to hike and explore! Thank you again for having us and for all of the memories we have made together in your beautiful house! We hope to see you again next year!

This is an AMAZING Airbnb. High quality blankets, towels, ornamental details throughout the space. Comfortable beds. Beautiful ambient lighting. Large backyard with a fire pit. The neighborhood is quiet, beautiful houses, surrounded by water, with lovey little shores and nooks to walk to. My 4 year old had toys to play with and a little potty that all came with the home. I will DEFINITELY stay again. My family and I loved this place.

I cannot say enough amazing things about this house - our stay was absolutely sublime. The decor was immaculately curated, the house had all the supplies required to cook family meals, the sunset was to die for, and we had an absolute blast at the pool. Communicating with Dan and Tabitha was great, very professional and responsive. The home was incredibly clean - it was the nicest AirBnb I've ever stayed in BY FAR, already looking forward to booking again. THANK YOU!

My family and I had a very relaxing stay at this place. Cozy with plenty of amenities. PAPA, the neighborhood cat likes to visit in the morning on the front deck and he’s a very good boy. Bring him treats.

Had a great weekend. We felt right at home and comfortable. Close to town and winery’s.

Jeanne’s house is a cute and clean cottage in a peaceful environment! The location is great as it is walking distance from the town! She is very responsive with her communication and we had a wonderful time last week!!! Thank you!!!

We had a fantastic time for a family weekend getaway. Great for kids, location is nearby restaurants and beach. The house was clean and felt cozy.

Maura was an excellent host and the home was perfect! We enjoyed the weekend very much and cannot thank Maura enough for her kindness, responsiveness, warm hearted spirit, and for opening up her home to us. Will always keep this spot in mind for future SI adventures!

We just spent an unforgettable weekend at J.P’s beautiful house, and we can't wait to be back! The house is absolutely beautiful, with impeccable taste and attention to detail. But what truly makes this property shine is its phenomenal location. Right in the middle of East Hampton and Amagansett and a 15 minute drive to Sag Harbor— couldn’t have asked for more. Also Carissa’s bakery is just a 6 minute walk. And, of course, no Hampton's experience is complete without a visit to Goldberg's for their classic lox and bagels - which is also a short walk away. The house itself is spacious, bright, and beautifully appointed, with everything you need to unwind and relax. Every room is nice and cozy and the kitchen is stunning with everything you need to cook with the amazing produce available at the so many farm stands around the area. (We loved Balsam and Amber Waves) J.P. was incredibly responsive and thoughtful, providing excellent recommendations and ensuring our stay was perfect.

We had a wonderful stay. Cute and comfortable house in an amazing location. Very comfortable for a family of 4.

We had a great family weekend at Andreas’s home. The house has a great clean hotel like feel with all needed amenities. There is plenty of space for eating, hanging and working. All 4 bedrooms have their own en suite bathroom. The hot tub and front porch are also great spots to relax. Sag Harbor town is about a mile away and you can walk on Hampton St which has a sidewalk. We walked another day to town by walking mostly on the bay beach (which is a few blocks away from the house) and gets you pretty close to Sag Harbor town. The bay beach there is very nice. Andreas was very accommodating. Can’t wait to return.

We loved our stay at Jimbo's. All the bedrooms are spacious and the beds are comfortable. The whole family enjoyed chilling out in the comfy sofas with a nice library in the living area. We all and in particular our dog loved the huge, green and well maintained lawn. He had so much fun with all the space to run and play! For us the greenery was very relaxing. The location is good - a 5 minute walk from the ice cream store, 12 minute walk from Crescent Beach (with the happening Sunset Beach Club), a 5 minute drive from the IGA, and a 5 minute drive from North Ferry. The furthest we had to drive was a 12 minute drive to Rams Head Point. The outdoor shower was lovely! Jimbo was very friendly and very responsive including providing some very efficient "tech support" on the dryer even though he was out of town. The issue was a confusing light on the dryer and some user error and was easily resolved on the phone. Additional towels were dropped off upon request. A pretty comprehensive set of silverware, plate settings, and kitchen utensils made it a fun and easy stay. Thank you Mary and Jimbo for sharing your house, we had precious moments there and we highly recommend it !

Mike is a great host with helpful recommendations and plenty of advice. The house is amazing. Well located, calm, clean and so convenient. The pool is huge and very deep. Everything is perfect. Felt like at home. We will be back

I was in Dion’s place with my family we really enjoyed the time we spent there,everything was perfect the pool was something that my kids enjoyed a lot, and hopefully we will come back again, for sure I totally recommend his house if you want to go and have a couple days of fun and relax thank you again Dion.

We must have passed the residence hundreds of times going out Montauk over the past 40 years. What a hidden gem. We were so fortunate to have the opportunity to stay at this location. The home was very well appointed, tidy and clean. What a gem of a home, even in the off season. We would love to return.