Pet-friendly vacation rentals in Shinnecock Hills

My family had a wonderful time at Robert’s home. The house was clean and cozy and the view of the water was peaceful. He was super communicative and friendly and check in/out was a breeze. The house is in a great area and super close to East Hampton, Amagansett, and Montauk. Highly recommend!

It was a lovely stay. Great location. House felt like a home and had great vibes.

Ed was great at communicating, house was everything we could have asked for. Would definitely book again!

We had an amazing time staying here! The house was beautiful and looked just like the photos. Super cozy, clean, and comfortable. If we’re ever back in the area, we’d love to stay here again!

We had such a wonderful stay here over New Years. Like many other reviews have stated, pictures do not do this home justice. It’s so much larger and more spread out than we expected. Perfect layout for two couples where we each felt like we had our own place, with plenty of cozy spaces to hang out too. The kitchen is SO well equipped for anything and everything. Beds and sofas were super comfortable and the we loved all of the charming touches of this historical home. The location is fantastic too. Walking distance to everything you could need and a quick drive to so many beautiful areas. I can imagine spending hours in the backyard when the weather is warmer too!

This place was perfect! We were pleasantly surprised by all there was to do in the area nearby and the house came stocked with everything we could’ve needed!

Madelaine’s cottage was the perfect location for our weekend in Water Mill! The house was cozy with a spacious and private backyard. The location is centrally located, and we were even able to walk to and from breakfast and the farmers market. I would recommend the cottage and would absolutely stay again!

We had a great stay at Jess and Zack’s place for my birthday weekend on the North Fork! They provided clear directions ahead of time on how to find their place and how to check in. We were greeted by the sweetest pup. The space was spotless and very comfortable. We had a fire in the fire pit one night and that was excellent. It’s super close to lots of great restaurants and wineries! I would recommend their place to anyone looking for a quiet and peaceful getaway!

Marta’s place was the perfect getaway for my family. The bedrooms were large with comfortable beds. The kitchen was huge with high end appliances, and the yard was a dream for our young dog. Lovely surroundings in the woods but close to town for shopping and restaurants. Truly an unforgettable experience!

We had a wonderful time in this beautiful home that is in an idyllic Hampton's setting. Ashton was a great host and for sure we will be back.

The house is beautiful, looks like photos. Stephen is a great host! Overall great stay, could not recommend more!

We had a fabulous stay at Spencer and Maddie's! Their house is lovely and perfect for a cozy family getaway. We especially loved the kitchen - stocked with all the necessary appliances, the fireplace and a welcoming family room. The house is tucked away in a quiet area, steps away from the beach and a short drive / jogging distance away from Greenport and its lovely cafes, nearby wineries and the beauty of North Fork. We appreciate how friendly, welcoming and responsive Spencer and Maddie were and look forward to coming back!

Christine was a great host and we enjoyed our stay at the cabin!

I was in Dion’s place with my family we really enjoyed the time we spent there,everything was perfect the pool was something that my kids enjoyed a lot, and hopefully we will come back again, for sure I totally recommend his house if you want to go and have a couple days of fun and relax thank you again Dion.

My stay here was phenomenal! From the host’s response time, down to the amenities that were placed throughout the house. As soon as you walk in, it felt like home. The house is spacious and highly functional. The design of the house offers a perfect blend of modern mixed with nostalgic elements. The best stay by far. Would love to book again!

House is well represented. Spacious, very clean, and great location. Good for families or groups of friends.

We absolutely loved our quick getaway from the city at Kate’s lovely home. It is hard to articulate in words just how beautiful of a home and location this was. It was truly magical. We were very comfortable as a family traveling with young children. Despite the weather being a bit chilly, we had a wonderful time soaking the views and discovering “treasures” by the water. We cannot wait to come back again soon.

The house was just as pictured. Extremely clean and on a peaceful residential street in a convenient location to explore the surrounding towns. Ana was also very responsive!

We needed a dog-friendly ranch style to home with three bedrooms and two bedrooms close to Sayville, where we would be celebrating Thanksgiving. I was lucky enough to find this rental which was clean, comfortable and ideal for our two-night stay. Adam was attentive and easily accessible via text. I would highly recommend this lovely home.

We had a wonderful stay at George’s. The unit is exactly as described, don’t be deterred by the adherence to the house, it’s completely private. It’s at a great location for north fork explorations and the amount of towels was outstanding!

Clare was a fantastic host. She helped us with getting around which was super helpful because we didn’t have a car. Her food recommendations were great. All in all, she created a warm and welcoming atmosphere which made our stay in Montauk a beautiful experience. Thanks for everything!

I would highly recommend Melissa's place in Jamesport. It was a great location with room to enjoy with some family members including children. It was perfect with some toys and a big outdoor area (and a private beach!) for us all to spend some time together while visiting family in the area. Melissa was accommodating and clear in her directions and gave us a warm welcome with a greeting basket, information about the area and coffee! The location is lovely and everything about the house was fun and comfortable. Thanks!

We had nice weekend at the cozy cottage. We loved that it was pet friendly and a short walk to the beach. Cameron was very friendly and responsive. She offered great suggestions for food and activities.

Incredible place to stay as a solo traveler. Clean, organized and efficient space with everything you could possibly need on site ! Amazing host with such knowledgeable recommendations for the surrounding area. Would absolutely stay here again & could not recommend more.