Vacation rentals in Old Mill Creek

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Old Mill Creek

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

Home in Lake Geneva

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Pet-Friendly Slice of Heaven by Lake Geneva & Como

Experience the ultimate family retreat in this well-appointed getaway in Geneva, Wisconsin. Hilltop Haven provides the perfect blend of relaxation and access to adventure! Nestled near quaint Lake Como and a few miles from the renowned Geneva Lake, you can easily partake in water sports, stroll by the waterfront, or visit the plethora of shops, restaurants, activities, and attractions nearby. Or stay on the property to get a slice of nature and relax, it’s set up to be comfortable and enjoyable!

Guest favorite

Apartment in West Lake View

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

Sun drenched 2 bedroom 1 bath with Kitchen & W/D

Welcome to beautiful Roscoe Village! Come relax and enjoy a gorgeous loft-like condo that has a huge sun-drenched living room and opens up right to the kitchen. Enjoy cooking on your own in the spacious kitchen and rest easily at night in a spacious king bed in the main bedroom. We love and welcome pets - so no need to leave your fur baby at home. Uber to Wicker Park and Logan Square. You’ll have your own private entrance with a lock box to get into the condo. We look forward to hosting you!

Guest favorite

Bungalow in Lake Geneva

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

Private Cozy Cottage Lake Geneva, WI

Come stay at our top rated Bed & Breakfast, located two blocks from the beautiful Lake Geneva. Relax in our California king suites, each contains a spa tub and shower, with heated floors and towel rails in the bathroom. Your complimentary breakfast basket is placed in your fridge prior to arrival, as well as complimentary gift of wine & cheese. Free WIFI is available on the property. No Pets, ADULTS over 21 ONLY. *NOTE all guests are required to pay a 8% Lake Geneva Bed Tax at check in.

Top guest favorite

Home in Lake Geneva

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

Updated luxury country getaway short walk to lake!

Luxury getaway close to private beaches, downtown Lake Geneva, and many area amenities. Relax in comfort in this newly renovated 3-bedroom. Enjoy all that the Lake Geneva area has to offer while unwinding in a modern, comfortable retreat. Conveniently located a 3-min walk to Lake Como and a 10-min drive to downtown Lake Geneva. Charming golf cart community with so much to do. Perfect for couples, families, and business travelers. Ideal space for up to 4 adults and great for families of 5.

Top guest favorite

Home in Lake Geneva

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 79 reviews

Huge! Sleeps 12, Perfect getaway for a large group

Pretend you are lost in a magical place as you curl up on the porch on a rocking chair. Then fall asleep in a heavenly bedroom in a luxurious king size bed. When you wake up, all your worries have faded away and the espresso machine awaits. This is Como! We designed the most heavenly home for you so the minute you step inside you're on vacation. Perfect for all seasons! Two living rooms, game room, 5 bedroom, 2.5 bath, stocked with everything we can think of to make your stay perfect.

Guest favorite

Home in Lake Geneva

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

The Clean Slate, Walk to down town, pet friendly

The Clean Slate is the latest offering from Lake Geneva luxury Rentals. Half mile walk to downtown. Pet friendly The house can accommodate 8 guests, but can be rented with its sister property, The White House, to accommodate larger groups. Contact host to inquire about renting both houses. This newly built home will surely delight. Tastefully decorated with all modern amenities. Easy access to downtown Lake Geneva’s shops, restaurants, Riviera Beach, and Geneva Lake Shore Path.

Guest favorite

Home in Lake Geneva

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

1 block to the Lake, then 2 blocks to Downtown

Renovated vintage cottage is blocks from the lake, 4 blocks to Riviera Beach, and a short walk to downtown. Stunning cottage boasts original stained glass with gorgeous renovated kitchen including granite countertops and stainless steel appliances. Fully stocked kitchen with plates, utensils, pots, pans and mixing bowls. Cabinets and drawers clearly labeled. Child plates, bowls, cups and kid utensils. Many games, toys, puzzles and books for kids too! Patio table outside.

Guest favorite

Home in Lake Geneva

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

NEW! Cozy Downtown Farmhouse, 5BR 3 BA Sleeps 15!!

Our gorgeous home is set in the heart of downtown Lake Geneva. 5 bedroom, 3 bathroom home that is two blocks from the lake and a few blocks from downtown shopping and restaurants. We just completed an extensive renovation of the home and it is now ready for you to stay for your dream vacation. Our homes are fully licensed and legal for short term rentals. We also rent the home two doors down and another in nearby Williams Bay!

Guest favorite

Home in Lake Geneva

5 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Modern Downtown Lake Geneva Charm - Sleeps 8

Beautiful 3 bedroom home located in the heart of Lake Geneva and walking distance to restaurants, bars, & the beach. This recently remodeled house is the perfect place for an escape. With an open kitchen concept, leading out to a large composite (Trex®) deck, there is no shortage of space for any activity or just to get back to a quieter more relaxing pace. *** This property is Licensed & Legal for weekend rentals ***

Superhost

Home in Fox Lake

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Lakefront Paradise

Relax and have fun with the family and friends at this unique getaway! We are situated directly on the lakefront with private access to our pier where you can enjoy world class sunset views. Jump in and go swimming, roast s'mores over a campfire right next to the water, grill up some burgers on the spacious deck or get some rest in our luxurious suites in this newly renovated (June 2021) home.

Superhost

Cottage in Antioch

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews

#1 The Lodge @ The Cottages on Petite Lake

This beautiful and spacious lakefront lodge has views, charm and wonderful amenities including a private hot tub with lake views. Enjoy your morning coffee with a beautiful sunrise from your private deck right over the water with a private hot tub. Spend your days on the lake with the beach just steps away. End the night with a bonfire or movie in the comfortable great room.

Superhost

Chalet in Williams Bay

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 249 reviews

The Bay Chalet

Featured in "At The Lake" Magazine in 2022! Enjoy the Northwoods of Lake Geneva! Just a 2-minute drive to Pier 290, Williams Bay public beach on Geneva Lake, lakefront park, boat launch and restaurants. 10 minutes to downtown Lake Geneva. 20 minutes to Alpine Valley. Enjoy Lake Geneva life while being tucked in the woods with a roaring fire in your cozy log cabin.

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

Cozy Cottage by the Lake! Kayaks! Paddleboard! Wow

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews2 months ago

This cottage was wonderful to stay at! Very cozy! Great to stay at in winter as an indoor getaway and this would be an awesome stay in the summer. I passed up the place at first when I arrived because I didn't think it would be that nice of a place! Rainfall shower was nice and great areas to sit and chill out. I would definitely stay here again!

Home in Salem

What guests are saying

The Beach house! Enjoy Beachfront Living!

5 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews3 months ago

MIke was an amazing host. Extremely responsive, and very flexible and accommodating. Was in town with my family for a funeral; Mike was very understanding and was willing to go the extra mile to support the changing flow of the trip. Beautiful view; I could imagine it would be amazing in the summer. All-in-all, a great stay, and exactly what we needed during this time. Would love to be there in the summer or fall!

Home in Racine

What guests are saying

The Harbor House - Amazing!

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews6 months ago

I honestly can’t say enough great things about everything - they are such kind, considerate, lovely, beautiful people & their house was amazing!!! Everything top notch, great instructions, great & quick communication. Above & beyond & my family and I are so grateful and thankful. May God continue to bless Karen & Paul bc they are deserving. Thank you!!!!!

Home in Winthrop Harbor

What guests are saying

Lake/Beach Getaway (Remodeled)

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews1 month ago

Me and my guests had an amazing time at marks home . His hospitality and attentiveness to his guest was spectacular. Any questions I had, I felt comfortable enough to ask because I knew he would be helpful and answer any questions. His home was beautiful and we extremely enjoy our stay .

Home in Round Lake Beach