Cottage vacation rentals in Niagara County

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Niagara County

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

The image shows a lakeside view of the property, featuring a charming brick house with a sloped backyard leading to the water. A boathouse is visible, along with a dock area. Smooth water reflects the soft hues of the sky and surrounding greenery.

Cottage in Wilson

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

Beautiful Lakeside Cottage

Located on the shores of Lake Ontario in Wilson, this three bedroom, one bath private home is awaiting your arrival. It is a short distance to wineries, breweries, and restaurants. The backyard oasisis of the lake is ideal for BBQing or just watching the beautiful sunsets. Complete kitchen, gas stove and stainless steel appliances with a dishwasher. All the bedrooms have plush linens. We invite you to enjoy the home we love. Please let us know if you are bringing a dog. There is a $75 pet fee.

Top guest favorite

A vintage restroom door displays weathered wood with brass gender symbols. Adjacent, the bathroom features a modern sink beneath a round mirror, complemented by wooden shelving stocked with toiletries. A window allows natural light, while plants add a touch of greenery.

Cottage in Youngstown

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Parkview Cottage w/Bonus Apartment - Sleeps 6

Our circa 1855 cottage, was fully renovated in 2022. Centrally located in the heart of Youngstown, this cozy home features 2BR/1bath/full kitchen in the main part of the house and a private attached apartment w/separate entrance 1BR/1bath w/kitchenette. Just a minutes walk to restaurants, shops, and the free shuttle stop to majestic Niagara Falls, NY. Enjoy a sunset from the front porch, gaze upon Falkner Park, the gazebo and Fort George, Canada just beyond. **See pet policy in house rules

Superhost

A wooden dock extends over the water, featuring a landing platform with steps leading down to the water's edge. An American flag waves gently in the breeze, surrounded by lush green trees reflecting on the calm surface of the lake.

Cottage in Wilson

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Ontario Lake-View Cottage

Have fun with the whole family at this stylish place with beautiful view of Lake Ontario. Relax in quiet neighborhood and pet friendly. Enjoy why you staying at cottage the access to the public boat ramp on Riverview side and park your trailer at park. Walk to Wilson Tuscarora state park and enjoy kayaking and biking by renting them Your kids can enjoy playground while you using picnic area and public beach for swimming. View sunset on Ontario lake by seating on gazebo or from living room.

Guest favorite

Lush greenery surrounds the view, with tall trees reaching upwards and their leaves creating a natural canopy. The sunlight filters gently through the branches, highlighting the serene atmosphere of the woodland area. In the distance, hints of water can be glimpsed through the trees.

Cottage in Burt

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

LaVida Cottage - a restful creekside destination

LaVida Cottage offers a quaint and quiet setting two blocks from Lake Ontario and overlooking 18 Mile Creek. In the 3/4 acre back yard there is a FIREPIT, two patios, picnic spots and plenty of places to pitch a family tent. The yard overlooks a very active wetland with all sorts of wildlife. Please note our rental rate includes the 5% local bed tax. There is excellent guest security (although Olcott is very safe) with exterior cottage lighting and video monitoring of the parking area.

Guest favorite

A small fire pit area surrounded by several Adirondack chairs is visible, set on green grass. In the background, trees frame a tranquil view of the lake, with a clear blue sky above, creating a serene outdoor space.

Cottage in Youngstown

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 373 reviews

Lakefront cottage, Youngstown USA

Cozy, secluded cottage off the main road with lake front. **Although we have lakefront property, there is currently no access to the water on our property***. Close to the village of Youngstown for boating, fishing, food, and entertainment. A 10 minute drive from Lewiston and Artpark. Stay hidden at the lake and relax, or explore the Niagara River and Lake Ontario! Also not far from Niagara Falls, one of the seven wonders of the world, and a short drive to the Canadian border!

Superhost

A serene outdoor space is presented, featuring a grassy area with a circular stone patio. Two wooden adirondack chairs face a small fire pit, with a clear view of the tranquil lake beyond. Lush trees provide natural shade along the shoreline.

Cottage in Burt

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

*HOT TUB | Lake Front | Incredible Views

Welcome to The Sunflower Home! This tranquil home is located right on the lake. Just mins to Olcott Beach, Krull Park & many local wineries. Centrally located yet quietly tucked away, this home is perfect for anyone looking to relax. Enjoy the sunset as you wind down in the hot tub, sip your beverage of choice, fireside, overlooking the lake, or head inside and enjoy the view from every window. Go to sleep on the comfortable king bed & wake up to the serenity of Lake Ontario.

Top guest favorite

A hot tub is positioned at the edge of a deck, with illuminated jets casting a soft blue glow. The tranquil waters of Lake Ontario stretch out in the background, reflecting the colors of a sunset sky filled with gentle hues of orange and purple.

Cottage in Ransomville

5 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Restful Retreat - Waterfront

Welcome to our beautiful lakefront cottage on Lake Ontario. Convenient to Niagara Falls, Niagara on the Lake, Lewiston, and the Niagara Wine Trails. Our cottage exudes a beach vibe and has been fully remodeled to accommodate guests with a flair for design. Enjoy our clean, beautifully decorated private cottage that has all the amenities you need. Relax during the evening in the hot tub or start a fire and watch the stars. Weber gas grill, Jenn Air electric double oven.

Superhost

A spacious deck is shown outside the cottage, featuring a large picnic table and several blue Adirondack chairs. White railings frame the area, which is surrounded by green grass and landscaping. Sunlight filters through the trees, highlighting the inviting outdoor space.

Cottage in Youngstown

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 257 reviews

SHELL COTTAGE

Sitting on the shore of Lake Ontario, SHELL COTTAGE is a cozy retreat to watch boats sail by or head out to the area's many attractions. Enjoy a campfire while the sun sets over the lake. Our lakeside haven is good for couples and families (with kids). We are accessible should you need anything during your stay. Niagara Falls is minutes away. Let us help make your visit to Western New York special. We also have Woodcliff Cottage available next door. Book SHELL COTTAGE!

Guest favorite

A scenic view of the lake is visible through a glass door, with outdoor seating arranged on a wooden deck. Two blue chairs face the water, while a round white table and chairs are positioned nearby, creating a serene space for relaxation.

Cottage in Barker

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Lake Front Vista & HotTub w/Sun-Thu night discount

Enjoy Spectacular Lakefront views. Relax at your own pace. Take a dip in the spa tub or just enjoy the scenery Very quiet road Speedy internet Fire-pit Enjoy the Niagara Wine Trail 2 Bdrm 6 min to Golden Hill Park 12 min to White Birch Golf course 15 min to Olcott/Burt (fishing charters) 20 min to Waterport/Kent (fishing charters) 50 min to Niagara Falls *Promo: 3rd night or more, will be discounted ~25% (no discount on cleaning and fees, excl 06/23-09/10)

Guest favorite

A cozy living area is highlighted by large picture windows offering views of Lake Ontario. Two comfortable armchairs are placed beside a small table with a lamp. Wooden flooring reflects the soft ambient light, creating a warm atmosphere. Nearby, a dining table is set for two.

Cottage in Youngstown

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Sunset Cottage on Lake Ontario

This romantic cozy cottage on Lake Ontario boasts a different sunset every night! Sleeps 2-4 guests. Relax on the large deck with a cup of coffee, a glass of wine, or revitalize and renew the soul with morning yoga while taking in the breathtaking lake views. Get competitive with any of the many games our clubhouse offers, pool table, ping pong, darts, cornhole or many other board games. Gas Grill & Blender for enjoyable evenings in.

Guest favorite

A vibrant row of cottage-style buildings in pastel colors is depicted, with a person in a pink dress walking along a wooden pathway. Decorative flowers hang from the blue and pink cottages, while a lighthouse stands in the background against a clear sky.

Cottage in Burt

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 340 reviews

Anchors Away Cottage with Hot tub!

Experience Niagara Falls USA and Lake Ontario like a local! You'll enjoy a restful sleep in our Anchors Away cottage right within walking distance of a public pebble beach. Our quaint cottage is just minutes from Olcott Beach, the Niagara Wine Trail, and world-famous fishing along Eighteenmile Creek and Burt Dam. Niagara Falls is about 30 miles away and the Buffalo metropolitan area is about 40 miles away.

Guest favorite

A covered patio extends outward, featuring outdoor seating and string lights overhead. The deck offers expansive views of Lake Ontario, with water meeting the horizon under a cloudy twilight sky. Lush greenery frames the sides of the structure.

Cottage in Barker

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 67 reviews

Private cottage near Niagara Falls with lake view

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Slow down and let the water, sunset, birds and everything this lake has to offer rejuvenate you. Located 30-45 minutes north of Buffalo, this cozy cottage offers expansive views of Lake Ontario. Experience a country feel, cidery, vineyards and multiple state parks, including Niagara Falls by driving short distances.