Monthly Rentals in New Baltimore

This is our second stay at Mary’s home - absolutely peaceful and slept great - will stay again!

Have stayed here multiple times and it’s great! My buddy who live out of state always comes back for a long weekend of duck hunting every. This house fits our needs perfectly!

This lakeside cottage was even more magical in person than the photos suggested. The space was warm and inviting with cozy furniture and plenty of space to gather in the dining room and sun room. The beds were comfy and the neighborhood is quiet and serene. The bathrooms are sparkling and well-stocked. The views are unrivaled - despite the rainy weather - the picture windows still framed the idyllic lake landscape perfectly. Even in the cold weather we could walk out on to the dock and explore the wide open grassy yard. The kitchen was extremely well-stocked with everything we needed including complimentary snacks and spices. We couldn’t have asked for more. They even provided excellent restaurant recommendations which were spot on - we especially loved the breakfast at Anchor Bay Pit Stop Diner and Lobster Mac and cheese at On the Bay Boutique Cafe. Highly recommend this delightful cottage!

Nestled in a beautiful quiet cozy neighborhood. Was the perfect place to get away with a group of friends. Our firepit attempt was dampened with unexpected rain. Loved the outside bar area and screened porch.