Guesthouse vacation rentals in Long Island

Dawn’s place is private, well-appointed and in a fantastic location. You have an ocean view from the cottage, have access to a small semi-private beach, and a brief walk along the coast via the gorgeous neighborhood takes you to the larger Ocean Beach & boardwalk. Additionally there are very good restaurants, state parks, museums and pubs nearby. You’ll feel pampered by Dawn’s consideration and attention to detail and refreshed by the location and beaches.

Nice ground floor apartment across the street from the beach and 2 blocks from the state park. Love the outdoors. And Delores and her brother were amazing. Friendly, responsive, and helpful.

Johnny and Amy were amazing hosts. The instructions to park, enter and get in were very well written out before our arrival and check-in was seamless. And once we were there, the place was beautiful, cozy and exactly as described. Our kids loved running around outside in the grass and exploring the outdoor fire-pit. If you want peaceful mornings, laying in bed, watching the wind rustle the trees and listening to the birds sing their morning songs, this is a place for you.

Peter's place is THE perfect stay for a couple (plus dog) planning a visit to Rockland County. The cottage is extremely clean and incredibly cozy. The surroundings are beautiful, with the property well set back from the road and bordering Harriman State Park. Suffern and its restaurants aren't far and there's easy access to the Palisades Parkway to go anywhere else nearby. I grew up in the county and visit my parents on a regular basis. Any time I can't stay at their home, Peter's place will be my go-to from now on.

Our band travels up to play in Long Island twice a year. Liz's place was a great, affordable place for us to spend the weekend. We had everything we needed. And, the location was not just close to lots of great restaurants and coffee shops (which we love) but also close to the event that were booked to play. Our band would very much like to stay there again :)

Loved the Oyster Bay Area and spent the first afternoon walking around the historic district. Very quiet neighborhood. Room had everything I needed and a very comfortable bed. Would definitely stay here again.

I will book again and again. The comfort of the bed and shower was fantastic. The appliances were updated and I will recommend this little piece of solitude Heaven. It’s like a wee nature refuge and Perfect location. The hosts were attentive and kind. A million thanks!

We were in town for a concert in Red Bank and the cabin met our needs perfectly. Ideal accommodations for two people and we were able to bring our dog along. An easy stay in a very comfortable setting.

Stayed here last November with a friend and was so glad I booked again! The place was clean, comfortable, and exactly as described. The host was responsive and made everything easy. Great location, too. Will definitely book again!

We loved our stay at Beth's. We were there with our two grandchildren (5 &7) and they thought the upstairs playroom was fabulous - it was even difficult to get them to come down . The accommodation is top notch with every facility you could desire. The location was just lovely - really peaceful and rural but not too far from shops, restaurants etc. We would not hesitate to return !

This place is quiet and very private, as someone in the area for work this is exactly what I am looking for. I work night shift and the host was understanding about odd sleeping hours and adjusted check out time for me. Wonderful all around, will definitely be back!

Amazing host

Quiet, nice spot.

We wanted a quiet weekend, and we got a whole lot more. Andrew and Mynor were amazing hosts!! From the complimentary beverages to the assistance with snow removal, their service was incredible. The photos did not do justice to the place; the decor was great, and the place was spotless. We will definitely be back!!

The carriage house was a lovely stay and very charming. Everything was clean, comfy and as described. The hosts were very friendly and detailed. It’s so quiet at night, but close enough to town for all amenities. The view of the city from the back patio was a plus!

Wonderful place to stay in wading river! Hosts were excellent and their place was cozy. Recommend to anyone needing a place to stay in the area.

We had a great stay and would recommend!

I had a wonderful stay ! The home was clean, comfortable, and exactly as described in the listing. The location was perfect. The host very responsive and made check-in super easy. I would definitely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone visiting the area!

We loved our short stay at Debbie and Paul’s place! Wonderful theme. Very comfortable bed and linens! Easy to use temperature control. Great location for exploring Mystic!

Neil and Tania, the owners live in a house on the road and the unit they rent is their coach house with 2 bed rooms, dedicated bathroom and a garage which is right behind their house. Their kitchen at the 2nd floor with dinning, living and bed rooms is well equipment and they even have a full stove in the garage.They had everything for us to stay comfortably for almost a week. Self and my daughter and son-in-law. We all worked as their internet had an awesome bandwidth. There are no stores or restaurants that are walk-able and needs a car. There are side walks and one can have good walk for 15 minutes on either side direction (left or right) for stores and restaurants. That is the only reason I had to give 4stars for the location. Otherwise very quite and comfortable place and we had a even a small hike to hillock behind.

My folks have stayed here a few times while visiting me and the family, and it's been great every time.

We had a lovely stay! The space is beautifully decorated and cozy, and the location is super convenient for exploring Mystic and nearby towns. I would definitely stay again and recommend to others!

Robin's gardener's cottage is just as billed-- a very peaceful and cozy cottage with all the amenities and a few creature comforts like a large screen TV with streaming services and good wifi, granite countertops. Having enough room for two and perhaps even sleeping 3 with the trundle bed is a magnificent value and a great getaway! The little alcove dining area is so nice! Thanks, Robin!

Thank you for everything Julie! beautiful home and great host. location was great super safe! and you can basically take the subway straight to the city.