Cabin vacation rentals in Highland Lake

This cabin was ideal for our wish for a quiet, cozy mid-week getaway. It was homey, interesting, well stocked, and most of all...authentic. The creek is picturesque, and the cabin has amenities and areas to accommodate different activities and moods, inside and out. We could have stayed longer. Getting to hiking trails in the Delaware Water Gap was convenient by car. And the hosts are very responsive! We'd come again!

great location, just like the pictures, beautiful home! and responsive host!

The place was secluded. the hot tub was perfect. The basement was real chill to hang out on a snowy icy evening

Great little weekend getaway. Super snowy weekend so wasn’t able to do much around town but the space was nice and cozy to relax in! Sam was super responsive and helped with anything we needed. Would definitely come back!

Ben’s cabin was beautiful! Such a lovely escape to a quiet spot in the woods. The hot tub is the best part :) the bathroom and kitchen are immaculate!

From the moment we walked in, we felt right at home—like we were stepping into a warm hug. The cabin is the perfect blend of cozy and quiet, making it an ideal escape. The book showcasing the cabin’s transformation during renovations—it was so cool to see the journey behind the space we were enjoying. And thank you for the homemade soap. Naomi is an incredible host, and this cabin is truly a gem. Can’t wait to come back!

I booked this cabin for a last minute getaway and was not disappointed. It's a very simple and rustic place that was exactly what we were looking for. It was close to many different options of places to visit and things to eat, but secluded enough to feel away from traffic and other people.

My wife and I stayed for a weekend away from home and the cabin was absolutely perfect. Lori was very proactive with all communications and made sure we didn't have any questions. Clear communication was also evident all over the cabin with labels and instructions everywhere so everything was easy to find. While the cabin isn't big and is in an area where there are few other cabins within eyesight, there was plenty of seating and great privacy. A larger family could stay there and be super comfortable and we felt like we had the woods to ourselves. For our needs, a quick getaway for the weekend, the cabin was fantastic and made us feel like we were away longer than we actually were. It was warm, cozy, private and backed by a super attentive host who clearly put a ton of thought into making the cabin a relaxing and easy rental.

Unbelievable time great value Mike and Debra are by far the best hosts. Made some great memories and some new friends.

We loved our stay! The cabin exceeded our expectations - it was perfectly cozy and had so many thoughtful details. The construction is amazing and felt really special. It did snow while we stayed and we weren't able to fully drive up the driveway (as warned!) but we parked at the end of the driveway and walked up. Not a big deal for us but something to keep in mind for anyone with accessibility needs. We stayed quite warm the whole time with the stove and heating system, and had plenty of hot water for the tub. Would highly recommend this for a getaway!

I loved staying in this home and hope to rent it again. It is just a few minutes from town and nestled in the woods. The place is beautifully decorated and has everything you need.

Comfortable cabin for family of 4. Nice to come home to an indoor fireplace and hot sauna after a day on the mountain. Only issue was with the coffeemaker and espresso machine. Promptly and proactively responded. (Paid for our coffees in town). Overall, we had a lovely stay in the Catskills.

This was truly one of the best Airbnb's we have ever stayed at - it looked exactly like the photos and had so many amenities and perks to make the weekend extremely relaxing. The hosts were proactive and super responsive, and we felt very welcome.

Amazing place for a quick weekend getaway from the city life! Pet friendly so you can bring your pups along to enjoy the outdoors!

This is the 3rd year we’ve stayed here and we always love coming back! The area is so quiet and peaceful with lots of space. There is a fire pit that we always utilize too. Highly recommend staying here for a quiet, relaxing vacation.

Book it! Jessica’s cabin is simply lovely. It is a perfect place to take your furry friends while you relax. The ambience is romantic, homely and cozy. She also offers everything you need to be comfortable; from kitchen appliances to books and bath tub accessories.

Spent a weekend with my family of 4 at this beautiful cabin house and could not have been more happier. The location is perfect. Secluded enough to have privacy and close enough to be near everything that you could possible need. We went to Kalahari water park for a day, which was only 20 minutes away. The cabin was clean and very spacious. It offered everything that you may need when staying with a family at an AirBnb. Tim was friendly and responsive!We appreciated him notifying us in advance to be careful because there was an ice storm that just hit. We would love to stay again in the warmer months and would highly recommend this property to anyone looking for the perfect little cabin getaway.

Despite the icy roads nearby, we had a great time. We went sledding and enjoyed watching the snow fall by the fire. Beautiful area! Make sure you have a 4x4 vehicle in the winter!

Host was very accommodating and generous . Please brings you back to simpler day just what we needed to get away from the city

Amazing place - perfect for romantic getaway just 2 hours from the city. The place is cute and has all things you need for a night in. They have the cutest alpacas and dogs, make sure to drop by their pen and say hi! The views, both at night and during the day, are amazing and we’d recommend carrying some firewood to light up a bonfire, a setup for which is, right outside the cabin. Cory and Sonia are amazing hosts. Our car got stuck in the snow in their driveway and they personally came and helped us get it out and also made sure to drop us back on the road in the morning. Amazing stay!

Lovely, peaceful, private cabin. Lisa was a fantastic and very responsive host throughout our stay. The directions and guest instructions were very clear, the place was exactly as described, check in and access were very straightforward. We look forward to our next visit.

Patrick was very good at communication. He reached out to make sure we got in ok, and also checked to make sure we were enjoying our stay. The house was a nice combination of old and new styles. The beds and blankets were very comfortable. The kitchen is small but well equipped and had everything we needed, and it was nice to sit all together at the dining table. We also enjoyed sitting by the fire and watching tv. The wildlife (deers) were wonderful to watch. Even though the yard was covered in icy snow the property was very pretty, and I’m sure in summer it’s even better. We loved it and would definitely recommend it if you are looking for a quiet retreat.

Cabin was very comfortable, clean, and easy to access. Had a Great weekend getaway and will definitely be booking again!

Jeanne’s home was cozy, warm and beautiful. The cabin and views are better in person. Safe, quiet community (would imagine it’s much busier in the warmer seasons). It was exactly what we were looking for. Even better that we were able to bring our pup along. Perfect little winter retreat. Thank you for having us!