House vacation rentals in Garden City

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Garden City

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A historic farmhouse, painted in white, is nestled among lush greenery. Tall trees provide shade, while the structure features green shutters and multiple entrances. The surrounding yard is well-maintained, showcasing a peaceful atmosphere within a natural setting.

Home in Atlantic Highlands

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Sea-renity in Navesink Home Away From Home

Join us for a relaxing stay at Sea-renity in Navesink, an oasis, your home away from home. Nestled in the historic district of Navesink Village, this tranquil renovated historic farmhouse built in the 1840’s, rests on over an acre of lush land with mature hardwood trees. Envision yourself experiencing the sounds and sights of nature, the nearby ocean surf, cultural aspects of the area: music, plays, theater, art, vast variety of cuisines, walks, a day at the beach, fishing, crabbing, and biking.

Guest favorite

A bright living room showcases a light-toned leather sofa set arranged around a marble coffee table. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, framed by soft curtains. A television is mounted on the wall, and a decorative wreath adds a seasonal touch.

Home in Port Washington

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Comfortable Entire House for rent. 4 bed, 3 baths

Spacious Entire Home! 4 bedrooms, 3 Baths, 4 car driveway, Hi speed WiFi, 70", (2)65" and 55" entertainment center, eat-in kitchen, living room, family room, dining room, jacuzzi with outdoor furniture in a private cul de sac. Pellegrino, Arizona, Starbucks, Dunkin, imported coffees and tea. Walking distance to the ocean, train, shops, tennis & golfing. This home, with modern comforts, is the perfect home-away-from-home for couples or families looking for a peaceful getaway right outside of NYC

Guest favorite

The exterior view showcases a bright, newly constructed home with white siding and a stone accent at the lower level. A spacious porch with seating is visible, along with a well-maintained lawn and a fenced yard, creating a welcoming entrance.

Home in Fairfield

5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Newly built twin beach house within steps to beach

Keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located home. Newly built in 2019! Premier beach living at its finest. Steps to Fairfield’s beaches and less than a mile to downtown restaurants, shops, and bars. Fenced backyard. Central air throughout. Decks off the front and back with a Weber grill. Furnished with luxury furniture, sheets, comforters, and pillows. Smart TVs in every bedroom and living room. Tesla charging station at the house. Identical home next door available for larger bookings

Guest favorite

A serene waterway is bordered by residential buildings and greenery, reflecting a clear blue sky. Several wooden docks extend into the water, providing access for boats. Lush grass lines the foreground, enhancing the peaceful, natural setting.

Home in Copiague

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Harbor Water Views

Situated just one house away from the picturesque Great South Bay on a quiet cul-de-sac, this rare gem in an American Venice setting boasts southern exposure and underwent updates in 2019. This charming residence is a 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom Classic Cape featuring a generously sized deck that was revamped in 2021. Conveniently located minutes away from shopping, beaches, and parks, this home provides a secluded retreat from the hustle and bustle, offering tranquility away from traffic and noise.

Guest favorite

The outdoor area features a spacious patio with seating, a table shaded by an umbrella, and a small fire pit. Play equipment and decorative plants enhance the yard, while the surrounding houses provide a quaint neighborhood backdrop.

Home in Keyport

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Visit the art cottage by the bay!

Vist this cute art filled house by the bay. This charming open planned home has a truly unique vibe perfect for small groups to get-a-way. The house has everything you need for a great beach weekend. Lovely gardens, patio and fire pit, hammocks, and more! 1 block from the bay with NYC views. 7 minute walk to downtown Keyport loaded with shopping, good food and nightlife. Boat launches, kayak rentals and jet skies in town. 15 minutes from Sandy Hook and several free beaches. All are welcome!

Top guest favorite

A spacious outdoor yard is featured, surrounded by trees and greenery. White lounge chairs and a small table are positioned on the grassy area, inviting relaxation. A hammock is visible in the background, adding to the tranquil outdoor setting.

Home in Northport

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Cool pad, Private Rms, Walk to village, Wtr view

Beautiful pad on a tranquil street and walkable neighborhood. 5-10 minute walk to the village and 2-minute walk to the cliffs overlooking the bay and sound. Water view from one bedroom, great outdoor yard - very private. Updated amenities, marble bathroom, cozy indoor living area and very comfortable beds. The rental space is private and is the entire first floor of the home. The home is a two-story duplex with a shared entrance and private locking doors to each space. Wonderful location.

Guest favorite

A view from the interior through a set of glass doors, showcasing tranquil waters and distant land. The scene highlights natural elements like tall grass along the shoreline, with a clear blue sky above.

Home in Milford

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

Designer Beach Retreat on Exclusive Cedar Beach

Welcome to your own slice of heaven! Enjoy dinner in your Chef's kitchen while watching one of the most radiant sunsets you will ever see. Stunning views from the private rear deck or snuggled on the couch inside the living room. Wade into Long Island Sound with semi-private beach access 250 feet away. The property is 5 doors down from the CT Audubon Society, known for its epic views and wildlife watching. The sunrises & sunsets are beautiful! 15 minutes to Yale. We can't wait to host you!

Superhost

A cozy living area features a large sectional sofa with decorative cushions, complemented by a plush armchair. Natural light is invited through two front windows, while a coffee table sits at the center, surrounded by green plants and framed art on the walls.

Home in Baldwin

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

Clarissa's Paradise

RESERVE NOW: This ideally located five-bedroom totally renovated home is the perfect spot for a family fun vacation. Located within walking distance of the well known playground and spray ground. The home features a spacious patio, central air conditioning, baseboard heating, WiFi, and Cable tv. The open layout provides perfect gathering spaces for your family, and all bedrooms are spacious and comfortably appointed. 4 full bathrooms . Sleeps 10. PLEASE NO PARTIES ARE STRICKLY PROHIBITED

Top guest favorite

A scenic view of sandy dunes is presented, dotted with green grass and leading up to nearby beach houses. A wooden walkway is visible, providing access to the beach area. The sky is clear and blue, enhancing the bright coastal atmosphere.

Home in Ocean Beach

5 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Sunny Spacious Pet Friendly Steps from the Beach

This ideally located four-bedroom home is the perfect spot for your family's vacation. The home features a spacious deck, central air conditioning, WiFi, 4 Smart TV's, a Sonos sound system and YouTube TV. The open layout provides perfect gathering spaces for your family, and all bedrooms are spacious and comfortably appointed. There are 2 full bathrooms as well as an outdoor shower. Fully equipped including beach chairs, towels, 5 bikes, 2 wagons and beach toys for the kids. Sleeps 10.

Superhost

A charming house is seen set among lush green trees, showcasing a light gray exterior. The front porch, framed by a wooden railing, invites relaxation. A white brick chimney adds character to the roofline, and several windows allow natural light to brighten the interior.

Home in Darien

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 197 reviews

Convenient and Cozy Antique Cape

Adorable little house in Darien CT, with a fireplace in winter and the beautiful local beaches in the summer. Right across from Trader Joe’s and around the corner from route 1 and Interstate 95, the little house is super convenient to local amenities. Probably the best perk of its central location is that it’s nestled behind Rorys, the best pub ever, so there’s no need to even cook if you are too busy or just don’t want to after working all day or a long day at the beach

Guest favorite

A balcony setting includes a small table surrounded by two lounge chairs with soft cushions, offering views of nearby water and homes. The sky above is clear and bright, enhancing the serene atmosphere of the space.

Home in Sea Bright

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Luxurious Sea Bright Home half block from beach!

Welcome to the PERFECT shore home in Sea Bright's PRIME location. Half a block from the beach with immediate beach access and half a block from the river. Walking distance to restaurants, bars, and surrounding towns. Short 5 min ride to the ferry (NYC). Enjoy your stay at the shore in a beautiful 3-bedroom home, with 3 balconies to watch the sunsets and beautiful water views, an outdoor shower, Weber Grill, and indoor Peleton and so much more! Do not pass on this home!

Top guest favorite

A spacious deck is featured, adorned with colorful flower planters and comfortable seating, overlooking a tranquil waterfront. Boats are docked along the wide canal, and the scenery includes calm waters and landscaped surroundings.

Home in Island Park

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Luxury Waterfront Home! Magnificent Views!

Beautiful newly built waterfront home with open floor plan. Huge Granite Island with five bar stools. Dining Table with six chairs. Huge Family room with 75” TV. Beautiful large custom made L shaped sofa that will easily seat 10-12 people. AWESOME WATERFRONT VIEWS. Watch the sun rise over the water! Comes with a boat slip and two jet ski ramps for your toys. Five minute car ride to the beach. Lots of great restaurants and bars with live music.

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

3-LEVE RETRO HOUSE/CLOSE TO BEACH, NYC, STAMFORD

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews6 months ago

Victoria was a gracious host - always quick to respond, flexible, and willing to assist. Entire process was easy from start to finish. In my opinion, the house was actually better in person than pictured in the listing. We were happily surprised with the cleanliness and comfort. The garage was a nice added value!

Home in Norwalk

What guests are saying

Beautiful whole house rental 2BR 2Bath

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews6 months ago

Angelique's home is absolutely charming and located in a lovely neighborhood. We were in town for a race at Jones Beach and loved how quiet and relaxing both her home and neighborhood were. The ground floor was very spacious and comfortable. The kitchen was very well stocked. Upstairs was quite cozy but there is also a bathroom on the main floor so my husband and I each "took" one. The home is very well located with easy access to local restaurants and coffee shops. Highly recommend.

Home in Amityville

What guests are saying

Private Bellport Gem with View!

5 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews2 months ago

We had a wonderful time in this home. It is big, and peaceful. The area is quiet, and this house is set way back from the road. The interior was charming and homey, with plenty of books and games for both adults and kids. There were plenty of spaces to sit and talk with friends, and then there were four bedrooms and several bathrooms with full baths to use. There is a huge loft space with lots of sitting room to catch up with people. The kitchen was spacious and equipped. The entire place felt like home. I wish we could’ve come during nicer weather, because the outdoor space and pool looked really nice too. Highly recommend!!

Home in Bellport