Cottage vacation rentals in Fair Haven

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Fair Haven

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Cottage in Sandy Creek

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 275 reviews

🌙 Olde Salem A-Frame Cottage 🔮 near Lake Ontario

You are steps away from witnessing the greatest sunsets along North Sandy Pond (across from Lake Ontario) when you stay at our relaxing, unique, and cozy A-frame - inspired by all things magical and earthy. Sit by the backyard fire, sip coffee by the electric fireplace, read a book in the bedroom nook, play board games, dance in the kitchen, and enjoy four seasons of nearby activities such as fishing, kayaking, boating, jet skiing, hiking, swimming, ice fishing, snowmobiling, and snowshoeing.

Superhost

A wooden deck overlooks the calm waters of Lake Ontario, with vibrant greenery in the foreground. The sky is clear with hints of clouds, creating a serene atmosphere. The peaceful view showcases the gentle waves lapping against the shoreline.

Cottage in Pulaski

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 59 reviews

Cozy LAKE ONTARIO WATERFRONT Breathtaking Views!

Enjoy a soothing stay at our cozy LAKE ONTARIO WATERFRONT cottage! This is a private residence that features an open floor plan with large windows to enjoy the stunning water views and unbelievable sunsets over the Lake. Relax on the full length spacious deck offering comfortable seating and listen to the blissful sound of waves gently crashing on the beach! The property has been recently renovated and offers nice, clean and stylish furnishings and amenities for your vacation. Perfect for 2.

Guest favorite

A serene view of Sodus Bay is captured, showcasing a sailboat gliding through the water alongside a larger boat. Lush greenery frames the shoreline, where cottages and trees are visible. The tranquil surface of the bay reflects the clear blue sky above.

Cottage in Sodus Point

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Bayside Getaway

Relax at the Getaway, a charming cottage overlooking Ontario's Great Sodus Bay. NOTE: weekly Saturday-to-Saturday bookings only during summer. Perfect for golfing, fishing, ice-fishing, beach-going, boating, apple-picking, hiking, or simply... getting away. Equipped for long & short stays. Adjacent to Sodus Bay Heights Golf Club. Short drive to Sodus Bay Beach, Beechwood State Park, Chimney Bluff State Park and many public and private access points. (All lake/beach access requires driving.)

Superhost

A wooden staircase descends through lush greenery toward the lakefront. Two Adirondack chairs sit at the bottom of the stairs, positioned for views of the water. The path leads to a private dock, partially visible over the tranquil blue lake.

Cottage in Skaneateles

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 241 reviews

Skaneateles Lake Cottage - Private Retreat!

The summertime on Skaneateles Lake awaits our next guests! Reserve a week or a weekend to enjoy Lake Life and Summer in Skaneateles! Looking to book an extended stay or a short romantic getaway? Enjoy all the comforts of home in this remodeled and very spacious lake cottage. Just a short stroll down a private path to your own lake front with spectacular views. Complete with a huge master bedroom with partial lake views and ensuite bathroom! Don’t delay reserve our lake cottage today!

Guest favorite

A fire pit area features several black Adirondack chairs arranged in a circle on a grassy lawn. A tranquil waterway is visible in the background, bordered by lush greenery. A small dock with a boat is positioned along the water's edge.

Cottage in Wolcott

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 67 reviews

Waterfront w/kayaks, fire pit, pedal boat, grill

Relax & unwind at our cozy cottage nestled hillside among the serenity of nature, 5 houses down a waterfront tributary leading into Port Bay with access to Lake Ontario. Perfect for nature lovers, fishing trips, or friends & families looking to slow down together and enjoy the outdoors together. A serene rural home base to explore small town America. Activities include enjoying the fire pit, kayaking or boating on the bay, observing the abundance of wildlife, fishing, playing games & more!

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Pulaski

5 out of 5 average rating, 81 reviews

Cozy 3-Br Lake Ontario cottage with sunset views

Our 3-bedroom lakefront cottage is the perfect gathering place for fishing groups, friends, and family to relax and make memories. Located right on Lake Ontario, and just 10 minutes from the mouth of the Salmon River, our family camp offers an open concept gathering space and lakefront deck outside, where you'll enjoy picture perfect sunsets. Stocked with linens, towels, full kitchen, WiFi, a Smart TV, washer/dryer and more, we make it easy to unwind after a day of exploring. Welcome!

Guest favorite

The exterior of Peppermint Cottage is framed by lush greenery and colorful flower beds, with vibrant pink and white blooms surrounding the pathway. A rustic wooden fence adds charm, while the front porch features a welcoming entrance and an American flag. Natural sunlight fills the scene.

Cottage in Lyons

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 443 reviews

Peppermint Cottage

Nestled in peaceful Upstate N.Y., between Finger Lakes Wine Country and Lake Ontario and right in the heart of the Erie Canal is the Peppermint Cottage. The Peppermint Cottage is a unique destination. The Peppermint Cottage is a place for guests to “Step Back in Time” and experience the simple pleasures of life including a warm fire, relaxing under the stars in a hot tub, sauna or strolling our gardens. Family friendly establishment. Birders, bicyclists and outdoor enthusiasts welcome.

Guest favorite

A private wooden dock extends into calm waters, surrounded by lush greenery and tall grasses. The stillness of the water reflects the natural landscape, inviting moments of tranquility. The expansive grassy area leads up to the water's edge, enhancing the sense of space.

Cottage in Sandy Creek

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

North Sandy Pond Cottage with lot on Skinner Creek

Immerse yourself in the beauty of nature as you enjoy views of Skinner Creek, which flows into North Sandy Pond, providing direct access to the waters of Lake Ontario. You'll have exclusive use of the private dock and fire pit. The road is not busy and great for walking. There are nearby marinas that provide paid boat launches and a public boat launch is also less than five miles away. A short drive away, you'll discover several breathtaking beaches! There is a limit of 2 dogs.

Superhost

The exterior view of the property showcases a welcoming deck leading to the water. A large umbrella provides shade over the seating area, while a private dock extends into the lake, offering easy access to the water. Lush grass borders the deck.

Cottage in Seneca Falls

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

FingerLakes Spectacular Cayuga Lake Best Location!

Lake Front on Cayuga Lake with GREAT views, a SUPER Deck, 2 Private Bedrooms, and 2 full bathrooms. The lake views are spectacular. Welcome to the heart of New York State Finger Lakes. Wake up to the gorgeous amazing sunrises. Enjoy the Dock on the water. Walk to the Cayuga State Park with beach, playground, boat launch, more! Enjoy unforgettable full moons or make all the wishes you want by spotting falling stars at night from our unobstructed deck. Up to 4 people

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area features large windows that provide views of Sodus Bay. Natural light fills the room, enhancing the warm tones of the area rug. A comfortable couch and a side chair are arranged around a coffee table, creating a welcoming space for relaxation.

Cottage in Sodus Point

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

Jameson Bay Inn on Sodus Bay (Waterfront)

The Jameson Bay Inn is a completely remodeled cottage which sits on Sodus Bay. This upscale cottage has ample parking, all of the amenities your family may need while on vacation, and gorgeous views of Sodus Bay. The large master bedroom even has views of Lake Ontario! The Jameson Bay Inn includes dock space for a boat, jetskis, and/or kayaks - great for fishing! There is also a beautiful patio only steps away from the water where you can enjoy watching boats and wildlife.

Superhost

A serene lakeside deck features a fire pit, surrounded by two comfortable chairs. The tranquil surface of the lake reflects the soft colors of a sunset, creating a peaceful outdoor atmosphere.

Cottage in Mannsville

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Serene 3-Bedroom Cottage on a Lake Ontario

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. This cozy cottage is surrounded by water and is a perfect escape from busy life. A deck overlooks Ontario lake and a spiral staircase leads you to the rock beach with direct access to the water. The Renshaw Bay offers great fishing and kayaking opportunities. This kitchen was built for entertaining and the enclosed patio offers prime gathering space. Come be one with nature at the cozy cottage!

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the cottage is shown, featuring a sloped metal roof and a grey siding. An American flag is displayed near the entrance, complemented by a vibrant green grassy area and trees that create a serene atmosphere.

Cottage in Sandy Creek

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 76 reviews

*Newly renovated* White Birches Cottage

You are a short walk away from North Sandy Pond (across from Lake Ontario) when you stay at our newly renovated and relaxing cottage. You can stay in and warm up by the electric fireplace, cook a full meal with our fully stocked kitchen, sit around the outside fire pit, or enjoy four seasons of nearby activities such as fishing, kayaking, boating, jet skiing, hiking, swimming, ice fishing, snowmobiling, and snowshoeing.

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

Cozy Cottage in Sandy Pond 2

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews4 months ago

We love staying at this cabin! It is clean, has the necessary amenities to include a washer and dryer. We always use the coffee maker and feel right at home in the morning in front of the electric fire place. This is our second time booking and we recommend this location.

Cottage in Pulaski

What guests are saying

The Gate - Chapman House. Short walk to town

5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews3 months ago

We have stayed at many Airbnb’s across the country and this is by far one of the best! Clean, quiet, well stocked, and in a perfect location (in walking distance to town). Lynn was very responsive and gave us recommendations for things to do in the area. Our hosts thought of everything. We highly recommend staying at The Gate. We’ll be back soon!

Cottage in Skaneateles

What guests are saying

Fabulous Fall Foliage Retreat

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews6 months ago

Very clean and cozy camp at the lake. Bonnie was very helpful and quick to respond to messages. The place was well stocked and the views are amazing! It was a little chilly in the bathroom but we understand that it’s a seasonal home. We would probably stay here again.

Cottage in Skaneateles

What guests are saying

Cozy lakeside fishing retreat.

5 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews2 weeks ago

Me and my family enjoyed our stay so much here! we loved how quiet it was and how close we were to the water to be able to throw a couple fishing lines out. we loved being able to see the water from the living room sofa as well! parking was easy, and we felt comfortable and cozy the whole stay! we are looking forward to coming back sometime in the future! Eric and Sharon were very helpful!

Cottage in Brewerton

What guests are saying

The Cabin at Sodus Point, 5 Bedrooms

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 83 reviews6 months ago

Home had enough beds for our whole group and plenty of pots and pans for us to cook. Nice to have TVs in every room for kids to unwind at night, and you can’t beat the short walk to the beautiful beach on Lake Ontario as well as the walk to the lighthouse.

Cottage in Sodus Point

What guests are saying

Stunning Lake Views From This Artistic Getaway

5 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews6 months ago

“Ventura Lake House “ is nothing short of magical. The cottage is so comfortable and eclectic, furniture with fascinating pieces of art made by the hosts. The living room and bedrooms were extremely comfortable as was every space on the property, inside and outdoors. The kitchen was perfectly outfitted with anything a person might need. Christine even left a special birthday treat for our son and croissants as well as many staples in the fridge. Our favorite part was sitting on an Adirondack chair just watching and listening to Lake Ontario. We will definitely be back again and again. So grateful that Christine and Paul offer this beautiful place — and their many creative talents — for others to enjoy! Thank you!

Cottage in Sodus

What guests are saying

Lake side cottage Sterling/ Fair Haven, NY

4.52 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews9 months ago

We have been here many times before, know what to expect and love the quiet, the fire flies, the proximity to the Nature Center and the intentional wildness around Bills cabin. This is a setting for people who can walk up stairs to get into the cabin. Once there, everything is on one floor, but not really wheelchair accessible. Beds are comfortable. Great deck and bbq. Sometimes phone and internet connections are difficult because of its location. You need to bring your own condiments except salt and pepper, and bring a good frying pan! be aware and prepared for the possibility of ticks and poison ivy. Bring long pants, etc for walking in tall grass at the Nature Preserve. Bill was very receptive to a couple of small things that needed attention and was great about doing something about them asap. It is a place of great beauty!

Cottage in Sterling

What guests are saying

All-Season Waterfront Cottage in Owasco Lake

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews7 months ago

Sonia’s house was great. Perfect location, beautiful setting. The depth of water was excellent for our young children, as well as the availability of a kayak and paddle boards. When we had questions Sonia was very quick to respond. We were disappointed that the dock wasn’t in the water as pictured, but the location was still worth it. We would come back again!

Cottage in Auburn

What guests are saying

Lakefront Cottage- Come Relax at The Shore House

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews4 months ago

The stay was absolutely wonderful! The house was impeccably clean, creating a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The view was nothing short of breathtaking, offering a perfect backdrop for relaxation and unforgettable moments. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience!

Cottage in Oswego

What guests are saying

The Lake Nest

5 out of 5 average rating, 77 reviews2 months ago

This was our second time staying at the Lake Nest and we enjoyed it just as much as the first! Drew and Kirsten are attentive and accommodating hosts that have thought of everything to make the stay enjoyable. The cottage is quiet. clean, and cozy- feels like home. Will definitely recommend to friends/family!

Cottage in Ontario

1 of 12 pages