House vacation rentals in Central Islip

Great little place to stay right by the bay.

My family and I had a beautiful stay and I couldn’t have asked for a better rental. The Airbnb was huge with more than enough room for everyone and the backyard was large and spacious enough to have everyone eat comfortably. If I ever need another large rental you can bet I’m gonna check here first.

Gaby’s place was clean and comfortable! She is very kind and it was exactly what we needed for the week. Her check in instructions and directions were thorough and the home is in a beautiful area. Already have our next stay booked :)

I was in Dion’s place with my family we really enjoyed the time we spent there,everything was perfect the pool was something that my kids enjoyed a lot, and hopefully we will come back again, for sure I totally recommend his house if you want to go and have a couple days of fun and relax thank you again Dion.

Worth the stay. Worth checking out. Good center location to highways if you need a Long Island retreat. Likely an excellent venue for a local sleepover, small birthday or gathering, holiday, special treat for your family. Highly recommend the host and can’t brag enough about the property. Cozy, cool and fun, the backyard will immediately transport you to an oasis in Florida. Stay here to get great ideas on what to do with your own home to make it the resort you’d love to stay!

Place was clean and reasonably priced for the area. Conveniently furnished with many kitchen appliances. Moderately noisy from the traffic (as you can expect close to the road) and typical noise from the rest of the house. Johnna was very easy to communicate with. Got greeted by a very cute cat as we parked outside :)

Five stars doesn't feel like enough, if anything I'd say everything was better than we'd expected based on the pictures and the reviews! First, as others have mentioned John was an incredible host, the place was well stocked and had all sorts of snacks and drinks (and a nice bottle of wine); he also bought us dinner and was very good about keeping in touch the whole time we were there. The house was amazing top to bottom, but I have to specifically call out the pool, which was jaw-droppingly beautiful and the perfect temperature despite cold weather outside. We loved the neighborhood and yard to walk our dogs, and the kitchen was great to cook in (made me miss having a gas stovetop). We'll definitely be visiting again, it was the kind of stay that sets a new bar for what to look for in a vacation!

A lovely stay for my brother in-law. Very comfortable with easy check-in and fast communication. Exactly what we needed!

So glad we stayed at John's beachfront home. We wanted a way to escape the noise and chaos of a large city and this was the perfect fit. Granted the commute is longer, but we couldn't get enough of the amazing ferry ride from Rockaway to Manhattan/Wall Street. Such a great way to explore NYC.

Kathy’s home was exactly as described spacious, clean, and incredibly inviting. I traveled with a large group of my friends, and we never felt on top of each other. Kathy was extremely accommodating & communicative when it came to checking in and checking out of the Airbnb,along with recommendations to eat on the island or close by. The home was an effortless walk to the beach and to center of town. If you were coming to enjoy fire Island with a large group of people, I would absolutely recommend this space!

Clean, quiet, easy. Close to where I was going for work. Would absolutely stay again.

Great space. Wonderful communication with host regarding any questions we had. Host was quick to respond. Very happy with the stay, would rent again.

Victoria's place was wonderful! It was spacious and comfortable and gave our family plenty of room to spread out and enjoy our visit. Victoria was a very responsive host and made check in and check out stress free and easy! There was ample parking for our cars and the house was private - it was the "house behind the house" so we weren't subject to busy traffic noise on the street. (Got a little confusing for DoorDash drivers but we worked it out :D). I will book this same place next time I am up for an extended weekend with the family. Highly recommend!

The inside and outside areas were meticulously maintained. The weather was great, so we were able to really enjoy the pool and deck. Michelle was extremely responsive and did a great job with instructions, recommendations, and communications. One member of our party needed to work a few days, and the office space in the basement was perfect.

My family and I had very specific needs for a 1 night stay in the Hamstead area and Romaine's place checked all the boxes. 2 separate beds in one private room, and another bed in another private room was exactly what we were looking for for a couple with 2 kids. The bathroom was clean and good sized. The entire place was clean and comfortable, with 2 TV's, a mini fridge stocked with bottled water , microwave, coffee maker and everything you wound need for all of those amenities. Street parking was no problem at all and the house is situated in a nice neighborhood. The host had great communication and everything was explained very clearly. I think this place is suitable for one person and up to 4, and possibly 5 given the futon in the room. I accidentally left a personal item of great importance to me there. The host immediately responded to me when I asked about it and mailed it back to me. It was my mistake and an inconvenience for the host, this says a lot about the host.

Please stay here and support Nicole.. what a wonderful host Comfortable, clean and safe home Snow storm hit overnight and we woke up to the sidewalk and steps already shoveled and salted … she even offered to dig out our car if the snow was piled up high enough Nicole was very proactive with great communication but we did not feel bothered Plenty of street parking right by the house We really enjoyed watching the ducks and other water fowl in the stream behind the house A little bit of nature to relax after a day in the city Thanks Nicole, we will be back to stay in your home again

Excellent location. An easy inexpensive ride into Penn Station via LLRR. A suggestion: I recommend those luggage racks one finds in hotels for your suitcase in each bedroom. That, or foot of bed benches. There is no closet for the small bedroom, so a place for your suitcase would be great. A chair in the small bedroom would also help.

Perri was a very responsive and accommodating host. The check in process was easy and flexible. The location was quiet and an easy walk to the subway.

Place was really great for our family with 3 teenagers. A lot of space, clean, with a beautiful view on a huge garden ! Perfect location for discovering the area. Juan was very helpful, very easy to communicate. Thank you Juan !

The stay was great. Our host was accommodated and great with communication. Would love to come back!

Very respectable, responsive and courteous couple! Proactive in solving your issues. Felt like home

AIi’s a great host. The house was as described, very spacious and well kept. Check-in was super easy as Ali sent me all the info 2 days before. The house is in a great location and everything is within driving distance. There’s also a YMCA 1 minute away which we used for workouts. Ali was also very responsive throughout our stay and made sure we were comfortable.

The house was absolutely beautiful well cap very clean and organize. I rented this place for Christmas so there was ample items that we found usable to make a beautiful Christmas table presentation. I would highly recommend this place again. Thank you Martha for your hospitality.

Hands-down, one of our favorite AirBnbs ever! I feel like I could’ve lived there. Just a lovely little cottage sequestered away from the main drag in Bellport, which is one of the most quaint and adorable villages on Long Island. We just loved it and we will be back again! The owners mentioned the size of the shower, well my husband is 6 foot 2 and had no trouble in the shower at all, although it was maybe a little tight. But the water pressure was wonderful and we had no problems at all. Thank you, Rafael!