Vacation rentals with a pool in Cayuga Lake

We loved this place!! There was so many amenities that we weren’t able to use because we weren’t in the house a ton as we were in a wedding, but boy did we miss out on them! We had a perfect stay and would absolutely stay again if we were ever in the area again. No complaints at all!

This by far our favorite vacation spot! We have come here countless times because of how much we love it. Less than 15 minutes to strong museum! Neil is super responsive and listens to feedback! We asked for kids board games at the house and he was able to provide! Can’t wait to come back

This place is beautiful if you’re looking for something close to Watkins Glenn and easy access to the breweries and wineries! It was very clean and Mallory communicated well. She leaves you snacks and tea/coffee to start your day!! Definitely will be back in the summer time.

This place was spectacular! Our family had an amazing time. It was everything we wanted and allowed us to focus on making incredible memories together. Thank you for sharing your home with us!

Great place! We do Christmas experiences, and this year it was here. My adult son and husband walked on ice for the first time! (Carefully.) We were able to spread out and all have our own spaces. Game room was wonderful. The lake view was beautiful. A lot of our time was spent sitting on the couch watching TV (with that view of the lake!) or around the dining room table talking and building legos, in the hot tub. It was wonderful.

We had a wonderful stay at Scott’s beautiful lakeside home at the Finger Lakes! We stayed for three days to celebrate my wife's birthday, and this serene spot made it truly special. The house is peaceful and perfectly situated by the lake, providing a perfect escape. Scott was incredibly responsive and proactive—he made sure we had all the instructions we needed in advance, and the home was equipped with all the necessary amenities to make our stay comfortable. It was clear he put thought into ensuring a smooth experience for his guests. We highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a relaxing and memorable stay!

We had a wonderful stay at Eddie’s home! He was very responsive and provided clear instructions for check-in and check-out, making everything seamless. The house was exactly as described—clean, cozy, and well-stocked with everything we needed, including complimentary 1911 canned drinks, travel-sized toiletries, and a fully equipped kitchen. The Peloton bike was a great bonus, especially before our Thanksgiving dinner! The location does require climbing a large hill from Route 20, which we were initially nervous about due to the weather forecast, but the road was well-maintained and it didn’t end up being an issue. The neighborhood was peaceful and the house has stunning views. We can only imagine how beautiful it is in the fall, or how fun the pool would be in warmer months. We’d definitely stay here again, ideally during nicer weather to fully enjoy the outdoor amenities.

Dean and his place are great, our stay was peaceful without any hiccups or surprises, everything was as described and pictures mimiced the listing to a T. We will absolutely return!

Second time staying at Marks house and we loved it yet again! Very clean, nice layout, and conveniently located. Plus, the park across the street was great for our dogs. Would love to come back on the summer!