Vacation rentals with a pool in Cayuga Lake

We loved this place!! There was so many amenities that we weren’t able to use because we weren’t in the house a ton as we were in a wedding, but boy did we miss out on them! We had a perfect stay and would absolutely stay again if we were ever in the area again. No complaints at all!

5/5 – A Perfect Family Getaway We had an incredible stay and truly didn’t want to leave. The home was ideal for a family vacation—comfortable, well-equipped, and full of thoughtful touches. My children were devastated to go! We had planned a few small adventures in the surrounding area, but they were so happy in the pool that we barely left the property. We came during spring break from upstate New York, where it was still snowing, so the warm weather and sunshine were a much-needed reprieve. The house had everything we needed: Netflix, Alexa, a garage full of pool noodles and floaties, and a lovely selection of children’s books that my toddlers adored. One of the most heartwarming moments was when Neil kindly gifted my daughter a stuffed cat she had fallen in love with—it meant so much to her and to us. This was the kind of stay that creates lasting memories. We can’t wait to come back.

Thank you, Mallory, for the lovely stay. The house was spotless and very cozy and your thoughtful touches made us feel right at home. We appreciated your quick responses. The location is perfect as it's only a 10 minute drive to Watkins Glen State Park. Definitely would recommend.

Beautiful, private spot. Clean and spacious. The first Airbnb in which I’ve stayed whose kitchen had everything needed and wanted. We were there late winter but I can imagine it is wonderful during the summer with the pool. Close to Wegmans; within 30 minutes of Rochester museums and Canandaigua Lake.

We had a wonderful stay at Scott’s beautiful lakeside home at the Finger Lakes! We stayed for three days to celebrate my wife's birthday, and this serene spot made it truly special. The house is peaceful and perfectly situated by the lake, providing a perfect escape. Scott was incredibly responsive and proactive—he made sure we had all the instructions we needed in advance, and the home was equipped with all the necessary amenities to make our stay comfortable. It was clear he put thought into ensuring a smooth experience for his guests. We highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a relaxing and memorable stay!

We had another lovely stay at the Hobbit House. It’s our go-to place when we’re visiting relatives in the area. Andrea is always helpful! Waking up to the assorted farm animals in the morning is a pleasure!

We had a great weekend! And will be back again. Thanks Eddie!

We chose Villa Vino for our annual girls trip and were more than happy with our choice! The cottage is beautiful and cozy, with lots of amenities to enjoy and lots of places to visit close by. Dean was an incredibly responsive and helpful host. We had an amazing time!

Host was extremely responsive. Home is beautiful and very large and matches online photos. There was some confusion about the bathrooms 1 full bath was in the basement. We had a number of challenges that could not be anticipated in the home and the host was very responsive.