Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Brighton

The houses managed by Christina and Historic Houseparts are truly gems in the Airbnb world. My husband and our five kids visit Rochester twice a year to see family, so we have a lot of experience with Airbnbs. I am always looking for something interesting, preferably historic, and am generally disappointed, except when we stay in these homes. It is truly a joy and luxury to be in a home that has been thoughtfully restored, decorated, and supplied without skimping. While there are aspects of an old home like bedroom doors not closing flush and awkward tiny staircases, we are willing to overlook a lot for a vacation in a cool home like this. I really appreciated the small fans in each bedroom and a really well stocked kitchen (large stockpots and mixers in Airbnbs are few and far between!). All the historic books on Rochester were exactly to our taste, too. The price point makes this stay a steal. Can’t recommend enough!!

Host was accommodating and generous. Also very quick to respond via chat! The house was exactly as pictured and perfect for four adults. Will definitely be back next time I visit family in Rochester!

This was our second stay here - we loved it so much the first time we stayed that we decided it will be our "go to" when home visiting family. The house is very clean, the perfect size for us and we feel very comfortable here. Great kitchen!

Wow! What a spectacular place! My little family of 6 went on a quick weekend getaway and we all fell in love with this house and did not want to leave. The upstairs rooms had their own fireplaces which were a nice touch. Kept the kids extra warm throughout the night. The master suite is stunning. The view alone, I could lay in that bed all day just staring out the window. And what an incredible bathroom! The shower felt like I was in a spa or resort. The bathtub was fantastic. I need this bathroom in my own house. The kitchen was open to the rest of the downstairs area and had a perfect view outside and to the lake. Also, it was fully stocked with any and everything. Tupperware, spices, utensils, coffee machine, you name it, it was there. Everything you’d want in an air bnb as an adult. Now, if you’re a kid (or even just a kid a heart) what a treat the basement was for everyone! The show stopper was definitely the movie room. I could go on and on! Can’t wait to go back!

We had an incredible stay at this rental! The indoor pool was absolutely fantastic - a highlight of our trip. Check- in and check-out were seamless, and Neil was wonderful to communicate with - responsive, friendly, and helpful. The location was ideal, with easy access to resturants and groceries. The kitchen was well appointed and had everything we needed to cook meals comfortably. Overall, this rental exceeded our expectations, and we will definitely stay here again. Highly recommend.

We enjoyed our long weekend. We had an issue with an outlet not working and they came right over to look at it. They thought of most everything to make our stay nice and easy. Would definitely recommend.

We had a great girl's weekend getaway at Michelle's cottage on Lake Canandaigua. It is so quiet and peaceful we just loved it. Everything was perfect...location, things to do, great restaurants, clean, warm, friendly people and beautiful scenery. What more can you ask for? I would definitely return if I was going to the Finger Lakes again. Thanks Michelle for a wonderful weekend!

Every time I visit, I feel that it's my home. Thank you!

Second time staying here, always lovely. Great location close to highland park, mt hope cemetery, bars, breweries, coffee and restaurants. Alecia is SO great at communicating, and a wonderful and kind host. I stayed over the Christmas holiday and I walked in to see a Christmas tree, fireplace playing on the tv, and adorable holiday decor. She is so thoughtful!

This home is full of history and feels so magical. From the charming antiques to the glowing candles throughout. It had such a warm and cozy ambience. This was by far the cleanest Airbnb we’ve ever stayed at. Robin was an amazing host and so accommodating and responsive. We had zero issues during our stay.

Comfortable and convenient.

This is not the first time my family has stayed at this AirBnB, and we will continue to book it each time my family members come to visit me in Rochester. Beautiful house right on park avenue, which means some of Rochester’s most fantastic restaurants, bakeries, and coffee shops are within walking distance. The description and pictures match the home exactly. The decor in the home is really nice, and everything is very modern and clean. The hosts are very kind and responsive, and provide local recommendations for things to do. The dedicated parking spot in the back is awesome especially on such a busy street. Can’t recommend this place enough!

The apartment was so cozy and comfortable - and super cute too! Walkable to downtown, easy to get around, and parking was a breeze. Benton and Sarah were so kind and nice - and the apartment is exactly as described. We stayed for a full week and the apartment truly felt like home.

Had an amazing stay at Paula’s place over Thanksgiving. The town is walkable and there are many cute restaurants to try! The place is very cozy, stocked with everything you could need during a stay. We were there over Thanksgiving and it was cold but her place was warm and cozy! Definitely go to the Greentown restaurant for drinks or local beers and amazing wings! For brunch check out Simply Crepes! Both places are just a few blocks away.

What a beautiful place Michael and Tricia have! The place smelled really good and they had lots of stocked items such as snacks, drinks, and toiletries if you forgot anything, they had it! Very peaceful and quiet with a gorgeous surrounding. Highly recommend staying here and will definitely come back when we decide on another trip to New York. I forgot to mention that they are super friendly and very responsive with our questions.

My mom and I enjoyed our stay in Rob's "Crib" very much. We enjoyed the mix of an older home and modern decor. There are plenty of easy uses for the lights, ceiling fans and TV. The driveway is a little narrow but we managed. Thanks for everything Rob!

Staying at the Sugar House Cabin at Kettle Ridge Farm was an absolute delight! The location strikes the perfect balance – close to everything we needed, yet secluded enough to feel like a peaceful retreat. It’s the ideal getaway if you’re looking to unwind and disconnect, while still being within easy reach of local attractions and conveniences. The cabin itself was spotless upon arrival, exactly as described in the listing. It’s clear that the owners take great care in maintaining the property, and their attention to detail didn’t go unnoticed. The home felt cozy and welcoming, with every amenity thoughtfully provided. The kitchen was incredibly well-equipped – far beyond what you’d typically expect – making it easy to prepare meals without missing a thing. This cabin is hands-down a much better alternative than staying at a traditional hotel. It offers a unique and personal experience that you simply can’t find elsewhere. We left fe

Wow!!!! Amazing home. So beautiful and big. So clean and just overall amazing we had such a good time!!!!✨ Thank you Addison

My family and I stayed here for about a week. The place was extremely private! The kitchen was very well equipped, allowing us to cook and grill most days. Everythjng was very clean and well maintained.

great place for golfers hunters and fishermen. tucked away in a wooded area with a fair distance between Neighbors. it would be very hard to disturb them even with late night campfire sing along! nice game room clean barbecue and all the utensils and appliances that you could possibly want.

Great little spot by beautiful Lake Conesus. Convenient location, the space was clean and comfortable and had everything we needed for a few day stay! Donald was great with communication and quick to respond when we needed the heat turned on. Recommended!

The cabin was wonderful!! Beautiful decorated with all needed amenities and very cozy. The Christmas tree was a really nice touch! We loved the area, private pond and wildlife. All instructions was super helpful to navigate and made our stay even more relaxing. This is a wonderful place to stay and close to many local towns and beautiful Canandaigua lake! We absolutely recommend this cabin!