Vacation rentals in Witmer

Wonderful house with truly comfortable furniture. I actually photographed some of the furniture and manufacturer's tags to get those chairs and sofa for home. Mattress (king) also excellent. I stayed 5 days for work, and didn't want to leave. Super convenient for hiking on Neversink, too. It is not completely private since you may see hikers going by, and as an older female staying alone, I was aware of that. But there are plenty of shades including blackout and I got used to it. The view, before leaves come out, is awesome, the Mt. Penn neighborhood and Pagoda lit up at night, and the Howard Street Bridge, love it. Time to read the Updike "Rabbit" books again. One tip, make sure the upper shower knob is pointed down, or you will get a cold overhead blast from the other shower head. Otherwise all appliances and amenities are terrific! Thank you Denise for your quick and friendly communication and nice greeting card. Would stay again.

John was great to work with and worked with us to meet our needs as we, unfortunately, were in town for a funeral. The house was great and had everything we needed. We appreciated very much the flexibility that John offered.

The house was just what was promised. Beautiful home in a beautiful setting. The amenities were a promised. The directions and information provided were very helpful. It was easy to find what we needed/wanted and the signage in the kitchen was great. The deck was lovely - even tho' there was only 1 day warm enough for us to actually use it. Thanks so much for hosting us. We loved our stay.

Great family vacation spot! Close to all the Hershey attractions. We enjoyed all the amenities like the Cornhole, swings, and fire pit. Place was clean. Fully stocked kitchen was perfect for making a home cooked meal one night. You can tell a lot of thought was put into this place to make it a 5 star stay. Highly recommend!

Very nice and spacious house. Amazing views. Our family really enjoyed staying here and we would be happy to return next time we are visiting the area.

The barn is beautiful. Situated on a pond, this place is perfect for families or anyone looking for breath of fresh air. The hosts were extremely communicative and went above and beyond to ensure our stay was as smooth as possible. There are many areas of the property to explore - fishing in the pond, chickens, fire pit, and hot tub. The barn itself was very clean and had everything we needed. We will be back!

This little quaint place was what me and my honey needed! It was small yet spacious and it was the cutest thing I’ve ever seen. It’s exactly how it looked in the photos. The host was responsive and super helpful, and that was very appreciated!!! If we are ever in the area again we will definitely be staying there!!

We had an amazing stay at the Wilkum House! It was extremely clean and had AMAZING decor throughout the entire house. The bathroom and kitchen are extremely nice and very clean. The backyard is even like a little getaway. The location of this place is ideal for hitting all the important parts of downtown Lancaster! Would absolutely stay again!

Very remote place we seen a lot of wildlife from the house and when we walked the trails..Dave and Barb were very helpful with everything thank you for sharing this beautiful place with us we hope to come back soon..