Vacation rentals in Sugar Loaf Cay

We so enjoyed our romantic escape to Brandon and Lucy's place. It was EXACTLY as described and pictured. There were no surprises: it was spotless, well stocked, and very comfortable. The space is airy, bright, comfortable, and romantic. Perfect for an overworked professional couple to unwind and relax. We left only once--for dinner at Colors--and otherwise soaked up the stunning, unparalleled views and paddle boarded and snorkelled all day. You won't want to leave! It's hard to find privacy like this. Brandon was very responsive and helpful, from helping us log into his hulu account (we are from canada and don't have hulu) to providing yoga mats. He also gave us great tips on where to find the best reefs for snorkelling. Lucy was very kind as well. Really the perfect hosts: we felt very welcome! Roland, the caretaker, is very friendly and helpful. He delivered a SUP on request and even cleaned a conch shell for me when he saw me admiring one. So thoughtful. We will be returning!

Treasure Time is absolutely beautiful. Very clean and comfortable The kitchen is well stocked with pots pans and utensils Beds were very comfortable rooms were welled cooled Definitely would recommend

Clem's Surf Shack on the Beach was absolutely incredible! From the moment we arrived, we were blown away by the breathtaking ocean views and the peaceful, private setting. The villa was well maintained, clean, and had all the amenities we needed for a fun and relaxing stay. Waking up to the sound of waves and enjoying sunrises on the beach was truly amazing. The beach was just steps away, with soft sand and turquoise water—perfect for swimming, looking for seashells, and watching stunning sunsets. The host, Clem, was fantastic—very responsive to texts and easy to get a hold of whenever we had a question. Whether we were exploring the nearby islands or just unwinding by the shore, this villa was the perfect home base. Highly recommend for anyone looking for an escape to paradise. We can't wait to return!

We had the best time at Maranatha Cottage and are already discussing our return. The cottage was beautiful and we enjoyed early mornings sitting on the porch with coffee overlooking the harbour. Green Turtle Cay has always been a special place to me and my family and I could not have asked for a better place to stay during our visit. Gregory was wonderful and Jennie was fantastic and so helpful. We can’t wait to get back!

This is our 3rd stay at Lo Key Villa and it did not disappoint! The separate upper and lower levels are perfect for a group trip (especially with kids). The space is clean, AC and fans worked well, and we felt safe. The washer/dryer worked and felt clean. The kitchen has enough supplies (and a great blender). The host, James, was responsive and helpful too! The proximity to CocoBay is insane - instant activities for kiddos or relaxing away from the excitement of feeding turtles and stingrays. We loved taking out the kayaks for a peaceful adventure. This home will always have a special place in our hearts. Can’t wait to return!

This was our third year at Efains’ place so we are super at home. Efain let us know about local events happening and asked if we needed anything but, other than that, just let us chill and gave us our privacy. However, if we did have a question he was quick to respond. We love this place especially because of the privacy outside….you can sit outside in sun or shade without seeing hardly anyone. And yet in a few short minutes’ walk you are at a beautiful quiet beach or lovely pool. It’s nice to see Treasure Cay start to rebound from Hurricane Dorian also. We have already booked next year!!!

Very much enjoyed my stay. Close to everything that I needed, especially given that I didn’t rent a car and walked everywhere. Wouldn’t hesitate to recommend the apartment and Margo as host.

What a lovely stay. The place looked just like the pictures and the beach was the prettiest I have ever seen. Definitely recommend going out by boat if you have the chance. That was one of our favorite things. Hosts were super great and check-in / out were super easy. I highly recommend it and would love to come back. Also, the locals were amazing. Met so many friendly, awesome people.

Wonderful stay, very clean, comfortable. Loved that it was so close to the beach. One suggestion would be to provide a wine corkscrew. But overall we had a great time.