Vacation rentals in South Eleuthera

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in South Eleuthera

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A serene view of the ocean is framed by lush greenery and swaying trees. The calm water reflects the clear blue sky, while a bench under the trees invites relaxation. Grassy areas lead toward the beach, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere.

Cottage in Tarpum Bay

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Beach Front Private Home with Dock

Ocean front home featuring a great private beach/dock with kayaks. Accommodations include 3 Bedrooms, 2 full baths (and outdoor shower), a patio with hammock. Savor panoramic views and breathtaking Caribbean sunsets from the large, covered deck, or from inside a spacious air-conditioned family room with its large windows and French doors. Located only 2 miles from the settlement of Tarpum Bay - restaurants and shopping are nearby. Eleuthera is known for its friendly people and is very safe.

A tranquil shoreline features soft white sand meeting clear turquoise waters. A shadow of a palm tree is cast onto the beach, enhancing the sense of serenity. The horizon displays gentle waves lapping against the shore under a bright blue sky.

Cottage in Tarpum Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Culmer Cottage: experience the REAL Bahamas

Originally built in 1828, Culmer Cottage was restored into a modern sea side home. It is close to groceries, restaurants, and the fishing dock. Its central location on the island permits easy access north or south. My cottage is fully equipped including beach towels and chairs, and a full kitchen. Ceiling fans in all rooms. Both bedrooms are air conditioned. Tarpum Bay is safe and quaint. By choosing to rent in a settlement, you will interact with some of the world's most friendly people.

Top guest favorite

A beach area is shown with a wooden swing set adorned with pineapple motifs. Two swings and a hammock are gently suspended between the posts. The sandy shore leads to calm water that reflects a clear sky with scattered clouds.

Home in Tarpum Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

On The Rocks 3 bedroom in Tarpum Bay Eleuthera

"On The Rocks" is one of a kind! We offer a unique experience that you will always treasure! Nestled 300 feet from the waterfront in Tarpum Bay, Eleuthera, you can sit ‘on the rocks’, view the sunset while sipping your favorite beverage. Our three bedroom, fully furnished, air-conditioned house is a 2 minute walk to the beach and local grocery store. Enjoy fishing, water sports, nature walks or crabbing? Lots of attractions and activities on Eleuthera! So, come stay with us "On The Rocks"!

Guest favorite

A wooden swing set is positioned on the beach, supported by sturdy posts. Gentle waves lap against the sandy shore, under a clear sky with scattered clouds. The calm, shallow water reflects the blue hues of the sky, creating a serene beach atmosphere.

Apartment in Tarpum Bay

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Steps to the Ocean- Munroe Cottages Apt 1

Great place to call home! Stay in the quaint fishing settlement of Tarpum Bay. This apartment is less than a minute walk to the ocean! Super clean 3 bedroom home is ready for your Bahamian experience! Fully furnished with washer and dryer in back. Walk to restaurants, grocery stores, and the beach. The local fisherman sell their catch on the dock. Large beach on the bayfront to swim in with flat clear water. Enjoy the culture & pristine nature that surround you in this great place to stay!

A rustic beach hut stands elevated on wooden posts, featuring a thatched roof made of palm fronds. Ladder steps lead to the entrance, surrounded by trees. The structure is situated near the turquoise sea, with glimpses of water visible between the foliage.

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

"Baha Mara" Tarpum Bay

Fall asleep 50 feet from the turquoise sea. Great snorkelling, swimming, shelling and relaxing right outside the door. Not just a vacation rental, but a beautifully designed home with all the amenities you will need for a comfortable stay. Comfy furniture, stylish, well-equipped cook's kitchen, great view. Good for couples, friends travelling in a group and kid friendly. Close to Rock Sound airport (15 mins) and Governors Harbour (30 mins). 5 minutes from the quaint town of Tarpum Bay.

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Seabreeze Beach Cottage - steps from own beach

We would love to welcome you to Seabreeze Cottage located just 3 miles north of Tarpum Bay on the beautiful island of Eleuthera. This 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home is the place for you to relax on your own private beach that runs along the property or enjoy the crystal clear waters of the Bahamas through swimming, snorkelling, kayaking or just floating with the tide. Escape the hustle and bustle and embrace what Eleuthera has to offer. There are many other attractions on Eleuthera to enjoy.

A sandy beach is framed by a swing set made of wooden posts, adorned with decorative pineapples. Two hammocks are suspended on either side, with gentle waves lapping at the shore. A rainbow appears in the sky, adding a serene touch to the coastal scene.

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Pineapple Pointe

The quaint settlement of Tarpum Bay is a warm, friendly and beautiful settlement in South Eleuthera. The house’s location is secured and roughly 7 minutes drive away from local shops, convenience stores, the beach, gas stations and the Rock Sound Airport. Our home is the perfect place for your next trip, to relax and enjoy the island life. Smoking is not allowed at all in the house. There is WI-FI, so you can stay connected during your stay! *A rental vehicle is a must on the island*

A weathered driftwood sculpture is positioned in the foreground, overlooking a serene beach. The scene reveals gentle waves lapping at the shore, with a sandy beach that stretches into the distance. A cloudy sky features shades of blue, adding to the coastal ambiance.

Home in Winding Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Wonderful Winding Bay

Welcome to Wonderful – Winding Bay, a secluded beachfront villa on Eleuthera’s shores. Enjoy luxury, panoramic ocean views, and seamless indoor-outdoor living. Wake to the sound of waves, step onto your terrace, and find white sands and turquoise waters steps away. With airy, light-filled rooms, refined furnishings, and a gourmet kitchen, your stay promises relaxation and adventure. Embrace tranquility and the unmatched beauty of the Bahamas at Wonderful – Winding Bay.

Guest favorite

A serene bayfront scene is presented, featuring calm waters under a blue sky dotted with soft clouds. In the distance, a small yellow boat gently floats on the water, surrounded by patches of greenery along the shoreline.

Guesthouse in Tarpum Bay

4.71 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Fantastic One Bedroom Cottage with Bayfront Views

Bayfront views abound on this cute guest house. Walk out your front door to Tarpum Bay's beach and steps to restaurants, bars, and grocery stores. Enjoy miles of bayfront beach! This cute guest cottage is located in Tarpum Bay, Eleuthera. It is known as a quaint and quiet fishing village where the locals still bring in their catch of the day. Minutes away from the Atlantic with its magnificent coral reefs and miles of beach with no one else for miles.

A panoramic view captures the turquoise waters of Tarpum Bay, stretching towards a clear blue sky dotted with fluffy white clouds. Lush greenery frames the foreground, enhancing the sense of seclusion while the calm waters invite relaxation and scenic enjoyment.

Apartment in Tarpum Bay

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

By the Bay Hideaway

Cute quaint 2 bedroom space nestled in the beautiful Tarpum Bay designed perfectly for an Island, close enough to the community to experience the culture , but far away enough for seclusion. On property with a small farm and many local fruit trees. Tarpum Bay has been culturally very quiet and community centric, miles of white beach for the most scenic photos and relaxation. Many grocery stores and community events to immerse within the culture.

Top guest favorite

A scenic view showcases the cottage bordered by lush greenery and trees. The calm ocean reflects blue hues, extending towards the horizon. The spacious yard offers a serene atmosphere, complemented by the gentle sway of palm fronds under a clear sky.

Cottage in Rock Sound

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Shorline Cottages, the ultimate getaway!

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. Enjoy the sounds and the tranquil smell of the ocean as you relax in bed or lounge on the veranda of your cottage. Watch the sunset every evening or dine on the pier. Simply immerse yourself in pure delight. This one bedroom cottage has just about everything you’ll need for vacation stay. From Sunset dining to night fishing and so much more.