Vacation rentals with a patio in Shelter Island Heights

The Boathouse was cozy, quaint and a very quiet place. We enjoyed our stay and loved the homey feel. Curran was a great host and I would highly recommend The Boathouse!

We enjoyed the weekend at the the mystic getaway, the apartment is clean and comfy! We located the Denison Homestead and took a beautiful trail hike even though it was cold and windy. We had a great dinner at SnP and comedy night at Mohegan Sun. We hope to return in the summer!

Lisa's apartment is exactly as depicted in the AirBnb listing. It is spacious, clean, comfortable, close to the village of Sag Harbor and down the block from a beautiful private beach. Given the cost of hotels in this area this apartment is an excellent value. While we did not speak or meet during our stay Lisa provided clear directions with regard to finding the home, parking and how to enter and left us her cell phone number in case we needed anything.

This was my second time staying here at Erica’s place and I will be choosing this airbnb every time I come to Long Island! It’s truly SO cozy and feels like my home away from home. Checking in is very simple and Erica will respond quickly every time you reach out. The place is always spotless, smells amazing and I always get the best sleep here! Thank you Erica for being such a great hostess and opening your home for us to enjoy our time in:)

We only stayed one night at Samantha and Robert’s but would definitely stay again next time we are in New Haven. The apartment was clean, quiet, and spacious. There were a number of thoughtful amenities like a high chair, extra toothbrushes and soap in the bathroom, and even some snacks. The neighborhood was really quiet with a nice view of the beach and downtown New Haven across the water.

Our short stay at this New Haven home was perfect. The shower was the reason I chose this Airbnb and it did not disappoint! Everything was clean and the place was spacious.

Comfortable accommodation. Everything you could ask for. We we’re lucky to stay longer over the holiday. Dave and Charlene are great hosts, great communicators. We plan to stay at this location whenever we vist family in Connecticut.

It was the perfect space for my husband and myself! So adorable and walkable to my daughter’s home.

Charm and close to everything. The master bedroom is special!

We loved our stay at Deborah and David's home. The house was perfect for our family, so clean and well equipped. It is even better than on the photos. And what an amazing backyard for the kids!

We booked this last minute as we were coming to celebrate Christmas with my family. We were going to be getting in very late, so I asked if that would be ok. Also, we thought it would be easier if my parents checked us in and set up the crib and toddler bed for the kids and she was very understanding and let us make that accommodation. The rooms were all clean and set up and it was perfect for what we needed. Great location. Definitely would book here again if we are in the area

Really liked this house - quiet and secluded with the family. Good amenities, lovely back yard, and peaceful surroundings. About 20 mins to the beach by the time you park and walk across. A 10-15 min walk to a little dock with a playground for young kids. Thanks for the stay!

My friends and I stayed at Shadae’s place for a weekend getaway, and it was the perfect home base for our adventures. The house was spacious, clean, and had everything we needed to feel comfortable. Shadae was a fantastic host, and her communication was prompt and friendly. We especially appreciated the well-stocked kitchen and the cozy living room where we could all relax together in the evenings. We would definitely recommend Shadae’s place to anyone looking for a comfortable and convenient stay.

We needed a dog-friendly ranch style to home with three bedrooms and two bedrooms close to Sayville, where we would be celebrating Thanksgiving. I was lucky enough to find this rental which was clean, comfortable and ideal for our two-night stay. Adam was attentive and easily accessible via text. I would highly recommend this lovely home.

Terence reached out to me before I left for NY. Everything was as he described it and I know he would have been happy to answer any further questions I might have. Nice place, great location!

This was our second year staying at this property, and we loved it just as much as the first time. Off-season here is beautiful—just as stunning as summer but without the crowds. The house is clean, modern, spacious, and still cozy, with everything you need for a relaxing stay. The nearby shopping center at the end of the street, with a grocery store, liquor store, Starbucks, Walgreens, bagel shop, pizzeria, and Chinese restaurant, makes life so convenient. And then on the other end of the street is a neighborhood beach. All you need to bring is your clothes and that's it. This property is a secret gem that’ll make you too a repeat.

We had a pleasant stay at Nick’s place. The unit was comfortable and clean. The location was perfect with a beautiful view of the water & restaurants in walking distance. Check-in was very easy and Nick was always responsive.

Thanks Lauren! We enjoyed your lovely place!

We really enjoyed staying at Lynn’s place! Very clean and had a great view of the ocean from the deck. Lynn was very responsive and made the experience seamless. We would definitely stay with Lynn again.

Had a wonderful stay with my family. Clean, comfortable, great location. Good communication. Had a little trouble with the front door first day but someone was available quickly to help. A+

Adam's place was amazing and perfect for the location. I would give it five stars!