Vacation rentals in Pumpkin Hill Beach

A spacious outdoor terrace features a bright seating area with red cushions and a glass-top table. A private pool reflects the clear blue sky, while the beach and ocean provide a serene backdrop, framed by palm trees and distant waves.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Casa Naranja - Upscale Living with a Private Pool

MichaelRating, 5 stars12 months ago

This was a wonderful experience. We highly recommend this place, not just for the amenities but for the host. Snorkeling out front was beautiful, the pool was great, nice trade winds, whole house filtered water. Jo met us at the dock with a tuk tuk, her personal vehicle and had lined up two golf cart rentals that were at the dock as well. We were able to smoothly get all our luggage and people to the house without stress. She got us settled in, explained everything about the house, and had a guide to Utila with a ton of useful information. The house was equipped with solar panels which really decreased our power usage. Power is extremely expensive on Utila. It's about 4 times what it is in the states. Expect to pay extra unless you want to run the AC all the time or rent a house with solar panels like this one. I don't think we could have had a better host or better house while we were on the island! Thanks so much, Jo!

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Guesthouse in Utila

Deja-Blue Casita @ Sea Esta

BrianRating, 5 stars1 month ago

11+ out of 10. Joe and Janelle are an amazing team. The property is spectacular with a view of the cays and Janelle is constantly working to make sure the property is spotless. The casitas were designed by Joe and decorated by Janelle and are lovely - from the screened in porch, drinkable water supply, quality bedding and towels, and little niceties such as a wireless phone charger and nightlights. The morning breakfasts were a highlight, cooked by Janelle and delivered to the casita by Joe at a time of your choosing. All the bread is homemade and there was zero repetition during our 7 days. The three dinners were equally delicious as Janelle is a topnotch chef. We looked forward to Joe's stories (jokes) which were delivered with impeccable timing. The wifi is consistent and even available on the top deck of the dock. Lounging there with the spectacular view and a good book was a wonderful way to while away a few hours every day. One of the treats was watching the rays from the dock

Top guest favorite

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Cay House, Jewel of the Utila Bay

LindaRating, 5 stars7 months ago

This was our second stay at the Caye House, and we will be back again. Tina, the property manager, is a gem! She's always so welcoming, super helpful, and concerned for our comfort. The house itself is perfectly located on the main strip within walking distance of pretty much everything, but it is on the water - so super peaceful. The house is large and airy, perfect for a small group. Our group dived with Watersports, and they picked us up and dropped us off on our private dock every day. The porch and private dock are perfect for watching sunrises and sunsets or taking a dip in the harbor. There's a freshwater shower at the end of the dock. The kitchen is fabulous if you want to make your own meals. All the rooms have great views. We love the Caye House, and our group is looking forward to our return.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

The cottage features a traditional thatched roof, surrounded by vibrant greenery. A spacious patio is visible, complemented by natural stone paths and tropical plants. Large windows provide natural light, and a tall palm tree stands prominently in the foreground.

Hut in Utila

The Little Grass Shack

Heiða HlínRating, 5 stars4 days ago

Stayed at Tara’s hut for about two weeks and absolutely loved it. The place was airy and cool during hot days, and incredibly cozy when the rain rolled in. The surrounding garden and area are stunning, with incredible wildlife. It’s peaceful and private, just a short walk from the main street. Tara was a wonderful host, responsive and caring. I couldn’t have asked for a better stay.

Three wooden chairs are positioned on the sandy beach, facing the calm ocean waters. A driftwood piece is situated nearby, adding a natural element to the beach setting. The clear sky and tranquil sea create a serene atmosphere.

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Sandy Bay Beach House

ByronRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

We had a great time at Laura’s house, very spacious inside and out, had everything you might need during your stay and its right in front of the beach with a wonderful view! Also special thanks to Angel, the concierge, he was very kind and helped us out with everything on time!

A spacious kitchen area features custom wooden cabinetry and a large center island with seating for four. Modern appliances, including a stainless steel refrigerator and a gas stove, are visible. Natural light streams in through a window with light curtains, highlighting the warm wooden flooring.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

Paradise Palms I

AlexandraRating, 5 stars1 week ago

This is my second time staying here! I love the house, the amenities, how spacious the place is, I’d recommend this to anyone wanting to go with their family or friends to Utila! Thank you Chris and Tamara for the excellent hospitality ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

The Dolphin House- A Serenity Beach Cottage

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews27 months ago

Cheri’s place on Utila is a hidden gem! They are genuinely some of the nicest people I have met while traveling - we didn’t want to leave! The place is exactly as described but BETTER in person. Those picture windows in the front of the house are huge - photos don’t do them justice. Cheri was also so accommodating before our arrival, getting quotes for dives and even when all the dive shops were booked up, she contacted a friend and made she we got on a boat for a 2 tank dive! There are so many beautiful places in the world that it’s hard to justify going to the same place twice, but Cheri’s place/Utila will definitely be on my future travel list.

Villa in Utila

What guests are saying

Casa de la Cala - 1BR/1BA Utila Oceanfront Retreat

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews2 months ago

What a beautiful place to stay! The cove is gorgeous, accessible and can be viewed from the porch. Snorkeling on the reef right there. You can hear the waves perfectly when they’re rolling. Apartment is full of natural light, other than in the dark, cool, peaceful bedroom. House is finished to North American standards, with great hot water and pressure, granite countertops, good lighting, etc. We lived just as at home for a month. Neighborhood is very quiet, and perfect bicycle-distance from town. Best aspect was Erin, who was a great host and all-around special person. She was very helpful in many ways, and really provided a great first experience on Utila.

Apartment in Utila

What guests are saying

The Lagoon House, A Charming Vacation Rental

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews15 months ago

We had an amazing stay at this Airbnb. Anita was extremely nice and very welcoming. She made sure our stay was very pleasant. The place looks exactly as described on line. The house is located close to the Utila Dream Ferry port, which makes it convenient. There are a lot of restaurants, bars, and shops at walking distance. Definitely staying at the Airbnb again in the feature. Thank you !

Cottage in Utila

What guests are saying

Beyond Paradise Apartment

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews24 months ago

Gene's place is perfect. It's outside of town by a 5-10 minute walk, but peaceful, with beautiful water views. The inside had wonderfully cold AC, was very comfortable, and stocked with everything we needed. Outside we watched pelicans, geckos and fish just a few steps off the porch while listening to the waves. Most importantly, Gene and his wife were very friendly and gracious. They made restaurant recommendations, we chatted about diving, and even borrowed their bicycles 1 afternoon when we realized we quickly needed to run an errand. We truly felt like we were visiting friends and can't recommend their apartment enough.

Apartment in Utila

What guests are saying

Las Brisas del Caribe

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews3 months ago

This was our second trip to Utila. I couldn't imagine a better house or location on the island. It had three separate living spaces which allowed us to spread out. The house is right next to Scott's driftwood beach, a great place to see driftwood art and to enter the water. The house is on a small bay which provided fantastic snorkeling. I saw more fish, conch's, moray, and wildlife in that bay than I did diving the island. The hosts were quick to respond to problems and did an excellent job. I highly recommend any property they manage but really recommend this specific house. This is a house we would buy. You can also walk the point across from the house and see very cool fossilized corals and the ocean pounding on the rocks. This is a great island, great house, location, and host. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

Home in Utila

What guests are saying

Mc. apartments

4.71 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews1 month ago

Casa Azul was a great little space to relax away from the main strip. It is walking distance to most things (but up a little hill so depends on your fitness). But far enough away to be peaceful and catch the breeze. We stayed with two couples- the rental space is the flat under the house but you will have the place to yourself. The front porch is a great spot to string up a hammock and watch for iguanas in the trees. The beds were really comfortable and the kitchen was perfect for making some communal meals when we wanted a break from baleadas. We did have to get a few of our own pantry essentials (coffee, oil, a large filtered water bottle etc- pretty much just salt provided). June was very responsive and helpful when we asked. Thanks for a great time Utila.

Apartment in Utila

1 of 12 pages

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Pumpkin Hill Beach vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Pumpkin Hill Beach

An infinity pool seamlessly merges with the ocean view, framed by a sandy beach. Rocky outcrops are visible in the water, with lush greenery emerging from the rocks. The sky offers a mixture of cloud cover and blue, creating a serene coastal atmosphere.

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Rocky Point House

BradleyRating, 5 stars12 months ago

This was our second time at Adam's place. If it's available, just book it - you will not be disappointed. Pros: location is far enough out to where it's very quiet, but still just a quick walk into town, this is the windy side of the island and this means ZERO bug issues, the pool is a perfect way to unwind at the end of a day diving - it stays nice and chilly and is perfect if you overdid it in the sun, the kitchen is well equipped, the property caretaker knows everything about the house and the island and is an absolute sweetheart, the beds are comfy, private beach right out front, perfect spot for a sunrise, great living room furniture, list goes on. Cons: honestly, you could nitpick a thing or two if you are that kind of person, but I can't list a single issue about this house that would keep me from returning time and time again.

The image captures a beach setting during sunset, with gentle waves lapping at the shore. Canoes are positioned on the sand, while colorful lounging chairs are set up for relaxation. Lush palm trees line the beach, and hints of vibrant food and leisure options are visible in the background.

Apartment in Utila

4.68 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Apartment close to the beach

MelissaRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Benjamin's place was great, exactly what we were looking for! close to all activity yet a little further away so we didnt have noise at night. excelent place

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

A serene garden area is framed by palm trees, featuring a bathtub with floral accents positioned near the ocean. A colorful lounge chair adds a vibrant touch, while gentle waves of the water can be seen in the background, providing a tranquil setting for relaxation.

Apartment in Utila

Casa Colorada - in the Heart of an Island Paradise

EverRating, 5 stars5 days ago

A very quiet place to rest, a place to escape the ordinary, where you can sleep peacefully without noise or hassles

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

A panoramic view of the ocean stretches across the image, featuring bright blue waters under a partly cloudy sky. The foreground includes lush greenery and a swimming pool, while a wooden dock extends toward a white structure on the water, enhancing the serene atmosphere.

Resort in Utila

Coral View Beach Resort Double Room (2 Beds)

XimenaRating, 5 stars12 months ago

the breakfast is very good and the petsonal is friendly and attentive

An open gazebo is situated by the shoreline, featuring two wooden chairs that face the ocean. A thatched roof provides shade, while hammocks hang nearby. Gentle waves can be seen lapping against the rocks, and distant mountains are visible on the horizon.

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

Beach House in the Trees - Sleeps up to 7!

PaulRating, 5 stars1 week ago

A lovely retreat located just out of the town, but walkable. Beautiful seafront location and responsive host. Trees need trimming to reveal the sea view, and if you fill the place, you might need more crockery etc. From our experience of Tamara, this would be quickly sorted though.

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

The Coconut House on Treasure Beach

DanaRating, 5 stars3 months ago

A wonderful setting for a memorable vacation, surrounded by the natural beauty of the Caribbean! A great spot to be as active or as relaxed as you like. Trish is a wonderful host and is very accommodating along with her amazing crew.