Places to stay in Phelps

Love the cabins at Screwy Louie’s! My husband and I stayed here for some time years ago and decided to revisit for our anniversary recently. The cabins were better than we remembered, everything was clean and tidy. I am from the area so I’m aware of everything Fair Haven has to offer, but the location of the cabins makes things super walkable. We will be back!

Great place! Beautiful. New. Safe neighborhood. Easy access to Cornell and Ithaca. Highly recommend. Will stay here again!

Beautiful home in a peaceful, private location. We were so comfortable and felt right at home! The large open concept kitchen and living room were perfect for family cooking and visiting. Incredibly comfortable reclining couches in the living room. We really enjoyed sitting out on the deck in the evening, in the screened in gazebo. Perfect Airbnb for a fall get away! Thank you so much for sharing your home, Tammy and Guy!

This charming historic home exceeded all expectations! Every detail sparkled with character, from the immaculate interior to the supremely comfortable beds. The location couldn't be better for anyone's stay in Rochester. Lucking out with warmer Dec. weather, we strolled through streets lined with architecturally unique and beautifully holiday-decorated homes that looked straight out of a postcard. I only wish we could have stayed longer to soak in more of the magical atmosphere. A perfect 5-star experience from start to finish in my favorite part of the city.

Very unique place in an old church. The space is huge and has everything needed for a comfortable stay. Everything was clean and the host was responsive to communication. Great location for visiting the wineries on the east side of Seneca lake. Also convenient to visiting Ithaca and Watkins Glen.

Had a last-minute business trip to Watkins Glen, and all of the decent hotels had limited availability. This place was perfect. We found a restaurant right down the street and ate there both nights. Dunkin Donuts was almost directly across the street, so we didn't even bother with the coffee maker in the morning. Hot tub was a nice bonus on the 2nd night!

We had a great few days at Anita's place. The location is perfect- walking distance to much of what Ithaca has to offer. The place itself was clean and comfortable. We could hear the people above us walking around, so make sure to bring earplugs if you are a light sleeper. Anita was a great host- very responsive and helpful.

Jacki's place far exceeded our expectations. The pictures do not do the place justice. It is a lot more spacious than it looks in the pictures and the place was very clean. The neighborhood was very quiet and the house was so easy to find. Great parking in the driveway and the laundry machines were new and easily accessible. We enjoyed our stay and being that it is an easy 18 min drive to Syracuse Stage, we will stay here again next time we come to see a show at Syracuse Stage or Landmark theatre.

We throughly enjoyed our 4 days. We felt invited, valued, and heard. We were so interested in the decor. Our eyes darted from collectable to architectural designs. We stayed in the Carriage House which was spotlessly clean, large and inviting. Coffee and breakfast were the best. We loved meeting the other guests daily, great conversation was had by all. Most of all, we felt welcome as guests and if our travels take us to Ithaca again, we will certainly stay with Madeline and Kenn again!