Vacation rentals in Old Tappan

5 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Home in Greenwood Lake

Escape to the lake!LAKEFRONT/Hot-tub/1 hour to NYC

TatyanaRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We had a staycation here and it was absolutely lovely. We enjoyed the space, especially the view. The hot tub was great in the chilly nights, played in the game room a bit, cooked in the kitchen and enjoyed some meals in the dining room. Easy to find, but felt very private. Thank you for sharing the lovely place.

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

The living area features large windows that allow natural light to fill the space, with views of the surrounding greenery. A comfortable sectional sofa is positioned around a wooden coffee table, creating a cozy gathering spot. A wall-mounted television is visible above a rustic wood-paneled fireplace.

Home in Lehman township

Cozy Family Poconos Home: Game Room, Pools,Firepit

BrianRating, 5 stars3 months ago

We had a big group stay at Anastasiya’s Airbnb and it was exactly as described. We also really enjoyed the table games in the home and the place was clean and very spacious. It was an easy check in and Anastasiya was very responsive throughout the entire process. It was also very close to Shawnee Mountain which was where we went to snowboard during the weekend. I would definitely recommend this place for anyone looking for an Airbnb!

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

A serene outdoor area features several gray chairs arranged around a fire pit. The grassy lawn leads to a tranquil lake, reflecting the vibrant colors of surrounding trees. A dock is visible in the distance, enhancing the natural beauty of the setting.

Cottage in Beach Lake

Driftwood Cottage on Welcome Lake-peaceful retreat

SamuelRating, 5 stars3 days ago

The driftwood cottage on welcome lake, is awesome. I went with my fiancé for the weekend of Easter. It also happens to be our birthdays. We had had a great time, if you want to relax and be at peace for a weekend this the cottage to be at. Thanks for having us!! Samuel and Lena 💕

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

Home in Bushkill

Sweet Home Poconos

SRating, 5 stars2 months ago

We had a terrific time. It’s a lovely home- 20 min from Shawnee mountain and steps away from an indoor/outdoor pool facility (depends on weather), sledding hill and small skiing hill with ski lift. I would absolutely stay here again- and highly recommend for anyone with young kids looking to teach them to ski. Very very convenient. The hosts were available for questions and were friendly/flexible. Incredible customer service. We will be back!

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

A scenic view of the river, showcasing lush green hills in the background and a collection of boats docked along the shore. A wooden deck is visible in the foreground, framed by a fence and greenery, inviting relaxation by the water.

Cottage in Sea Bright

Sea Bright NJ Cottage 1 block from BEACH sleeps 6!

GailRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

Nice cozy cottage one block from the beach.. spent many hours walking the beach and found many beautiful shells and sea glass on our walks. Cozy cottage perfect for us and our dog in a quiet and beautiful neighborhood.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

A private outdoor deck featuring a wooden floor and a shaded area. Several seating options include four light-colored lounge chairs and a dining table surrounded by additional chairs, providing ample space for relaxation and dining while enjoying the ocean views.

Apartment in Long Beach

Incredible Long Beach Private Rental

AllanRating, 5 stars3 months ago

Absolutely superb hosts and such a great location. Steven couldn’t have been a better host, our kids and us loved his place and would highly recommend. Thoughtful touches everywhere and very clean. Hope we can stay again sometime.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

A serene lake view is presented, showcasing calm waters bordered by lush greenery and residential homes on the opposite shore. A private dock is visible in the foreground, accompanied by a shaded gazebo. The bright blue sky reflects on the lake's surface.

Home in Hopatcong

Lakefront Hopatcong w/dock kayaks fishing near NYC

MichelRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

This was by far the best Airbnb experience we have had. Super clean and comfortable, quiet neighborhood and beautiful view of the lake. Shiying was a very accommodating and friendly host. We absolutely loved our stay and would definitely love to return. Thank you!

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

A serene lakeside dock is depicted, featuring two blue adirondack chairs and a small table. A kayak and another boat are visible alongside the dock, reflecting the calm water. Foliage frames the scene, enhancing the peaceful atmosphere.

Cabin in Shohola

Rhodo - charming private lake front cabin

ChristinaRating, 5 stars6 months ago

Beautiful property and wonderful hosts who were so accommodating as to drive out to fix the internet for the one member of our group who needed to unfortunately work during our stay. Accommodations were basic and comfortable, which were expected and perfect for our group. We were there on the first chilly weekend of fall and able to spend both nights around the cozy wood stove during the evening and the dock during the day. The lakefront community is beautiful and I hope we can return with our dogs during the summer to take advantage of swimming and kayaking next year.

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

Jewy’s Cozy Cottage

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews4 months ago

Jenny was an amazing host and her husband Wesley was the cherry on top. Incredibly helpful and hospitable. They even invited me to have thanksgiving dinner with them! So cozy, it feels like a home that’s lived in, not a hotel or a commercial space. It’s a warm and loving HOME.

Apartment in Newton

What guests are saying

Narrowsburg House with Breathtaking Mountain Views

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 89 reviews2 months ago

Little slice of heaven in the Western Catskills! This home was a perfect long-weekend escape from the hustle of city life—absolutely spectacular views, lovely fireplace, well-stocked kitchen, and that perfect combination of spacious/airy and cozy. Amazingly well-outfitted for kids with plenty of toys & books, and we had fun in the snow in the yard. It was fairly blustery and wet out much of the weekend, so we spent most of our time inside but never felt cooped up.

Home in Narrowsburg

What guests are saying

Spacious, Quiet 4 Bedroom + All Season Hot Tub

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews3 days ago

My family had a fabulous 4 night stay at Tina’s place! There was plenty of space to lounge around and we all enjoyed the hot tub. We were a short drive to so many restaurants, farms, breweries and hiking spots. Tina responded immediately every time we asked a question. Would definitely stay here again!

Home in New Paltz

What guests are saying

Water's Edge Lakefront Home

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews4 months ago

WOW!! We cannot say enough amazing things about our stay. We stayed for the holidays and the snow surrounding the lake was the most beautiful surrounding imaginable. It was so peaceful and we watched both sunrises and sunsets there. Plus there were tons of beautiful swans to appreciate! The house was extremely pristine, decorated beautifully for the holidays, and felt like home. This was such a special stay and our host was so accommodating! We will absolutely be back.

Home in Greenwood Lake

What guests are saying

Lakeside Spring Retreat: Hike, Kayak, Relax

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews2 months ago

What a great place to stay with your dogs. From the moment we entered, we felt dogs were welcome. The fact that it was pet friendly did not impact the quality of our stay. It was cozy, comfortable & impeccably clean. Our hostess was very responsive. I was concerned about the safety of the walkway due to ice & our Michelle had extra salt added to the driveway prior to our arrival. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay & would love to stay again.

Home in Vernon Township

What guests are saying

Cottage with Picturesque Views

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 87 reviews2 months ago

This place is literally a piece of heaven! During our stay, we had a full frontal of the frozen lake, it was pure magic! Waking up to the beautiful view of the lake was magic. If you are trying to disconnect, relax, reconnect with your loved one, this is your spot! The details in this rental were to die for! From the beautiful kitchen, to the rooms, there is not a single spot in this rental that was overlooked by design!! There is also ample space outside to hang out and grill! It was a beautiful and relaxing winter stay, the host was extremely responsive, even went out his way to grab allergy medicine for me through one of the snowy days.. thank you so much for your kindness! This place is absolutely heaven! I am definitely coming back!

Cottage in Greenwood Lake

What guests are saying

Luxury Home with Mountain Views

5 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews2 months ago

The house is even more beautiful than the pictures. It is beautifully designed and extremely clean and comfortable. Kitchen is well equipped, beds are very comfortable, and the playroom for the toddlers was an amazing addition to the experience. Judy was very responsive and considerate of all of our needs. We would love to come back for another stay!

Home in New Paltz

What guests are saying

Beautiful whole house rental 2BR 2Bath

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews6 months ago

Angelique's home is absolutely charming and located in a lovely neighborhood. We were in town for a race at Jones Beach and loved how quiet and relaxing both her home and neighborhood were. The ground floor was very spacious and comfortable. The kitchen was very well stocked. Upstairs was quite cozy but there is also a bathroom on the main floor so my husband and I each "took" one. The home is very well located with easy access to local restaurants and coffee shops. Highly recommend.

Home in Amityville

What guests are saying

Greenwood Lake’s Iconic Lakefront “Icehouse”

5 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews3 months ago

From booking through check out, Maureen was pleasant, communicated promptly and clearly, and had the house perfectly dialed in to accommodate our family. The house is situated on a large, beautiful lakefront lot with spectacular views, and outfitted for families and friends to have an amazingly fun experience, regardless of weather or time of year. If you’re looking for a peaceful getaway, or a lively time with friends, this place will not disappoint!

Home in Greenwood Lake

1 of 12 pages

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Old Tappan vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Stay near Old Tappan's top sights

The Old '76 House4 locals recommend

Organica Natural Foods3 locals recommend

Stop & Shop3 locals recommend

Other great vacation rentals in Old Tappan

Apartment in Downtown Stamford

An expansive outdoor area showcases a heated pool surrounded by wooden decking. Sun loungers and umbrellas are arranged around the pool, with colorful seating accents visible. Pathways meander through lush greenery, integrating seating and recreational spaces within the tranquil courtyard.

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Sunny 1BR Apartment

JoanRating, 5 stars3 months ago

Clean , modern apt. Very easy to navigate with the technology. Staff very friendly and helpful. A bit noisy on street outside with traffic. Will definitely rent again with URBY, but request a courtyard side unit

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

A serene backyard setting is surrounded by tall trees, showcasing a mix of open grassy space and partial woodland. Five white adirondack chairs are arranged around a firepit, with a dining table visible nearby, inviting outdoor gatherings.

Home in South Fallsburg

Renovated & Spacious 3BR Catskills Retreat

NicolaRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Alan was a pleasure to work with. He promptly answers all my messages. We worked with him for our company stays. we stayed well over a month in 2 of his home. Check out all his homes for rent.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

A lakeside scene features a small fire pit surrounded by four chairs on grassy ground. Two kayaks are visible near a wooden dock extending into the lake, which reflects the overcast sky. Lush trees line the distant shore.

Apartment in Cochecton

Lake view with new 6 person jacuzzi & lake area

JaneRating, 5 stars1 month ago

I was looking for some quiet after a stressful few months and something of a view. I love the water so I picked this place and it want a far drive from me. I felt at home and comfortable. The kitchen has everything you could think of which was great because I really wanted to bake for myself and just do a great self care weekend which I did. Me and my pup got to have some alone time and hang by the water across the street at the gated off little beach. Hung out in the hammock and sat on the boat launch. Exactly what I needed. Definitely coming back !

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

A view into the living area reveals warm wooden flooring and a bright, airy atmosphere. A spacious dining table surrounded by white chairs is visible, along with a kitchen beyond. Light filters in through several window blinds, complementing the softly colored walls.

Home in Neptune City

Peaceful Getaway

EmmaRating, 5 stars3 months ago

My family really enjoyed staying here for Christmas! We have family nearby so the location worked well for us- it’s also a plus to be walking distance to Main St shops and restaurants (our favorites, Vic’s and Darcy’s)!We travel with our dogs and this house was really comfortable for them which makes us happy and feel at home as well. Big backyard and nice neighborhood for walking. Most airbnbs we’ve stayed in lack seating but Tiffany’s large sectional with dining table for 6 in an open concept downstairs was a great perk. Tiffany made check in and check out extremely easy and made us feel relaxed about being away from home. Would love to stay again for our next trip to the shore!

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

An open living area is presented with a spiral staircase leading to an upper level. A dining table with dark placemats and a vase of fresh flowers is centrally located. Cozy seating options include a textured sofa and an accent chair, while a television is mounted on the wall.

Condo in Vernon Township

Peaceful Mountain Retreat

Adam Rating, 5 stars1 week ago

Perfect stay. Felt at home from the moment I arrived and Adam was really easy to communicate with and very accommodating. The condo was clean and cozy. For sure will be back.

4.73 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

The entrance of Minerals Resort and Spa is showcased, featuring a prominent sign surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage and colorful flower beds. The building's stone accents and unique architecture complement the natural scenery of the lush mountains in the background.

Condo in Vernon Township

200 yds Minerals - great for hotel weddings

SaraRating, 5 stars5 months ago

We had a great time! The unit is an easy walk to Minerals, and the layout was perfect for our needs. Joann was a fantastic host and we can’t wait to stay again!

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

The home is set within a wooded landscape, featuring a large wrap-around deck and distinctive red accents. The multi-level structure includes large windows that invite natural light. A paved driveway leads to the entrance, surrounded by lush greenery and scattered rocks.

Home in Bushkill

Charming Peaceful Retreat with Hot Tub

BrittRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We had a great 2 night stay in early spring. It was perfect for a get together for 3 couples to meet in a convenient location coming from 3 different directions. We used the hot tub and sat outside on the porch. Close to bushkill, dingmans and Milford where we went for brunch on Sunday. Cozy place.