Vacation rentals in New Milford

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Milford

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

Home in Unadilla

5 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Escape the City

Spend a beautiful week in small-town America in a historic 1915 craftsman style three-story home on Main St. Home features six bedrooms on the second floor. A beautiful sunroom with lots of windows to have your morning coffee and a wraparound porch with rocking chairs and a porch swing. In the evening, light a fire out in the backyard around the large oversized fire pit. Enjoy the beautiful summer nights or come stay for the winter holidays and hope to catch some snow while enjoying the Jacuzzi.

Top guest favorite

A historic stone building is seen blanketed in fresh snow, framed by tall snow-covered trees. Streetlights cast a warm glow on the scene, while a gently plowed street reveals clear pathways. The tranquil winter landscape enhances the charm of the surrounding area.

Loft in Walton

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

1860's Victorian guest house in the Catskills

This cozy getaway is on a historical street in one of the oldest villages in the Catskills. Situated on a street that boasts a charming white framed church, a grand blue stoned library & one of the oldest Opera House's, turned movie theater. Walk to antique shops, restaurants, coffee shops, the park (swim in the summer or ice skate/ sled in winter) or get in the car for scenic drives to surrounding farms, hiking trails & farmers markets in warmer seasons. Perfect for a couple and 1-2 children.

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor area features several gray chairs arranged around a fire pit. The grassy lawn leads to a tranquil lake, reflecting the vibrant colors of surrounding trees. A dock is visible in the distance, enhancing the natural beauty of the setting.

Cottage in Beach Lake

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Driftwood Cottage on Welcome Lake-peaceful retreat

This gem of a vacation rental is perfectly situated on a private lake. Recently renovated, the main level features an open concept living area, with a cozy fireplace for chilly evenings, upgraded kitchen, a master bedroom with a luxurious en-suite bathroom. A charming loft serves as a cozy relaxation spot or additional sleeping area. Each room offers a spectacular lake view. Two full bathrooms ensures everyone has space to unwind. Outdoor includes a hot tub, perfect for relaxation by the lake.

Superhost

Home in Lake Ariel

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Lakeview Chalet - Pool & Lake/Beach - Kayaking

Perfect getaway with lake views. Large deck, BBQ & fire pit in a safe family-friendly community with lots of amenities! Steps away from the pool - close to beach/lake area. HOME HAS AIR CONDITIONING and Fans! Community has 2 Lakes and pools with beach/BBQ area. All you need for a fun-filled and relaxing getaway. Basketball & Tennis Courts, Kayak rentals and more... Winter -The Hideout offers snow tubing and skiing. Guests are responsible for lift tickets, rentals and any other fees for use.

Guest favorite

A spacious wooden deck is shown, adorned with a patterned rug and a small table with a plant. Lounge chairs are positioned for relaxation, and decorative accents, including wall art and hanging elements, complement the natural wooded surroundings.

Treehouse in Tunkhannock

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 196 reviews

Creekside Getaway in the Trees

A very large & private 2nd floor (steps) efficiency studio apt with a spectacular 40 foot deck amid trees overlooking Bowman's Creek in the beautiful Endless Mountains of NEPA . Very close to Tunkhannock, a beautiful country town w/ great shops, food, stores, outdoor activities, entertainment & much more. Included are furnishings, dishes, bedding, electric, heat, air, internet, off street parking & more. Near restaurants, coffee shops, entertainment, antiques, hiking paths, lakes & nature.

Top guest favorite

A gentle landscape is captured, featuring a deer standing in a sunlit field of tall grass. A farmhouse is visible in the distance, surrounded by rolling hills under a clear blue sky.

Home in Dushore

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Scenic Mountain View Getaway

Escape to a stunning home boasting breathtaking mountain vistas. Unwind amidst nature on the expansive deck, spotting wildlife, or soak in the hot tub while marveling at the scenery. Relax in the cozy reading nook for ultimate tranquility. Explore nearby state parks like Rickett's Glen, Worlds End, and Loyalsock, or embark on a hike to the mountain's peak for a picturesque picnic. Delight in local events in charming towns with fantastic shops and restaurants, enhancing your getaway experience.

Guest favorite

A 4 season sunroom features large windows providing ample natural light. A small round dining table with four chairs is positioned beside a lounge area with a comfortable sectional couch. A striped area rug lies on the wooden floor, enhancing the inviting ambiance.

Home in Honesdale

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

The Overlook- A freshly remodeled, spacious home.

Happy to welcome you to our stunning Northeast PA family style home, The Overlook. This freshly renovated 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom ranch style home is located just outside of downtown Honesdale in a relaxing and peaceful neighborhood. The property comes complete with a gorgeous 4 season sunroom and a spacious backyard. The Overlook is just 3/4 of a mile from downtown Historic Honesdale, where fantastic local shops and restaurants await! We promise once you get here, you won't want to leave:)

Guest favorite

Farm stay in Meshoppen

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

Cozy country farmhouse with HOT TUB!!

Come Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. It’s a great spot for a girls or couples weekend !!! Enjoy a big yard, newly built pond and a hot tub!! You get the whole house & property to yourself. The hot tub is a perfect spot for Stargazing on a clear night !! We have wild life that come out to visit and The new pond is ready for swimming or fishing! Our quiet dirt road is Great for riding bikes and going for walks. This is a great spot unwind and recharge !!!

Guest favorite

Home in Lake Ariel

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 78 reviews

20% discount! Holiday special! Poconos Best place!

Discover the charm of our Lake Ariel house, perfect for families or groups. Relax in the hot tub, enjoy the fireplace, or play pool and ping-pong. Nearby, explore skiing, tubing, ice skating, and lakeside fun. The gated community offers heated pools, sports courts, hiking trails, and a golf course. With 4 bedrooms, 10 beds, and 3 baths, everyone will find their space. Dine on the deck, lounge in the living room, or explore local attractions. Your unforgettable retreat awaits!

Top guest favorite

A tranquil landscape view of a gently flowing stream bordered by greenery. The spacious backyard features well-kept grass and natural stones. The modern home is visible in the background, showcasing a large deck that overlooks the serene setting.

Home in Franklin

5 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

All Star Village Modern Waterfront Luxury Home

Close to Cooperstown All Star Village- 15 to 20 minutes away (13.5 miles) Catskills Estate: Fully Brand New Spacious estate on 13 picturesque acres with forest trails: Escape New York City to find yourself in a beautiful mountain home nestled in nature with forest and water views. Relax on a 40 ft outdoor deck overlooking a spring-water stream in your own backyard! Enjoy hiking, fishing, hunting, ATV riding, and snowmobiling on your own land. Brand New Ping Pong Table!

Superhost

A serene lakeside view is captured from a wooden dock featuring two chairs, one white and one blue. The calm water reflects the cloudy sky and surrounding greenery, creating a peaceful atmosphere. Trees line the far bank, with hints of nearby residences visible in the distance.

Cottage in Nicholson

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Lakeside Cottage near skiing/waterparks/wineries

Welcoming cottage located on a private lake near skiing, golfing, waterparks, wineries, and breweries. Recently renovated with a large living/dining area perfect for relaxing and gathering with family & friends. Offers an additional loft with 2 full-size beds, great for kids. A short walking distance from a year-round bar and grill with a rotating seasonal menu and craft beer. Several other casual and fine dining options are located within minutes.

Superhost

A serene view of the property nestled among tall trees, showcasing a blend of natural greenery and a shoreline. Wooden stairs lead from the rocky beach up to the house, providing access to the lush surroundings.

Home in Hawley

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Poconos Lakefront Best View Lake Wallenpaupack⛷

The best view on the lake I would describe it as hypnotic. Close to several ski resorts. Montage, Elk, Camelback, Jack Frost , and Big Bolder are all less than 40 min drive,!!!two fireplaces and a fire pit !!The pictures do not do it justice. Brand new everything look at the pictures. Huge deck private dock and swim dock!! Perfectly situated between silver birches and the boat house. Walk the dyke to the beach!!

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

Torrey Forest House, private home on 100 acres.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews2 months ago

We had a great weekend at the Boyds Mill barn. The house was extremely spacious, cozy, and well stocked with everything we could have possibly wanted. Most importantly, Amy was extremely responsive and ready to host us on a short notice. Would highly recommend staying here if you’re looking for a good weekend getaway with friends or family.

Home in Honesdale

What guests are saying

Miller Fly Life on the River

5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews8 months ago

We had the most perfect stay at Miller Flylife! Shar was the best host I’ve ever had and she even left us snacks, smores fixin’s and a sweet note on arrival. We were there to go to French Woods Camp and I would recommend her house a thousand times to other families. It was just great.

Home in Hancock

What guests are saying

Lacey Villa

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews2 months ago

I had a wonderful stay at LaceyVilla! The place was very cozy and beautifully decorated. My room was clean and the bed was super comfy, so I slept really well. the living area was great for relaxing. I loved the outdoor space too—perfect for enjoying coffee in the morning. The location was very quiet and peaceful . Cindy was friendly and was very helpful. I highly recommend LaceyVilla! It's a perfect place to relax and enjoy. --- Let me know if you need any changes!

Home in Laceyville

What guests are saying

Lakefront Cottage & Cozy Ski Retreat. Elk Mountain

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews1 month ago

Our family traveled to Pennsylvania to ski at Elk Mountain and was fortunate to identify such an extraordinary home and host. We truly enjoyed our stay at Leisha’s home on the lake .. it was well maintained, clean, and organized. Leisha was very supportive of our special needs and I would undoubtedly recommend this Airbnb property to other parties exploring options in the region. Due to the lakeside location, the magic is certainly in the warmer months; however, for the winter enthusiasts seeking a country home proximal to Pennsylvania’s best skiing, consider Leisha’s home .. you’ll enjoy your stay.

Home in Greenfield Township

What guests are saying

5BR Vacation Home with lake views & central AC

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews9 months ago

We had a wonderful week. Our group was five adults, an 8 year old boy and 2 year old girl. We had plenty of room to spread out but there were plenty of spaces to enjoy together as well. We would definitely return and highly recommend this lovely home!

Vacation home in Lake Ariel

What guests are saying

Bear Run Bungalow |New|Fireplace|Firepit|Hot Tub

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews2 days ago

When I got to the house I was immediately happy with the place , my fiancé and my brother; who came from another country for a visit , said they loved everything: the house very clean and organized , the location, organization and communication with the host. This was an incredible experience, not only because the house had everything we needed and even more to have fun; the night peace, the options nearby, the playground for the children in the city, the markets for what we needed. I describe it as such a perfect weekend that I asked to extend one more night and I was lucky enough to get it! Thank you Mathew, you know how to be a great host!

Home in Hawley

What guests are saying

Lakefront Life!

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews7 months ago

Tracy’s property is stunning. You can simply sit out and enjoy the views but we took advantage of the lake and spent almost the whole day out on kayaks. It was beautiful. We enjoyed the grill and the huge tv in the living room. Tracy was helpful and attentive. We can’t wait to visit again!

Cottage in New Milford Township