Vacation rentals in McAlisterville

My family and I had an amazing time here over Easter weekend. The home is beautiful, spacious and the jet tub and showers were great! My baby nephew had a great time lounging in the bean bag while we all enjoyed the comfy couch, played pool and shuffleboard. The kids loved the swing set and having an easter egg hunt in the backyard. We will definitely be staying here again in the future. This home was very close to stores we needed. The country store had the best steaks!

Our stay at this Airbnb was absolutely perfect! The location was stunning—beautiful scenery all around, and it felt so peaceful and private, exactly what we were looking for. The house itself had absolutely everything we needed, making it feel like a home away from home. We also loved exploring the local wineries, which were just a short drive away. If you're looking for a relaxing getaway in a gorgeous setting, this is the place. We can’t wait to come back!

Susan’s place was absolutely wonderful. I’ve always dreamed of staying somewhere peaceful and secluded—and this cabin delivered exactly that. The view was spectacular, and even though the weather wasn’t fully on our side (a mix of rain and strong winds during our two-day stay), the beauty and serenity of the place still made it a memorable trip for my daughter and me. What truly stood out was how accurate the listing was—what you see is exactly what you get. As someone who’s stayed in several Airbnbs, I really appreciated that there were no surprises. The home was just as described, and Susan was incredibly responsive and thoughtful throughout. Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful space with us! We left feeling refreshed and grateful 🙏🙂

The house was huge. Beautifull and well stocked kitchen. Outdoor was peaceful and enormous yard where we could run and play. My whole family can't wait to go back.

What an amazing stay! Karen took care of us so well ahead of time that our stay was flawless! Easy check-in, beautiful home, LOTS to do without even leaving the building, and something for everyone! Very spacious and clean, and no doubt we’ll be back! I highly recommend this place if ever you visit Hershey or the Hummelstown area! Can’t say enough about how wonderful our stay was! Thanks again Karen, you are a rockstar!

The perfect cottage for a girls getaway to go antiquing. I've stayed in 4 Airbnb's this year and this home felt the most cozy and comfortable with live plants, cute pillows, and all the lovely decorations the are needed to prevent a cold, sterile environment. We greatly enjoyed the wood burning fireplace with 2 fires during our stay. The bathtub is fabulous and the kitchen was well equipped and clean. The front porch provides the perfect opportunity to enjoy the peacefulness of the creek and the occasional clickety clack of horse hoofs from an Amish horse and buggy. Lastly, a stay is only as good as the host's service. The electric power went out in the area and Brenda kindly delivered a cell phone charger, candles and kindling wood for our wood fire at 10 pm. We would most definitely stay here again.

Beautiful home, secluded. Great outdoor space, firepit. Beautiful view right on Penn’s creek. Landon was super friendly and proactive. Great guide for local places . Highly recommend. We stayed to do some fishing on Penn’s creek

My husband and I started our honeymoon off in the perfect place. It was private, peaceful, and a great space to stay for our first night as a married couple. Definitely recommend for an easygoing getaway!

This place fit perfectly for us over a busy weekend attending the PIAA Championship. Great kitchen, great bedrooms, useful utilities and modern amenities. The hosts were proactive and helpful. Highly recommend!