Long Island vacation rentals

Book unique vacation rentals, houses, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Long Island

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Cottage in Long Island

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Sunset Studio Cottage/ Hilltop/Sea views

"Sunset Studio Cottage" is nestle in hills of Salt Pond Long Island, Baha. Hilltop overlooking the beautiful Salt Pond Harbour(Home to second largest Sailing Regatta though out the archipelago of the Bahamas). Beautiful views(WOW) from the front porch or the large deck with sun, sea and spectacular sunsets with your beverage of choice. The beach is in walking distance and you can hear the sound of ocean crashing into the cliff s from the deck in the evenings all while watching falling stars

Top guest favorite

Villa in Stella Maris

5 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Rock Hill: Island Villa w/Private Pool

Far from the crowds... Close to perfect! Amazing Experiences & Stunning Views/Beaches/Pools This 4BR/4BA Villa Overlooking the Atlantic Ocean INCLUDES private pools and access to beaches, bars, and restaurants of Stella Maris Resort; all within EASY WALKING distance. EXPLORE the “untouched wonders” of Long Island. Rock Hill is one of the newest and most stylish homes on the island. Check us out on social media (RockHill_Bahamas) to see the experiences that await you on this amazing island.

Guest favorite

An outdoor dining area features a wooden table set with plates and glasses, accompanied by dark wooden chairs. A large umbrella provides shade, while the background showcases expansive views of the ocean and lush greenery beneath a bright blue sky.

Bungalow in Stella Maris

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Two Turtles ocean villa: A new gem on Long Island

Welcome to Long Island..... an unspoiled island paradise. Stella Maris is the perfect location from which to discover this laid back island, to explore endless beaches and to kick back and unwind. Nestled high above the Atlantic in a beautiful island setting, Two Turtles provides breathtaking views over the ocean and palm gardens. The villa was fully renovated in 2021 and combines island style living, inclusive of large outside areas with all modern amenities of a comfortable island home.

Guest favorite

Apartment in Long Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Vala's Vacation Rentals 1

Vala's Vacation Rentals 1,2 & 3 (all next door to each other-each unit sleeps 2) are centrally located in Hamilton's, Long Island, The Bahamas. Our island is 76 miles long and 7 miles wide; a rental car is a must. To enjoy the island; swim in the beautiful turquoise waters or shrimp hole, take a boat tour to swim with the pigs or fishing, picnicing, snorkeling, site-seeing tours at the columbus monument & Hamilton's cave; this is the island to choose. Enjoy our native tasty dishes.

A lone palm tree sways gently in the breeze, overlooking a vast ocean. The waves meet a lush green landscape that stretches along the shore, under a cloudy sky that reflects soft shades of blue and gray.

Home in Dunmore Settlement

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Morrisville Beach House

Escape to paradise in this stunning beach house which sits on 20 acres. Experience crystal-clear waters perfect for snorkeling and fishing, with captivating coral reefs & a shipwreck to explore beneath the waves. Enjoy ultimate seclusion on the private beach, stretching for miles without a soul in sight. The house boasts a private road to the beach. Relax on the lookout balcony in the garage, offering panoramic views of the breathtaking surroundings. Your beach getaway awaits!

Top guest favorite

An aerial view showcases a secluded beach with soft, sandy shores bordered by rocky outcrops. The turquoise waters gently lap at the coastline, while lush greenery extends into the distance. The tranquil scene offers a sense of natural beauty and untouched serenity.

Apartment in Deadman's Cay Settlement

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Sea Star@Driftwood Beautiful 2 Bed/2 Bath Villa

Forget all of your worries when you step into this spacious and serene space. Master Bedroom features a comfy King Size Bed, 55" Flat Screen TV and Master Bath with Walk in Closet. Spacious Living Area with Comfortable Couches, 65" Screen TV , Dining Table, Home Office & A Fully Stocked Kitchen boasting New Stainless Steel Appliances. Bedroom # 2 has a Full Size Bed & an adjacent Bathroom. Beautiful Back Patio with outdoor dining, bbq grill and Fire Pit.

Guest favorite

A panoramic view of an island features lush greenery surrounding clear turquoise waters. The shoreline blends gently into deeper blue hues, revealing a striking contrast between shallow and deep areas. Small waves create a soft texture on the water's surface under a bright sky.

Guest suite in Long Island

4.76 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Perfect Location & Best Value: Turtle Treasure

The perfect location for exploring Long Island. Situated centrally on the Island close to all the main attractions! Comfortable living space, all the modern amenities, boat rentals, fishing / eco tours and cafe on site! Fully equipped kitchenette, linens, towels and beach towels provided with a limited amount (enough for 2-3 days) of toiletries, toilet paper, and paper towels supplied. Bring your sense of adventure and enjoy a truly peaceful location!

A natural swimming area is depicted, surrounded by rugged rock formations. Clear turquoise water allows for visibility of underwater elements. Sunlight reflects off the surface, casting ripples across the serene environment, suggesting a tranquil spot for relaxation and exploration.

Cottage in Buckley's Settlement

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Cabanya Azul on the Hill w/view of the Atlantic

Cabanya Azul on the Hill - Buckleys, Long Island: This newly constructed cottage has a beautiful view of the Atlantic Ocean to the east & the calming waters on the west side of the Island. Cable TV w/58" inch smart ROKU TV in living room & 50 inch TV's in bedrooms - can use your firestick/roku or any other streaming device. Rental cars are available on the Island, and I can refer you to a couple of places that are nearby.

Guest favorite

A serene beach scene is depicted, featuring soft white sand leading to calm turquoise waters. Lush greenery surrounds a rocky coastline, creating a secluded feel. Clear skies and gentle waves contribute to a tranquil atmosphere, perfect for relaxation.

Home in Long Island

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Two bed/Two bath, Car Included.

Your family will be close to everything when you stay at this cottage. Enjoy your vacation at our 2-bed/2-bath cottage that is centrally located, yet in a quiet neighbourhood, vehicle included. Just a short drive from the airport and minutes away from grocery stores, eateries, and attractions including the world famous Dean's Blue Hole centrally-located place. Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay.

Guest favorite

A covered gazebo offers shaded seating with a bench and table, overlooking calm turquoise waters. Coastal plants frame the space, while a small dog explores the open area. Puffy white clouds drift across a bright blue sky, enhancing the serene seaside setting.

Guesthouse in Long Island

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

The Wild Dilly

Keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located place. This charming property is located just 5 minutes away from the nearest grocery store and offers a quiet and private retreat with a spacious yard and stunning ocean views. Additionally, it is conveniently located just 15 minutes away from the Deadman Cay Airport. Perfect for those seeking tranquility and convenience.

Top guest favorite

A beachside cottage with a thatched roof is illuminated by soft lighting, creating a relaxing ambiance. Adjoining white Adirondack chairs are positioned on the sandy beach. A colorful flag billows gently in the breeze next to a palm tree, enhancing the coastal atmosphere.

Cottage in Long Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Tiny's - Toes In The Sand Sea Grape BEACH Cottage

Bahamas "Clean & Pristine" Certified. Cute little beach club on a quaint family island SEA GRAPE COTTAGE = TOES IN THE SAND VACATION. Close to restaurants and services. You’ll love this place because of the cleanliness, coziness, the location, and views. Tiny's is good for couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, families (with kids), and furry friends (pets).

Condo in Long Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Tangerine Sunsets Long Island Santa Maria

Luxury Beachfront Paradise in Cape Santa Maria, Long Island, Bahamas Escape to a world of unparalleled luxury and natural beauty at our exclusive beachfront vacation rental home in the affluent neighborhood of Galliot Cay on the pristine North of Long Island, Bahamas. Indulge in the epitome of tropical living as you revel in the following highlights:

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

Villa del Sol: The Perfect Island Getaway!

5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews11 months ago

Very clean and comfortable house, strongly recommend for families with kids, absolutely safe. Host helpful, will be back again. We stayed for 2 weeks, really enjoy location and have no complains or concerns. Location is convenient for most of the beaches, food stores/restaurant.

Cottage in Clarence Town

What guests are saying

Entire Home - Private, Tranquil, Ocean Front

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews9 months ago

Beautiful home, very tasteful, clean and private. Can’t say enough positives about Jeremiah’s home on Long Island, Bahamas! Our family had a lovely stay and we highly recommend this home if you need a great place to stay on the island. Thompson Bay/Salt Pond/ McCann area is our favorite area on Long Island. Close to lunch or dinner at Tiny’s, plus there is a terrific grocery store in Salt Pond. Be sure to visit Dean’s Blue Hole, Hamilton’s Cave, and your choice of many Atlantic side beaches. Thank you to our hosts for this stay! We had a question on Day 2, and it was quickly resolved. Prompt response by Jeremiah, thank you!

Villa in McKann's Settlement

What guests are saying

Near stunning Cape Santa Beach, WiFi and Sat TV

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews10 months ago

It was the first time my family and I visited Long Island. We met Docky and Jill and they made us feel at home from the very beginning. Starting from the simplest details of providing, coffee, tea, bug spray, baby oil for mosquitoes to the more complex like taking time out to direct us everywhere on the entire island. The home is equipped with all of the basics even some cooking seasonings. The yard is big and has a beautiful huge tamarind trees. a nice gazebo, grill and the house hilltop view was spectacular. We had true privacy and the neighbors were quiet and kept to themselves. We never saw them..You definitely will need a car to get around especially to restaurants and grocery shopping. It’s located to the very northern tip of the island. The busiest settlement is 45 minutes to the south. We will be back again and will be delighted to book with Bonafide fishing house again. We didn’t do any fishing with Docky because of the rain. We came as visitors and left feeling like locals.

Cottage in Stella Maris

What guests are saying

Large 5 Bed/2 Bath - Unique Stay - The Lodge

4.7 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews11 months ago

We had a great stay here and would return 100%! PROS - Easy check-in and check-out. - Great location - Peaceful, close to the airport and other places, however you will need a car to get around. - Very clean and no clutter inside. Hot showers, lots of towels, large open plan areas. - All AC's worked great and we were all comfortable inside. - Location felt safe. CONS - Not really cons, more things to note. - There is a flight of stairs to enter the apartment. This didn't bother us at all but could be difficult for others to carry cases etc. up the stairs. - The kitchen didn't have power during our stay, however the host kindly offered us one that was just across the hallway which worked great for us. - The outside had great wildlife like money bats, lizards etc. however we did find a small scorpion in some clothes we left outside to dry. Again, this didn't bother us as it's nature and what we came to see! However we felt it was important to write this so others are aware.

Place to stay in Lower Deadman's Cay Settlement

What guests are saying

Little Blue Cottage

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews12 months ago

The place was very clean and beautiful as in the Photos. The surroundings was so peaceful and quite which was really nice. Great location with stores right across the street, that we were able to pickup groceries and souvenirs. The host Monique was superb, she went above and beyond to make sure that our stay was a great one. She assisted us in finding a car rental, some great food and recommended the must visit spots of the island. We definitely will be recommending this location and host to our family and friends, who thinking about visiting Long Island.

Guesthouse in Long Island

What guests are saying

Long Island Villas Available

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews120 months ago

It was a pleasure, to stay at Michaels Apartment in Long Island. Michael did everything that I and my friend had an awesome and chilled vacation. He worked out, that we will get a car over there, which was super nice - since we thought you can just rent it at the airport, but not in Long Island :D So do it beforeor ask Michael :) ! Unfortunately he couldn't be at the house during our stay, but he texted every eveningto make sure we had fun and everything is alright. Thank you so much for that! The accomodation is super nice. There is a ton of space, the kitchen is already equipped, so you don't need to bring anything. Also: His assistant is super nice and friendly, brought us fresh mangos EVERY day (!!!) and some coconuts :) it was great! There are living just around 3000 people on the island, so it is actually VERY unlikely to see a person while you're at the beach, which is actually quite amazing. Thank you so mich for taking care of us! It was an awesome vacation :)

Apartment in Deadman's Cay Settlement

What guests are saying

Peeps Love our Beach Cottage ! April Available !

5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews12 months ago

George is the best! He’s the neighbor you always wanted - friendly, knowledgeable, immediately responsive, welcoming and brings great recommendations. For us, George was particularly helpful in coordinating tours, guides and even helping to check on logistics. He truly made our stay enjoyable and stacked with a ton of memories and provided concierge level service. The cottage was perfect - full of charm and everything you need with nothing you don’t. Great WiFi speeds if you have to work or stay connected, but the beautiful beach and snorkeling 200’ away will keep you out of the house most of the days. Above and beyond, for sure - George is truly a super host and we would highly recommend staying at his cottage…just as long as you don’t book when we want to return!

Cottage in Wemyss Settlement

What guests are saying

Serenity | Away From The Things Of Man... Lat23N.c

5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews12 months ago

Jim aptly named Serenity as it is the essence of a peaceful escape. Why this cabin isn't featured among the top AirBNB's is surprising as I have spent hours pouring over listings to find places as secluded or private as Serenity. Where else can you find miles of beautiful beach with only your own footprints on it? There is one other home about a half mile down the beach but nobody appeared to be there during our stay so we had miles of sand all to ourselves with no prying eyes. The cabin itself was a lovely space, and we had no issues adjusting to solar and found that with even limited sun, plenty of power was produced to run the fan, hotplate, lights, and keep our devices charged. We had no issues with bugs as even light winds seemed to keep them at bay. The kitchen had all the basics and the market is a very short drive, although food prices in the Bahamas are about 3-4X that of the US. My only complaint is that it's difficult to escape the sun and in the morning hours.

Hut in Long Island

1 of 12 pages

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Apartments

Convenient locations with everyday essentials

Houses

A space thats all yours, with room for everyone

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Popular amenities for Long Island vacation rentals

Laptop-friendly workspace

Long Island house rentals

A spacious semi-detached house sits along the beachfront, surrounded by lush greenery. Soft sand leads to clear waters, while the structure features a large porch. The inviting beach area provides direct access to the Atlantic Ocean, creating a serene coastal environment.

Home in Long Island

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Beachfront Home - House Marlin

Guest favorite

Home in Gray's

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Sea Grape Villas

A serene outdoor space features a swimming pool surrounded by lounge chairs adorned with floral patterns. In the background, palm trees sway gently by the sandy beach, with turquoise waters visible under a bright blue sky scattered with clouds.

Home in Wemyss Settlement

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

CASA DE BAHAMAS

Top guest favorite

A covered porch offers a serene view of the ocean and surrounding greenery. Two black metal chairs with soft cushions are positioned for relaxation, inviting moments of contemplation while enjoying the coastal breeze and the vibrant blue waters.

Home in Clarence Town

5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Beachfront Villa - Private beach

A wooden dining table with several matching chairs is set on a tiled terrace, facing the ocean. Palm trees sway gently, providing a tropical ambiance. The blue waters of a swimming pool glisten in the background, while the horizon showcases the expansive ocean view.

Home in Stella Maris

4.65 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

4Bedroom Dolphin House with Pool

The villa presents a modern façade with a spacious entrance, set on a gently sloped lot. Lush greenery surrounds the property, including palm trees and vibrant shrubs. A circular driveway leads to the front entrance, with large windows capturing natural light.

Home in Stella Maris

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Stella Views - stunning 360 degree views

A newly rebuilt home is set among swaying palm trees, featuring a light-colored exterior with stone accents. A well-maintained lawn surrounds the property, and a small garage is visible to one side, complementing the cheerful and welcoming atmosphere of the location.

Home in Stella Maris

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Home living by the Ocean

Show all

Other great vacation rentals in Long Island

Sunset colors reflect on the calm water, framed by palm trees and a thatched-roof gazebo. The beach is visible, with soft sandy shores merging into the serene sea, creating a peaceful ambience for relaxation.

Apartment in Long Island, BS

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

The Crab House On Sunset Beach with Mooring

Show all

Your guide to Long Island

Welcome to Long Island

A literal paradise for divers, anglers, and sailors, Long Island is the hidden gem of the Bahamas. Known as the most scenic island in the entire country, it boasts brilliantly colored coral reefs, picturesque beaches, and oceans teeming with life. Here, island life prevails, dictated by the rolling ocean, with the main activities including sailing, fishing, scuba diving, free diving, and snorkeling. You’ll need a few hours’ rest and recuperation between adventures, probably sunbathing in the balmy temperatures.

This secluded oasis offers 80 miles of lush, untamed greenery and unspoiled sparkling waters. The east coast features rugged cliffs and endless caves, while the quieter west coast offers expanses of white sand and turquoise sea and some of the world’s most beautiful beaches. Adventure awaits divers at Dean’s Blue Hole, the second deepest underwater sinkhole in the world. Foodies won’t be disappointed either: The island’s best-known delicacy, conch, is a delicately flavored seafood available in every form imaginable. Just 45 minutes from Nassau by plane, Long Island offers a laid-back and authentic Bahamian vibe that you can’t help but love.

The best time to stay in a vacation rental in Long Island

Not far above the equator and smack dab in the middle of the Caribbean Sea, Long Island offers warm tropical weather all year long. Temperatures generally stay within a narrow band of warm but not too hot, as is typical of a Caribbean island. Even on “chilly” nights, a long-sleeved shirt will suffice — no need for a winter coat here! The best time to visit for warm-weather activities is between late November and mid-May, while the peak travel season ranges from mid-December to mid-April. The low season is more humid and cloudier, but visitors willing to risk a little more rainfall will find the island even more tranquil than usual. Be aware that the Atlantic hurricane season ranges from June through November. The island does fall within the hurricane belt, although serious storms are rare.

Top things to do in Long Island

Dean’s Blue Hole

Perhaps the island’s biggest draw is Dean’s Blue Hole, the second-deepest underwater sinkhole in the world, which plunges to an awe-inspiring depth of 663 feet. With exceptional visibility, divers will love this paradise with its incredible untouched reefs and vast variety of tropical sea life. Travelers not wishing to descend into the depths can safely enjoy the beauty of the blue hole from the waist-deep surrounding water, and the sheltered nature of the bay makes it ideal for novice swimmers and kids.

Saint Mary the Virgin Anglican Church

For lovers of history, Long Island features the oldest church in the country. Now a romantic ruin, the vast stone building is thought to have been built by the Spanish in the 17th century. The picturesque structure makes the perfect backdrop for an island sunset.

Hamilton’s Cave

The largest cave system in the Bahamas, this complex of passageways, some more than 45 feet wide, features a host of stalagmites, stalactites, and other fascinating rock formations. The caves are also home to a bat colony that comes alive around dusk. The property’s owner provides a guided tour and flashlights to ensure you don’t need to worry about getting left behind in the dark.

Long Island vacation rentals

Top-rated vacation rentals in Long Island

Villa del Sol: The Perfect Island Getaway!

Entire Home - Private, Tranquil, Ocean Front

Near stunning Cape Santa Beach, WiFi and Sat TV

Tranquility. Special pricing going on

Large 5 Bed/2 Bath - Unique Stay - The Lodge

Little Blue Cottage

Blue Cottage

Long Island Villas Available

Peeps Love our Beach Cottage ! April Available !

Grandmothers Cottage

Serenity | Away From The Things Of Man... Lat23N.c

Ocean Front Villa 1/1

Vacation rentals for every style

Popular amenities for Long Island vacation rentals

Long Island house rentals

Other great vacation rentals in Long Island

Your guide to Long Island

Welcome to Long Island

The best time to stay in a vacation rental in Long Island

Top things to do in Long Island

Dean’s Blue Hole

Saint Mary the Virgin Anglican Church

Hamilton’s Cave

Destinations to explore