Lake house vacation rentals in Lake Shelbyville

Find and book unique lake houses on Airbnb

Top-rated lake house rentals in Lake Shelbyville

Guests agree: these lake houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Home in Effingham

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 78 reviews

Haven on the Lake-Swim/Fishing Dock-8 Beds-2 Baths

Location, Location! Beautiful home with lake access for swimming, fishing, and boating on beautiful Lake Sara. Wonderful 2400sq ft house with dock & boat slips & water toys at awesome location for families/friends to relax & enjoy scenery & boating, have fun in the water, grill out, use the game room, or sit by the fire pit or the fireplace. 7 minutes from Interstates 70 & 57. 6 minutes to Walmart. 6-10 minutes to area restaurants. Golf Courses-1 minute to ForeWay & 2 minutes to Cardinal.

Guest favorite

Home in Shelbyville

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

The Vintage Victorian, @ Lake Shelbyville

Make some memories at this unique and family-friendly Vintage Victorian located 1.6 miles from Lake Shelbyville. Our cozy set-up includes three-bedrooms, a relaxing patio overlooking an old brick road, kitchen and spacious dining quarters. The small town is the heart of the Lake Shelbyville. Enriched with historical culture and scenic walking/biking trails, there is something that will capture the attention of your entire family. Located 116 miles from St. Louis and 209 miles from Chicago.

Guest favorite

Home in Decatur

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Cozy 5BR Lakefront House! FirePit, GameRoom, BBQ

Escape to a private haven nestled on the shores of a picturesque lake in the heart of Decatur, Illinois. This spacious lake house is perfect for large groups and offers stunning lake views and ample entertainment space. Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat or a fun-filled getaway, this is the ideal spot for making lasting memories! 3 Minutes to Scovill Zoo 3 Minutes to the Children's Museum of Illinois 3 Minutes to the Chevrolet Hall of Fame Museum 4 Minutes to Overlook Adventure Park

Guest favorite

Home in Shelbyville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

909 & Vine Photo Worthy Home With Pool & Hot Tub

Imagine a luxurious location with versatile design capabilities that convert to your needs. Offering accommodations and VIP services that provide you with all the comforts of home, and then some. Experience a private outdoor space to relax poolside, soak in the hot tub, sit by a fire, or take a peaceful stroll through beautiful gardens and lush grounds. For those days where you want to just stay inside, we offer board games, an Xbox One game console, and 5 TV's with streaming capabilities.

Superhost

Home in Tuscola

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Carico - Isolated, comfortable single family home

A newly remodeled stand-alone home with a private drive will be all yours. Please contact us for exceptions such as long-term reservations out of the availability window, same-day reservations, early check-in, or late checkout. We prefer to host guests with good reviews. Requests from guests with (0)ZERO might be denied solely on this criterion. Tuscola, IL, is the location of one of the busier railroad junctions south of Greater Chicagoland, where UP, CSX, and CN cross the CN together.

Guest favorite

Home in Effingham

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Lake Sara Lake House

Come enjoy our Lake Sara home that is situated on Blue Gill Cove with inviting water from the swimming / fishing dock, electric boat lift for your use, beautiful views and a home with 5 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and an open concept common area. Per the Effingham Water Authority short-term rental ordinance, maximum occupancy is 2 adults (aged 21 and older) per bedroom, with a maximum of 8 adults. This is a 5-bedroom home, so additional guests above 8 adults must be children under the age of 21.

Guest favorite

Home in Effingham

5 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Lakeside SARAndipity: Sleeps 8 w/ outdoor spaces!

Stay on Lake Sara in Effingham with family and friends! Clean, comfortable home renovated in 2020 sleeps 8 people with 2.5 baths & plenty of space. Several outdoor spaces including a large yard, patio, screened-in porch, & a boat dock for swimming/relaxing lakeside. Full kitchen with new appliances & grill included. New beds, furniture, & linens. Full finished basement. Located near several lakeside restaurants & only 15 min from Downtown Effingham! Dock is available to park your boat.

Guest favorite

Home in Sullivan

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Lake Shelbyville-Lakeside Villas

Lake Shelbyville is the perfect place to spend your next vacation, reunion, weekend away you name it! Our property offers amenities shared among the villas; fully stocked pond, half basketball court, fire pits, playground, & backs up to a local popular camping ground, just minutes from the lake and marina! Inside our villas are fully equipped kitchens, washer and dryer, free WiFi, smart TVs, fully stocked with starter amenities to get your vacation started without rushing to the store!

Superhost

Home in Neoga

4.69 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Glampers Corner at Lake Mattoon

Enjoy lake living at Glampers Corner! Conveniently located at Lake Mattoon with private lake access. The GC offers 1100 sf of living space with accommodations of home. No need to haul a camper to enjoy days at the lake. Private lake access 300 yards from the front door restricted to those living on the private drive. Located within walking distance of the campground and marina and less than 1 mile to the public beach. Sit and watch the sunset on the west facing screened porch.

Superhost

Home in Decatur

New place to stay

Relax at the Ridge, Lake, Hot Tub, Views, Fire-pit

Welcome to The Ridge, designed to harmonize with nature and provide a serene escape from the everyday. Perched gracefully on the edge of Lake Decatur, this thoughtfully crafted cabin features stunningly large windows, comfortable sunroom, hot tub with lake views, lounge seating with fire-table, quality furnishings to kick back on and every detail provided with meticulous detail. Located just minutes to Devon Amphitheatre, Zoo, Millikin, ADM, hiking, restaurants and shopping.

Guest favorite

Home in Effingham

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

Lake Me Away

Lake Me Away is a beautiful retreat on Lake Sara. The house, garage & dock provide everything you want in a lake vacation. Situated in a lovely cove that's just across the lake from the public beach, a Marina & Pinky's Restaurant. The house is kept up-to-date with a stunning view of the lake. The all season room is a great space to chill out & the screened in porch makes relaxing a breeze during your stay. The dock is equipped with all the amenities to truly 'lake' you away!

Guest favorite

Home in Effingham

5 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

Boutique Lake-Side Home with Magical Views

Experience this Iconic Mid-Century Modern home with 200+ feet of stunning frontage and a mesmerizing 180-degree view. Step into this meticulous curation of high-end designer furnishings and international art that create a plush, spa-like ambiance filled with love and unparalleled comfort. Reserve this harmonious haven where luxury and nature blend seamlessly. Search "ICONIC LAKE SARA HOME" on YouTube to see an amazing video! Enquire if interested in extending your stay.