Harbour Island vacation rentals

Book unique vacation rentals, houses, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Harbour Island

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A spacious balcony is viewed, featuring a railing adorned with green plants. Beyond, the vibrant blue waters of the bay are visible, along with sandy areas and docked boats. The scene is illuminated by bright sunshine, showcasing the seaside atmosphere.

Apartment in Dunmore Town

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

The Mill Apartment

This 3 bedroom island apartment is a newly renovated space in the center of historic Dunmore Town that has been in my family for 5 generations. Overlooking the bay with a perfect view of the sunset from the living room and balcony. It is conveniently located near the main dock where you will arrive to the island by water taxi or seaplane. Conveniently located near the dock, pink sand beach, cafés, restaurants, and nightlife. The Elbow Room Bar is downstairs and is open Mon-Sat from 4pm-12am.

Guest favorite

A stretch of pristine pink sand beach extends along the coast, meeting calm turquoise waters. Lush greenery lines the beach, with a clear blue sky overhead, creating a serene and inviting coastal scene.

Apartment in Dunmore Town

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Three Little Birds, Sirens Cove Studio Suite

Sirens Cove is a one bedroom one full bathroom one full kitchen suite that is partitioned off from the house “Three Little Birds”. It has its own entry with a porch, King bed, Split A/C, and back-up generator for power outages. The crows nest, yard, parking lot and driveway are shared by the other two suits. The property boarders Ramora Bay Club and Marina for easy access to food and drinks. Also a very short walk to the famous pink sand beach. Quiet, nestled in the woods and not on any roads.

Two palm trees frame a serene view of the calm, turquoise waters reflecting the sky. The sandy beach extends into the horizon, where gentle waves meet the shore. Soft clouds drift above, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere of the beachfront setting.

Tiny home in Dunmore Town

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews

Tiny House Bayfront, 2 Acres, Private Beach Area

On exclusive Harbour Island, a very unique vacation property! Located bayfront on a 40 ft high bluff (just south of Gumelemi Bluff) on the prestigious Narrows portion of the Island, directly on the water. Offering Incredible bay and sunset views from the house and grounds. 300 ft of water frontage. Two acres of TOTAL PRIVACY. Stroll down the easy-graded walkway to the private beach area. Located on Girls Bank sand flats, near the famous LONE TREE. Dunmore Town is less than 1/4 mile away.

Guest favorite

A view from a covered porch overlooks a lush green lawn leading to the tranquil waters of the bay. The scene features a private dock in the distance, framed by trees and soft blue skies, creating a serene outdoor setting.

Vacation home in Dunmore Town

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Sunset Cove

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Beautifully positioned on the Bayside of Harbour Island, the aptly named rental Sunset Cove is an ideal rental for water sports enthusiast with its clear waters and private dock. A wonderfully comfortable home, excellently maintained to a high standard with two king size bedrooms with two bathrooms and separate one bedroom cottage. The large living area, fully facilitated kitchen, and large outside deck are perfect for sunset BBQ evenings

Guest favorite

A sandy path bordered by lush greenery leads to the serene beach. Two lounge chairs are positioned on the sandy shore, facing the tranquil ocean waters that transition from light blue to deep blue under a clear sky.

Apartment in Dunmore Town

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Coastal 1 - 2BR 1 Bath Steps to Pink Sand Beach

Experience island living at its best in our chic and spacious Airbnb on Harbour Island, Eleuthera. Just 3 minutes from the stunning pink sand beach and steps from a full grocery store, this modern retreat sleeps a maximum of 4 persons with 2 Twin beds, a King bedroom, Full Kitchen, Bathroom, and Living room. Enjoy 2 large smart TVs, cozy bedding, and all kitchen essentials. We also assist with golf cart rentals and tours. Relax in style and comfort—your perfect island escape awaits!

Superhost

A welcoming living area features a comfortable sofa with decorative pillows and two armchairs. A glass coffee table sits atop a textured area rug, with a vase of pink flowers at its center. Natural light enters through large windows, enhancing the space's bright ambiance.

Home in Dunmore Town

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Upper Colebrook

Conveniently located, this home in Harbour Island combines privacy and comfort to provide the perfect tropical escape. Just minutes away the famous Pink Sands beach. This 3-bedroom, 2 bath home has a fully equipped kitchen and outdoor space your family is sure to enjoy. Housekeeping; except for Sunday and Holidays. Amenities include: Wi-Fi, smart TV, air conditioning-all bedrooms, and living/kitchen area, BBQ grill, washer/dryer. Ask us about renting a golf cart.

Superhost

An upper deck space features two lounge chairs with colorful patterned cushions, surrounded by a white lattice railing. Tropical trees and a clear blue sky create a scenic backdrop, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere of the outdoor area.

Home in Dunmore Town

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Island Cottage 3 bedroom / 3 bath

Watercolor Cottage in the heart of Harbour Islands historic Dunmore Town. One block from the Harbour and approx. 600 steps from the famous pink sand beach, walk to shops, restaurants and all…. . 3 Bed/ 3 Bath. The bedrooms are separate so WC may not be suitable for families with small children. Lower rate for Main House booking (party of four or less), additional fee is included in your inquiry quote for The Annex (parties of five or six).

Top guest favorite

A spacious deck overlooks the vibrant blue Bahamian waters and lush greenery. Two white, wicker chairs are positioned invitingly, offering a perfect view of the serene beach and sky above. The area is enhanced by the surrounding tropical foliage.

Villa in Dunmore Town

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 56 reviews

Silk Road - Chinatown, Harbour Island

A free standing 1 bedroom beach side villa. Brand new build with old island charm, steps from pink sands beach and views out over the blue Bahamian waters. *Update April 23,2025 we have installed a battery backup system which can power the unit for up to 36 hours in the case of power outages. It is a seamless transition when the power goes out, it doesn't even reset the Internet modem so you'll never even know the power is out.

Superhost

A charming cottage with light blue exterior features a welcoming deck, complemented by two lounge chairs adorned with decorative pillows. The entrance shows a warm light glowing inside, while lush greenery surrounds the space, enhancing the serene atmosphere.

Guesthouse in Dunmore Town

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Flamingo Cottage Garden Retreat

Welcome to Flamingo Cottage, a charming sanctuary on the tranquil Harbour Island. Perfect for a romantic getaway or a solo retreat, this enchanting one-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage invites you to unwind and immerse yourself in paradise. Flamingo Cottage is more than a vacation rental—it’s your personal slice of paradise. Create unforgettable memories and experience the enchanting beauty of Harbour Island at Flamingo Cottage.

A spacious bedroom features a wooden bed framed with woven accents and crisp white bedding. A ceiling fan hangs above, and natural light enters through a window, illuminating the turquoise walls. A doorway leads outdoors, revealing glimpses of a tropical garden.

Cottage in Dunmore Town

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 81 reviews

Family Cottage near Pink Sand Beach! Kid Friendly!

Great family cottage with tropical garden in quiet area. Short walk to pink sand beach and nearby resort. This two bedroom cottage comfortably sleeps 2 adults and up to 2 kids (we have a maximum capacity of 4 people in total). Note that 2nd bedroom accessed by passing through master suite. Enter through well known Romora Bay Resort & Marina. Enjoy their two fabulous restaurants and bar.

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

The Flat, A perfect Island Retreat

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews1 week ago

Spent a lovely week at The Flat, it was absolutely perfect and exactly as described. Great location to be based from, it was easy to get around, very convenient location to operate from as close to restaurants, stores, beach etc. We will definitely be back.

Apartment in Dunmore Town

What guests are saying

Skylights | Golf Cart Included

4.65 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews3 months ago

We stayed at Sha’Nyha’s place for a week and we highly recommend it. Golf cart was waiting for us at Government dock which was super helpful. Our 16.5 year old (licensed) son drove and our 13 year old daughter navigated and we had no issues finding the place (with google maps). The place is bigger in person. The open concept kitchen-dining-living area works really well. Both bedrooms have their own bathrooms and are at the opposite ends of the house which provides additional privacy. The AC units (in every room) work extremely well and keep the house nice and cool. The hammock on the porch was an added bonus. We found the house to be a true five minute walk to the beach and while we almost always took the golf cart in to town, it’s totally walkable. My husband and I jogged to Arthur’s Bakery one morning and walked back. Very doable. We did not meet Sha’Nyha in-person, which would have been nice, but her mom, Simone, came to the rescue a few times and was super friendly and welcoming.

Home in Dunmore Town

What guests are saying

Ma Mimi Cottage

4.5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews13 months ago

Dillan was a gracious host, particularly in light of complicated conditions on Harbour Island. The remoteness of the island means things are more expensive, and they sometimes don't work the way you would expect on the mainland. But that is the beauty of this unspoiled, beautiful place that we are privileged to visit. Dillan's place is well appointed with a good kitchen, washer/dryer, wifi, and two bedrooms with a shared bathroom with tub/shower, and an outdoor shower as well. All the beach towels, too. The location is in the center of town, easy to wak to grocery store, shops, and restaurants. We are grateful to have stayed here.

Home in Dunmore Town

What guests are saying

Chat & Chill #2 Come and Relax !

5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews1 month ago

This condo is wonderful- even bigger and nicer than the pictures capture with tons of deck space. Having a washer and dryer was especially useful. Super convenient to the beach and the host Iris went way above and beyond to make sure we had everything to make our trip perfect (including helping arrange for a golf cart and taxi rides). If you’re considering staying there, do yourself a favor and do it!

Villa in Dunmore Town

What guests are saying

Harbour island Bahamas ocean view

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews126 months ago

Our group rented 3 houses on Harbour Island and this was far and beyond the best house. The living space is huge and very clean, the bedrooms are large and comfy. The house is newly renovated. We had no complaints and everyone was very happy with the stay. We arrived at the airport and took a taxi cab to the "water taxi" which took us to harbour island. (Ask for Juan the water taxi guy, he's great!) Once on the island, we took a cab to the house but learned it's really within walking distance of lots of restaurants and a grocery shop. We also could have walked there from the water taxi had we known the way! This house had the best location for us on the island. Very centrally located. Our only suggestions for traveling to the island are 1) bring water if possible, it's very expensive on the island and 2) expect brief power outages, we had 2 during our stay! Otherwise, we have nothing but good things to say about our stay at the house and the accommodations.

Home in Dunmore Town

What guests are saying

The Sugar Apple Lodging - 1 Bedroom Balcony View

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews13 months ago

Rosita was an excellent host and her space is a great home base for a stay on Harbour Island. The unit is clean, quiet and has all amenities you could need. A well appointed kitchen, comfortable bed, lots of towels etc. It was easy to find and close to several restaurants and bars.

Apartment in Dunmore Town

What guests are saying

Waters Edge

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews2 months ago

This house is so perfect for a group of 4. The outdoor shower was a major highlight. We spent every morning on the deck with coffee overlooking the harbour. Being able to paddle board directly from the house into the harbour is a major flex. LOCATION cannot be beat. I guarantee you that yours friends will be jealous. Needed to text Charise for clarification about the WiFi and she got back to me immediately.

Cottage in Dunmore Town

What guests are saying

Top of The Hill- Portrait room

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews1 month ago

We really enjoyed our stay with Will and Earlyn. The room was very comfortable and the location was an easy walk to the beach and restaurants. Note that you should bring your own toiletries, but they did provide beach towels. The very friendly resident cat was also a plus!

Private room in Dunmore Town

1 of 12 pages