Vacation rentals in Gardner Lake

We were in the area to meet our son's fiance's extended family. Nathania's home was perfect! We had 7 adults and 5 little boys ages 9, 7, 5, 2, and 2 months. There was plenty of space to spread out and enjoy the time together. The hot tub, kayaks, and foosball table were especially popular! We were able to host a family dinner with guests which was wonderful. Everything we needed for preparation was readily available. Lots of beautiful parks, playgrounds, hiking areas. Plenty to keep everyone entertained! Nathania was extremely kind, gracious, and responsive to questions. We had absolutely zero issues. So grateful for a wonderful vacation. Thank you for sharing your idyllic home with us. We hope to visit again!!!

The house is historic and charming. Very walkable to downtown mystic and other activities as described. Wendy and James were amazing hosts and very responsive and helpful. They responded on short notice late in the evening to help me set up an extra bed so that I could be on the main floor with my mother who is handicapped. Would definitely stay here again!

I came here in the dead of winter for a writer's retreat with a fellow writer- AND I WOULD DO IT AGAIN! It was a beautiful and inspiring place to write. Perched on Andover Lake, it was too cold to frolic outside but that was actually liberating. There was a rocking chair-ottoman combo in the master bedroom looking out on the lake and watching it freeze while I worked on some writing was so peaceful and perfect. When I needed to switch it up, there was a writer's desk with the same view and I can not overstate how nice and productive it was to work from it. I am sure in the summer it's a really fun stay (there were kayaks and a dock for swimming) but I actually loved being isolated in such an idyllic place. It's near a few other homes but the road was low traffic enough for a cold weather run around half the lake. Marcie was super helpful with suggestions for places to eat. We didn't actually use the recs - but that only speaks to how nice the house was and how hard it was to leave!

My family and I loved staying at Gail’s place! We grew up in Madison and were back for a visit. It was such a great place and allowed us to re-live many fond memories of growing up in the area!

Had a wonderful time over Easter with my family and dog. The view was exquisite and the house very comfortable. Eileen was very responsive and even had hair dryers sent over. The house was very well equipped with lots of kitchen staple goods. Just be aware there is no microwave, but there is a very nice Breville toaster oven. Also, there is a large table outside for a group, but only a small table and counter seating in kitchen inside. We didn't have any issue since the weather was perfect for us to enjoy our Easter dinner outside. Overall, a beautiful home and only minutes from Greenport and wineries.

June and her bungalow emanated an inviting warmth from the very beginning. My partner and I were looking for a peaceful getaway with our pup, and we were thrilled to see such a beautiful, affordable, pet friendly option by the water. I then saw that it was just 15mins from my grandmother in Waterford, so we would be able to visit with her, too! We exchanged friendly messages right after booking, and I immediately felt confident and comfortable with our decision to stay at her place. June was incredibly thoughtful and seemed to think of everything! She sent a message earlier in the week ahead of the booking to let us know she was preparing for our stay and to share excitement on the beautiful forecast. She was flexible and communicative on check in/check out times, and wished us well throughout her stay. We felt truly at home upon arrival. You can tell this bungalow has been loved and cared for, and that many good times have been shared. Very positive and serene energy. 🌅♥️🐾

It was a perfect spot for our little family vacation. We were so close to a few really nice beaches and the area is a short drive to mystic aquarium and village. Patsy and family are very nice and gave some great suggestions for activities in the area.

What a beautiful place and conveniently located. The house was wonderful decorated, was very comfortable and definitely was a relaxing place to get away. Irina was a wonderful host and the home had many wonderful amenities to offer.