Vacation rentals in Garden City South

Derek was a great communicator from start to finish!!! Beautiful place and location! House was fully stocked with all necessities. Backyard is stunning. Will definitely be back!!

Great, responsive and accommodating host. Very nice, homey place to stay in fire island and enjoy the beach. The house is also very close to the dock for the ferry and water taxi.

Ryan’s place was perfect for my parents to stay for their trip to Northport. The space was clean and comfortable, and the location was very convenient. Ryan was helpful and responsive for their entire trip.

Our stay was lovely. Hope to stay again!

Excellent stay! Hosts were responsive and very helpful. The house is absolutely beautiful, the pictures do not do it justice. The location is perfect and we had a wonderful time. The house was very clean and had beautiful decor. Highly recommend! Five stars one of my favorite and I will definitely be back. Thank you to Susan and Zoe for a wonderful stay.

Very kind and accomodating hosts to my last min disaster with my rental home. 10/10 would reccomend to anyone!!

The place was amazing. I spent here one week with my wife right before the Christmas week and we felt at home. We couldn't ask for a better host. Arthur was extremely reactive, very responsive, flexible and prepared the apartment with some very nice Christmas decorations. We did enjoy our time. I strongly recommend this place and I am sure I will visit Arthur again in the future!

You will be surprised to be able to see the sunrise from your bedroom, have cocktails on a little beach on the brackish Shrewsbury River with windsurfers trying their luck, walk to Bahr's seafood resto or Proving Ground tavern with good beer and food and views -- great location and quiet at night and interesting to watch clammers ride out in their little boats in the morning.

Great space centrally located with a great backyard. Highly recommend!