Fitness-friendly vacation rentals in Fire Island

Great listing, great host. Street below is pretty loud at night even with the windows closed.

Incredible location! Walking distance to the town. The neighborhood is very quiet and we felt very comfortable all weekend long. Carole and Rich are wondering hosts, and the apartment had everything we needed. We would recommend!!

We stayed for one month. It was a pleasant stay. No issues. Everything was as advertised -- no surprises. Would stay again.

Alicia was amazing to work with and extremely responsive! Weather caused changes to my travel plans which created plenty of other stress and she was fantastic to work with to sort out! Very clear and detailed instructions. No questions throughout my stay. She checked in to make sure everything was going well. Primary reason for booking was the proximity to Yale campus. It was perfect, 3 blocks away. Quiet building with helpful residents when asked questions. It is an older building. The unit has some great updates in the kitchen and bath that fit the space and make it more functional and inviting. Will definitely stay again!

This is our second stay at this location. The place is clean and comfortable, and in a great East Rock location. Look forward to another stay.

I Wonderful place, great for couples, I will come back many times,

Very nice and clean place! Comfortable beds, with lots of natural light, and a nice gym for those that use it. Would definitely recommend! There are not a lot of extra towels and coffee cups, so you may need to do a bit of dishes/laundry depending the number of people and length of stay.

I stayed here during a work trip and absolutely loved it! The place was clean and stylish, and had everything I needed for a comfortable stay. The beds were super comfortable, which made a big difference after a long day. The location is ideal. It’s just a short walk to downtown and surrounded by great food options. Check-in was seamless and the host’s communication was clear and helpful the whole time. Would definitely stay here again!

Amazing hosts, very responsive to messages, great place to stay! Decent gym. Supermarket within 5 minutes walking distance.

Great experience

Julie was very responsive and organized host. The place is in the center with complete amenities. I highly recommend her place for anyone visiting New Haven!

Marcela was a fabulous host! She is very thoughtful and we had everything we needed. She also responds very quickly. The place was very clean and efficiently organized. It is a true gem. We would definitely stay again! Thank you Marcela!!!!

Our stay was a wonderful experience. The host was very helpful and accommodating. Would stay here again! 10 out of 10.

If we don't give a good review, can we keep this to ourselves?! Patti was a perfect host; the views were fantastic, whether from the outdoor porch or inside through the French doors looking out on the water. Access to the small beach and pool were excellent and we were close to several good restaurants (many of which Patti suggested, including some on the water) for take-out during the pandemic. Wifi was great and everything was very clean and as advertised. We generally fly for vacations and long weekends but had to stay closer to home this year and this was a perfect choice.

Ildiko was very friendly and proactive. Her place was very clean and in a great location just a few minutes away from downtown Southhampton. She had plenty of linens and towels. The best part were the toys she had which my kids couldn't get enough of! Thank you Ildiko!

I thoroughly enjoyed the condo! It was well within walking distance to downtown, and the building staff was friendly. Would stay here again.

This is a beautiful place to stay! Very clean and pleasantly decorated! Our family felt completely at home. We had everything we needed for our three-day stay. The kitchen was well-stocked, there were plenty of amenities and even a great selection of games that our family enjoyed playing. We were close to a couple of beautiful beaches and a wonderful cozy local coffee shop. Miguel and Kaitlyn are great hosts! Very responsive, helpful and friendly! We would highly recommend their place and would definitely stay again!

My family and I had our Thanksgiving here this year. Unbelievable kitchen. I mean, STOCKED to the brim, I barely had to use anything of my own from my place. We felt super cozy by her fireplace, loved our morning beach walks, and enjoyed her amazing selection of board games upstairs. I have to say that the listing doesn’t capture the sheer SIZE of the home. So much privacy for everyone, and enough comfy gathering spaces to spend time together. Also, the beds were so comfy! We will totally book with them again in the future.

My colleagues and I really enjoyed our stay. Everything was clean and looked just like the pictures. Erna was very proactive and had a great personality.

We loved our stay at Deborah and David's home. The house was perfect for our family, so clean and well equipped. It is even better than on the photos. And what an amazing backyard for the kids!

Victoria was a gracious host - always quick to respond, flexible, and willing to assist. Entire process was easy from start to finish. In my opinion, the house was actually better in person than pictured in the listing. We were happily surprised with the cleanliness and comfort. The garage was a nice added value!

We really enjoyed staying here at Godfrey’s house on Long Island. We highly recommend it! Pictures and descriptions matched well with what we found. Bedrooms were spacious and the multiple living spaces had plenty of room for socializing. Strong Wi-Fi signal throughout the house. Greatly appreciated the well stocked, very clean kitchen and providing towels and linens. Glad that he does not scrimp on the little things like coffee pods, toilet paper, paper towels, and soap! Never had to make a run to a store to get something. Godfrey was also very good at communicating to include rapid responses. Overall, an absolutely wonderful stay for our family and we would want to stay there again.

Juliette’s home was the perfect place for my family to spend a long holiday weekend together. The house is far more spacious than the pictures let on, and with two living rooms there is plenty of communal space plus private corners to retreat to when needed. Everything you could need is readily available and the community is quiet and the perfect setting for a trip out to The Hamptons. I have stayed at many rentals in the area and this was by far one of my favorite stays, I definitely recommend this home to anyone considering a visit.

This is the best stay that I have had since using Air bnb!! The house was clean and felt just like being at home. The decor and the furniture was AMAZING!! My entire family enjoyed our stay. We were able to go for a nice walk and the house is located in the perfect area. It was peaceful and a short walk to restaurants. We will most certainly stay at this location again on our next visit!