Beach house vacation rentals in Bay Shore

This spot is incredible!! Rented it for me, my partner and a few of our friends for my birthday and it was truly a spectacular landing spot!! Robert is very communicative and available about any needs and the view cannot be beat. Will note that while they are pet friendly, they don’t like animals on the furniture and also it is a glitter free space, if you are a sparkly gay like myself, it may not be the space for you!

The apartment was just perfect - spacious , well equipped , super comfortable and the most amazing location. It was great to have the big skies and calm of the ocean boardwalk to start and end busy Manhattan days. Being so close to the A train station was a real bonus and we loved getting the NYC ferry too. Stop and Shop handy and well stocked for groceries and Vino By The Sea has a great selection of wines including some local gems. Couldn’t have asked for a better family stay.

Everything was beautiful. It was exceptionally enjoyable to visit during the off season. We had the whole island to ourselves.

Christina was super responsive and flexible with our check-in time! This was so helpful because we were in town for a wedding. The house was perfect, really nice private neighborhood feel but also walking distance to the main part of bay shore and the water. We really enjoyed our stay and would definitely recommend booking with Christina in the future!

We had a wonderful time staying here! My parents were in town for the weekend and we couldn’t have picked a better spot to stay. Lots of memories were made at this special place. Our host Tami host was just great! She made us feel at home and was very responsive. Will be back again!

We’ve traveled here from Florida to visit Manhattan and family during the holidays. We had such a great time at Dagmara’s beach house. Squeaky clean, newly renovated and equipped with everything you might need. Very well designed and organized place. I’d recommend it to Everyone!

My daughter and I had a lovely stay at this apartment. It was perfectly located to allow us to take a great long walk on the boardwalk in the morning, and was an easy drive to the events we were on Long Island for. Bruce was a great host and very responsive to questions ahead of our stay. We so appreciated the special touches like cookies left for us and a bottle of milk to go with our coffee! Our stay was easy and comfortable we would definitely stay there again.

I highly recommend the Sunset Cottage. The house and property are pristine. John and Lara are super hosts.

It was a wonderful stay. We appreciated how open, bright and private this home is with a gorgeous pool and beautiful grounds. We enjoyed walking down to the bay and into town where everyone was friendly and helpful. Jamie was responsive when help needed with something in the house. It was close to family and friends and felt like home. Thank you Jamie for giving us the opportunity to stay in your home. Good luck in future Frank & Sharon

With all the executive trips I've had to take, this is by far my most favorite place that I've ever stayed at. Their place was clean, cozy, welcoming, inviting, in an amazing location, and had great amenities. My first impression of stepping in with cozy music playing and snacks waiting gave me a brighter disposition on my whole trip after a bad time in the subway. Coming back after exploring NYC each day became part of the experience instead of just a place to rest. I highly recommend it!

We had the most amazing stay at Ashley and David's beautiful home. The architecture was stunning and allowed for lots of natural light to flood the space, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The house is impeccable and every detail was thoughtfully curated. Ashley and David were incredibly kind and responsive hosts. They went above and beyond to make sure our stay was comfortable and enjoyable. Bellport is beautiful and offered plenty of activities and sights to explore. We couldn’t have asked for a better Airbnb experience.

What can I say .. this accommodation is absolutely amazing 😍 so peaceful, relaxing and just such amazing views and the house was incredible, everything is exactly how the photos looked , the pool was amazing, the house was so clean , the bbq was spotless, the fire pit was clean , everything was just amazing from start to finish, I would definitely recommend this place to anybody ! John has been an incredible host and so kind and very helpful all week , welcomed me and my family with a beautiful gift basket on arrival to which shows how much he respects and thinks about his guests and even offered up a meal on him 1 of the nights ! Not much more to say apart from this place is 10/10 , the host is 10/10 ! Will definitely be back in the further without a doubt!

A lovely stay for my brother in-law. Very comfortable with easy check-in and fast communication. Exactly what we needed!

We really enjoyed our stay at Bellport, it was extremely clean! The kitchen/baths were well appointed. The yard is gorgeous and the pool was delightful. Beds were very comfortable and the bathrooms are beautiful. Such a great place!

really nice place and a very friendly and responsive host

This place is amazing!!! Our family of four stayed with two teenagers and it was perfect for everyone to have their own space. The location is great. It’s a short drive to the beach, an hour train ride to the city, or stay home & enjoy the amazing views. All the amenities were luxurious from towels and bedding to the super comfortable beds and the place was spotless which isn’t easy to do next to the water. Our family loved it, it’s one of the nicest places we’ve stayed. I would highly recommend.

We had a great stay for 1 night when we found ourselves in a pinch. Eddie was available for any questions including pre-stay right away and the house was as described in addition to being very clean, spacious, and updated. Would definitely stay again, hopefully for longer next time!

Appreciated Gregory being friendly and thorough, meeting us in person, giving us a tour of the place upon arrival, and the charm factor of this house. The kitchen was very well stocked and usable, there was a lot of community space and a lot of bedrooms and beds, so it was great for our purpose.

House was great! Diana explained everything clearly so I didn’t need to ask any questions. Would definitely stay again!

Had a truly amazing stay! House was exactly as pictured and was perfect for sleeping 8 people comfortably. Perfect location in between the beach and the town. Host was incredibly accommodating and very responsive. Outdoor roof space was perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach. Highly recommend!!

Angelique's home is absolutely charming and located in a lovely neighborhood. We were in town for a race at Jones Beach and loved how quiet and relaxing both her home and neighborhood were. The ground floor was very spacious and comfortable. The kitchen was very well stocked. Upstairs was quite cozy but there is also a bathroom on the main floor so my husband and I each "took" one. The home is very well located with easy access to local restaurants and coffee shops. Highly recommend.

Wally’s place is advertised. More an old school beach house than a luxury stay. A bit no frills, but it certainly had what our group needed, and the location more than makes up for it. The design is a bit unorthodox (kitchen/living room separate from the rest of the house), but worked for us. Make sure you watch the video tour, as it provides a more accurate view of the house than the photos. ACs functioned, grill heated up, speaker connected, and always enjoy an outdoor shower. Easy 5 min walk from the ferry (less if you’re not carrying bags) and even shorter walk to the beach. Really enjoyed Kismet, just a quiet, friendly neighborhood and a nice break from real life. Wally was very responsive, making sure to touch base before check-in and check-out, and we were able to leave our bags on the porch after checkout to get some extra time on the beach, which we certainly appreciated.

We had a great time here and really enjoyed the space! It’s very cute and close to everything you need! Catherine was very responsive and friendly! We definitely plan to stay here again!