Vacation rentals with outdoor seating in Baiting Hollow

We had a terrific stay at this beautiful home for a girls weekend! We had a group of 8 of us and it was more than enough room for all of us to enjoy comfortably! An amazingly huge kitchen it was so easy to make all meals. So private and spacious, the home is furnished so beautifully and we loved being able to sit together at the gorgeous dining table that could fit all of us. Henry the host was incredibly flexible and accommodating, any of the issues we had were addressed asap. He also included a nice guide on things to do in the area, places to eat and where things are located in the home. The driveway parking instructions were very easy we had 6 cars parked with no issues! Beautiful backyard and patio, we wished it wasn't winter so we could have used the pool because it looked so nice. We would highly recommend a visit in the summer! We loved our stay it was such a nice trip in a great area!

Maher’s house was an amazing peaceful experience. I enjoyed my time there and he had great recommendations to restaurants and activities! He was very responsive with all questions we had. I will totally stay here in the future if I can get the chance again!! Thank you Maher!!

Our family opted for a trip to New London to reconnect with our family for Thanksgiving. We were able to utilize the beautiful dining room for our dinner . We loved staying at Rosa’s place and were very comfortable . Just a note - there is only one bathroom and it is on the second floor ( as are all the bedrooms) We made this work but can be difficult with a larger family . It would definitely not deter me from booking again! This place was beautiful. The surrounding area and ease of access was comforting ! Would definitely stay here again .

Aida’s space was large, luxurious and perfect for our two-family getaway. Would book again.

6 of us stayed as a family for a wedding. Plenty of bedrooms and bathrooms for all. Very clean and spacious. My adult kids had fun using hot tub and pool table. We enjoyed the outdoor fire as well. There is a drip coffee maker, but we brought a small single cup brewer because we all like different things to drink. Ice maker in freezer was convenient. Master bed was medium firmness. We brought our 25 pound dog and the back yard is fenced. Walking him in the area was quiet and safe. The listing was about the same cost as getting 3 hotel rooms, but with privacy and extra amenities. We would stay again if we needed to be in the area. Thank you for letting us use your home.

House is perfect. We stayed for a long weekend over Thanksgiving. Perfect location, beds are comfy, fireplace is cozy and host is very responsive and kind.

We had a wonderful stay. Anything you can possibly need for a comfortable getway is available. There were even some drinks & snacks which were greatly appreciated. The home was clean and well stocked with items such as linens, towels, soap, dishes, etc. We also felt safe & right at home in this quiet neighborhood. House is roomy with a great backyard. Robin's instructions were very clear & thorough. Robin was also very friendly & made certain we were comfortable. If we are ever back in town, we would definitely book here again. Thanks again Robin!

We loved our stay here! The place was very warm and comfy (we stayed during winter). We enjoyed cooking in the kitchen and the beds were super comfy. Lovely little homely touches made the place feel like a home away from home. Milford is also a picturesque little town worth exploring.

We had a wonderful stay! Edward and Barb were fantastic hosts. We were visiting friends and needed a comfortable space to relax, sleep, and rest as a family. The bedroom easily fit our daughter’s pack ‘n play, and we enjoyed the spacious living area for playing. When we needed assistance early in the morning (at 6:20 am), Edward was quick to respond and help. We also appreciated the beautiful Christmas decorations and the thoughtful Christmas card they wrote for us.

I booked last-minute for a solo stay, hoping my wife and dog could join mid-week, but logistics didn’t quite work out, but even then was a win/win situation. Bryan was kind, intuitive, flexible, and at ease with my changing plans. And over the next few days, you could see more of how his skills as a contractor, photographer, musician, studio owner, and long-standing good citizen served him in shaping, maintaining, and hosting this place, and offering suggestions about his town and the area. I was carless, but he lent me a good bike, and, walking-wise, it's ten-minute to the Elizabeth Morton Wildlife Refuge. So the main apartment is cozy, private, with its own entrance, doesn't even feel like a part of the main house. Occasionally, I heard a happy dog greet him, or a trace of his gentle guitar, but it was wonderfully quiet overall, especially the yard. The extra cabin with a sauna was a great perk I’d love to enjoy more with family next time.

Our 3 time staying at Amanda’s home. Beautiful and spacious within walking distance to village. Looking forward to coming back next year!

Great spot! Very walkable. It's also a great layout if traveling with small children - there is a separate meditation room upstairs that was perfect for setting up our travel cribs. Would stay again!

Had an absolutely wonderful stay! Location is perfect and Jaime was incredibly friendly throughout!! He let me know that they had everything we would need.. but as a self-described obsessive packer I didnt listen. He wasn't kiding! They had beach chairs, umbrellas, and everything else you need for the perfect beach day. I brought an entire wagon of stuff and used one bag. It really is an awesome little find!!

The apartment is lovely, and we loved being able to use the backyard. Verona is an incredible host and I highly recommend this location if you need to get away for a weekend.

The place is close to Yale where I was working. The area is quiet and safe. Rosaria sets very high standards of cleanliness.

Such a nice peaceful wonderful place. 10/10, definitely recommend.

Great place, exactly as advertised. Terrific location near ferry dock (making arrival/check-in extremely easy and fast, which was a relief after a long trip to get to Fire Island), near the little main hub of Cherry Grove… minutes or less to the general store, restaurants, bars. 5 minute walk to the beach. Although there is some bar noise at night, the unit is well sound-insulated. Hosts extremely friendly and communicative, full of info and recommendations. They take pride in their place and in being great hosts. Cozy place with very good value for Fire Island. The pool was a nice plus - salt water pool, lit at night. Met some of the other residents in the building who were extremely friendly and fun. Bed was very comfy. We slept in a lot. Wi-Fi worked perfectly. Nice desk in the bedroom for the few times work called. Roku TV. Lots of board games Bedroom has AC which worked great. Beach chairs and towels included. Coin laundry on site worked well. Great value. Would definitely return!

The place was quiet, clean and had wonderful heat on a cold winter night. Thank you for the pleasant stay.

Nice place to stay, close to the main highway.

Lovely stay in greenport! Short drive from major north fork activities. Can imagine its even better during the busy season!

Very cute apartment, clean, Lauren was very responsive and helpful!

Such a beautiful condo by the water! Too bad we stayed in November, we would have enjoyed the terrace way more! Mia was so responsive and helpful with my questions prior to the weekend at her place.

Had a wonderful stay with my family. Clean, comfortable, great location. Good communication. Had a little trouble with the front door first day but someone was available quickly to help. A+

Overall relaxing stay and trip to Greenport. Sherri is very communicative and her instructions and listing is clear and accurate. The condo is well decorated and clean and has everything you need for a nice weekend. One thing to note- we were aware check in is between 3 and 5 pm based on the listing (wound up being around 4) but it would be nice for it to be earlier. Still 5 stars though!