Vacation rentals in Arthur's Town

We had a terrific stay at On the Rocks. The location is ideal. Spacious and very comfortably arranged with lots of thoughtful details to make you quickly feel at home. The hosts are wonderful- warm and easy to communicate with. We can’t wait to return.

The place was nice and comfortable only problem was the water pressure but I guess it’s was the neighborhood

We really enjoyed our stay at Baha Mara. It was everything we had hoped for and more. The house itself is spacious and light-filled, well appointed and equipped, with lovely art and nice touches throughout. Comfortable beds and living room space, great kitchen for cooking, large porch for sitting out. We spent a lot of time relaxing on the day beds at water's edge, as well as exploring the tide line and in the water on the SUPs and with snorkels. This was our first visit to Eleuthera, and we found Baha Mara to be perfectly located to venture out to various villages, beaches, restaurants and grocery options not too far from the house. We discovered on our first day that the closest eastside beach, Islandia, is closed to the public pending a sale of the surrounding 466+ acres (!), so we explored a handful of the myriad sandy stretches up and down the coast. We only wished that we had more days to spend and that we had booked a day out on the boat with John/Big Mac Fishing. Next time!

We absolutely loved this beautiful beach house and Fernandez Bay Beach. September is when most restaurants are closed, we were so thankful Jana had such a well stocked kitchen. We did enjoy conch salad at Duke’s twice and delicious dinners twice at Hidden Treasures at Regatta/Cultural Park. Water view out both bedrooms, dining area, living room and back porch was spectacular! Amazing sunrises off front porch over the coconut tree and sunsets from the back porch. Great snorkeling, kayaking and exploring by the rocks in all directions. Cat Island is friendly, natural, uncrowded. Alvernia’s Food Store was great for car rental and the freshest groceries/good selection during our 2 week stay. The Cat Island map made it easy to explore/adventure out each day, great pics! Always nice to be back at the beach house for a swim and outdoor shower! Nice hot indoor showers if rain approached. Definitely planning to return! Thankful to celebrate our 35th Wedding Anniversary at such a special place!

Amanda’s place provides Cat island catharsis. Among the most cherished of travel experiences. Cat Island is remote, and so a real chance to disconnect from the world and restore in Bahamian beauty.

We had a wonderful time at Betty’s ❤️ Beautiful beaches easily accessible, great patio, inspiring views - just what we were looking for:) Would absolutely stay again & highly recommend for long or short stays.

Sandcastle exceeded our expectations in every way. The location was absolutely perfect—just steps from the pristine beach with crystal-clear waters that made for incredible swimming and snorkeling. It felt like a secluded paradise, yet we loved having a restaurant within walking distance for a delicious meal. The home’s open design and large windows filled the space with natural light creating a warm and inviting atmosphere that instantly made us feel at home. It was thoughtfully stocked with everything we needed and more—from a fully equipped kitchen and laundry to comfortable furniture, quality linens, and cozy beds. We made full use of the snorkels, stand-up paddleboard, kayak, and floaties, encountering incredible marine life and discovering hidden beaches which felt like private treasures. Our exceptional hosts enriched our trip with local insights of places and history we’d never have discovered otherwise. Sandcastle was a perfect island retreat—we can’t wait to return!

This place is worth every penny!! The house was clean and comfy with everything you needed. It had a bbq, lovely deck that overlooked the harbour and the dock/tent area along the water was incredible! Having that place to relax in the morning or evening all to our self was worth the stay itself. Shorlette and her husband Joey are fantastic hosts and always there to help. Always so responsive and caring. The location of the place is great as well. We rented a car and we could tour around the island either North or South in less than a hour. Great people, swimming locations, restaurants, grocery/liquor/gas stores all minutes away. Staying here again wouldn’t even be a question, I’d like to live here hahha! Book it while you can, before we book it up again.

We spent two glorious weeks at Fix Ya Face and as we left today we realized…it did fix our faces! Months of stress left us, replaced by smiles and relaxation on our faces. The house, the view, and the location are ideal. It’s a short path to the beach and a short path to Shannas Cove restaurant if you enjoy incredible, unique, chef-designed meals in an intimate setting as we do! The house is very well appointed. We lacked nothing. We’ve explored many of the beaches around the island and you can’t beat the location of this home on Shannas Cove for swimming, safe snorkeling, and walking. There was always something to see! The view from the house is breathtaking. Kelly and Windy are wonderful hosts and we look forward to returning next year!